• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

AI Generated Music

That is a fair test, especially for a live band. A track can sound convincing in headphones, but the arrangement has to survive real players, timing and the room before it feels like a song rather than a production.
 
As I've said before I have very mixed feelings on it, hate AI slop where no care was take in generating and where applicable producing it or where people are trying to pass off AI generation as their own work, but some people are producing some good stuff with it.

I had a laugh a few days ago hearing one of the AI generated theme tunes one streamer I watch uses blasting out from a passing Iceland delivery vehicle heh.

Copyright, etc. wise it depends for me how much is a model learning abstractly from being fed existing works - because at the end of the day that is basically almost all music out there* or whether it is regurgitating recognisable pieces of existing music.

* So much modern music directly or indirectly has been influenced by the likes of Vangelis, Tangerine Dream, etc. etc. and they in turn you can find in their music inspiration from older composers, etc.

EDIT: Most of the AI models have turned to **** anyhow now for music - several sites were taken out or neutered into something completely pointless due to copyright, Suno has killed off all their old models and replaced it with a "sanctioned" model (V6) which isn't great with lots of shimmering and smush and sounds like you are listening to the music with cotton wool in your ears and most of the Chinese models, etc. aren't that great and often just slamming together a bunch of pieces of existing tunes and adding filters over the top to hide the ugliness.
 
Last edited:
So I recently got caught out again.
I have a liking for traditional music heavied up and if anybody has heard The Hu from Mongolia you'll get what I mean.
Somebody told me to give these a listen and after about 10 videos I thought something isn't right.
Everything is AI but I now feel dirty for really enjoying it :(

And before somebody says "Didn't you notice the AI on the video?" no I didn't because I'm usually doing another two things at the same time.

 
Last edited:
I mean it sounds exactly like an overproduced suno track, the vocals are a massive giveaway.

The day AI spawns an artist comparable to someone like Aphex Twin or Bjork etc in terms of uniqueness and creativity is the day I'll be impressed/worried.
 
Last edited:
I mean it sounds exactly like an overproduced suno track, the vocals are a massive giveaway.

The day AI spawns an artist comparable to someone like Aphex Twin or Bjork etc in terms of uniqueness and creativity is the day I'll be impressed/worried.

Yes like I said I'm normally doing three things at once so while doing jobs it was on in the background until I twigged.
While typing this I have a guitar in my hand while watching Neagley.
 
I got caught out twice on Friday, both albums recommended by roon / Qobuz. One was by Pendragon (yeah right) and the other by Marcus King (has he had a sex change?). On further listening the tizzy distortion in the vocals really gave them both away.
 
The day AI spawns an artist comparable to someone like Aphex Twin or Bjork etc in terms of uniqueness and creativity is the day I'll be impressed/worried.

"Production" quality aside if someone spent enough time on the prompting it is possible(ish) albeit a lot of the models are now being shackled :( Suno V6 falls back to a much more limited variation of generic rhythms, etc. one of the issues there though is if someone understands music theory to that level they can develop prompts that complex they almost certainly have the skills, training and likely the equipment to produce better manually.

Suno V6 is pretty poor though - for 10 similar prompts you will get 10 almost if not just variations of the same thing and the quality is like listening to a 56kbit MP3.

Everything is AI but I now feel dirty for really enjoying it :(

I don't hate it, though it is pretty generic and at times the AI shows through, but at least it isn't fire and forget AI slop.
 
I hate it. Music is an expression of human creativity, drawing from the artist's human life experience. AI music is and always will be awful, meaningless slop.
 
I hate it. Music is an expression of human creativity, drawing from the artist's human life experience. AI music is and always will be awful, meaningless slop.

I was at a pub the other week and a friend asked if I'd heard of a certain band because he couldn't stop listening to them.
During a break from singing I was outside so checked out this band and from my small screen they sounded OK.
I went back in and said I've had a listen to 3 songs and they're very good, not my cup of tea but still very good.
He said "Yeah, it's better than any real stuff out at the moment" :eek:
 
Not entirely sure if this is relevant in this topic but I saw something on an instagram reel at the end of last week I think regarding AI generated music over in Germany.

The Munich Regional Court ruled on Friday that Suno AI, a US-based company, which generates songs from text prompts. has violated copyrights and has to disclose illicit revenues.


The lawsuit initiated in January 2025 by GEMA, Germany's state-mandated licensing agency, argued that Suno trained its AI models on copyrighted music without obtaining licences or compensating its rights holders.

 
Not sure what they mean by illicit revenues.

I think a distinction has to be made personally between AI models trained on copyright material to build an understanding of music (which is basically what people do anyway) or trained on copyright material to then reproduce (regurgitate) it in recognisable form. Because if you train an advanced enough model on enough non-copyright material it will eventually start to produce stuff similar to existing copyright material - and then you'd have to train it (or another model which analyses the output) on the copyright material to be able to detect and filter out generations which conflict with existing copyright material LOL.
 
Last edited:
I like to listen to blues guitar on Spotify as a sort of background when I’m wasting hours at the PC processing my Astro images.
For the past few weeks I’ve been “listening” to some very good slow blues guitar when tonight I decided to look up the label that most of it seems to come under.
It was a label I’d not heard of before, called Crossroads records and it hit me like a thunderbolt that I’d been listening to AI blues guitar for weeks!
I know that I shouldn’t be listening to it but it’s bloody good background music!
 
I was listening to a 3 hour compilation of Mississippi Delta blues the other day and knew instantly the moment the video rolled over to the next, which was AI, based on how generic it was. To be honest I find the very idea of a machine that experiences and feels absolutely nothing, writing a song about how hard everything it hasn't lived is, insulting. In the same way I'm not going to listen to some fake country singer tell me about blue jeans shorts, ice cold beer, pickup trucks and cowboy boots. I prefer when my country musicians had crippling addiction problems and wrote about that experience and the hell they were in.

Another one is drum and bass mixes. You can spot the AI generated drum and bass mixes easily since they use the same generic asian woman / anime woman / playstation 1 disc art cover style as they try to evoke nostalgia for a time and place they never lived, and as for the music, it is so horrifically bland. One of the channels had a "release" page where in the last 6 months they've released several albums and several EPs and over 60 individual tracks total. So I decided to check out their release with the most number of songs (19 in total). What I think has happened is they've prompted an AI to generate a "mix" and then badly cut it into individual tracks that make no sense for anyone who knows the genre. The first 8 bars of the "tracks" are so similar it's hilarious.

It's all soulless trash in my experience.
 
Last edited:
So a few months ago a bloke came back into my life who I knew from the Glam Rock scene in the 90s.
I started to hear some of his recordings and was very impressed.
He has just released his latest album which is the second video and I was about to talk to him about his recording process and if he had used local musicians to help when I realised every single bit of it is AI :eek:

The first video is with film to show his talents but then again it's all AI but that is his voice.
I really don't know what to think because no matter how you weigh it up it's AI but shows what amazing stuff you can do with it if you know what you're doing


This is his album just released.


This is his Christmas Single with video -


Anyway over to you to judge.
 
My Youtube Music has been overrun with suggestions of some of this stuff. Whilst I enjoy the odd track they do feel a bit off
 
Back
Top Bottom