Well i thought I would bump this, Considering I've only just started to play it...
Its good, It's very eerie, and my nerves are pretty shot after a session on it last night. I love scary games, After Resident evil took a turn towards the more action packed gaming, Silent Hill was my only saving grace.(Dead Space is brilliant too, but Didnt rate the sequel)
So now after playing Alan Wake I can say for definite I can add another Survival Horror game to my list.
I mean the way I play the game is probably why I find it so damn scary, I explore. I run away from the lights, into the darkness looking for extra items. And its while doing this that I can tell you now, It's horrible. haha. I can imagine people who stay with in the lights, or run from 1 light to another all game, will find the game somewhat less scary.
but It gets a thumbs up from me.