IMHO it really is irrelevant (within reason) what your BMI is (or any other measure involving looking purely at the body weight), because different people have different frames and muscle structure which makes these types of indices more or less useless unless you fit neatly into the average type.
What's much more important than BMI is percentage body fat, where men shoud ideally be no more than 20% of body weight. For example, my ideal body weight (5'11") is apparently around 170lb according to the chart above, but that's my lean mass already (checked using Tanita BF scales and a much more sophisticated machine a while before) without any body fat at all, which is obviously impossible. So I can still be very, very fit (say, 11% body fat) and I will still be overweight according to normal body weight indices, which is why I take them with a grain of salt.
Conversely, you can be underweight according to BMI but still be a porker, if you have narrow bones and very little muscle.