Alternative top 100 list

GIBURROWS

GIBURROWS

GIBURROWS

Soldato
Joined
13 Jan 2010
Posts
5,247
Location
The 'Shire'
As PC Gamer seem to have forgotten about many games for what reason or another I would like to make another list and base it on hours played as surely that is the best way to rate a game?
 
Hours played?

What of Portal? FEAR? Monkey Island? loads of other single player, story driven, non-open world games?

Championship/Football Manager isn't the best game ever. But it would rate pretty high on that measure.
 
I think everyone should put their top 10. And that will give points to games.

For examples.

1st position 10 points
2nd 9 points...
etc

Then sum up and thats it... I dont know if we will reach top 100 but just to have an idea of the forum opinion..
 
smogsy said:
best way is an average of user rating of thousands of people
Click to expand...

I'd probably argue against that too.

Just look at the IMDB movies list. Dark Knight at 4, Fellowship of the Ring at 9, Forest Gump at 14. All ahead of Psycho (32), Alien (49), The Shining (56).

And Citizen Kane at 65!

My list of favourite films includes some rubbish, and excludes many genuine classics. Because I am a neanderthal, and my opinion is extremely flawed.
 
Martink137 said:
I think everyone should put their top 10. And that will give points to games.

For examples.

1st position 10 points
2nd 9 points...
etc

Then sum up and thats it... I dont know if we will reach top 100 but just to have an idea of the forum opinion..
Click to expand...

I concur, feel free to add your top tens....
 
  1. Sleeping Dogs
  2. Deus Ex: Human Revolution
  3. Metro 2033
  4. Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
  5. Mafia 2
  6. Hitman 2 Silent Assassin
  7. Bioshock Infinite
  8. Mirror's Edge
  9. Hotline Miami
  10. Trine 2

Adjusted ^^
 
Last edited:
cheesyboy said:
Hours played?

What of Portal? FEAR? Monkey Island? loads of other single player, story driven, non-open world games?

Championship/Football Manager isn't the best game ever. But it would rate pretty high on that measure.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Many of my favourite games are single player and can be finished in a no. of hours.
 
My Top 10

1)CS
2)Ultima Online
3)GTA III
4)Quake
5)Comand and Conquer red Alert
6)Agre of Empires 2
7)Diablo II
8)Civilization II
9)Unreal Tournament 99
10)Grim Fandango

All quiet old video games, but well, these are the games I grew up with...

Notes: I would have added Final Fantasy 7, but I consider it a Console Game and I dont know if the intention is only PC.
 
100.Unreal Tournament
99.Unreal Tournament
98.Unreal Tournament
97.Unreal Tournament
96.Unreal Tournament
95.Unreal Tournament
94.Unreal Tournament
93.Unreal Tournament
92.Unreal Tournament
91.Unreal Tournament
90.Unreal Tournament
89.Unreal Tournament
88.Unreal Tournament
87.Unreal Tournament
86.Unreal Tournament
85.Unreal Tournament
84.Unreal Tournament
83.Unreal Tournament
82.Unreal Tournament
81.Unreal Tournament
80.Unreal Tournament
79.Unreal Tournament
78.Unreal Tournament
77.Unreal Tournament
76.Unreal Tournament
75.Unreal Tournament
74.Unreal Tournament
73.Unreal Tournament
72.Unreal Tournament
71.Unreal Tournament
70.Unreal Tournament
69.Unreal Tournament
68.Unreal Tournament
67.Unreal Tournament
66.Unreal Tournament
65.Unreal Tournament
64.Unreal Tournament
63.Unreal Tournament
62.Unreal Tournament
61.Unreal Tournament
60.Unreal Tournament
59.Unreal Tournament
58.Unreal Tournament
57.Unreal Tournament
56.Unreal Tournament
55.Unreal Tournament
54.Unreal Tournament
53.Unreal Tournament
52.Unreal Tournament
51.Unreal Tournament
50.Unreal Tournament
49.Unreal Tournament
48.Unreal Tournament
47.Unreal Tournament
46.Unreal Tournament
45.Unreal Tournament
44.Unreal Tournament
43.Unreal Tournament
42.Unreal Tournament
41.Unreal Tournament
40.Unreal Tournament
39.Unreal Tournament
38.Unreal Tournament
37.Unreal Tournament
36.Unreal Tournament
35.Unreal Tournament
34.Unreal Tournament
33.Unreal Tournament
32.Unreal Tournament
31.Unreal Tournament
30.Unreal Tournament
29.Unreal Tournament
28.Unreal Tournament
27.Unreal Tournament
26.Unreal Tournament
25.Unreal Tournament
24.Unreal Tournament
23.Unreal Tournament
22.Unreal Tournament
21.Unreal Tournament
20.Unreal Tournament
19.Unreal Tournament
18.Unreal Tournament
17.Unreal Tournament
16.Unreal Tournament
15.Unreal Tournament
14.Unreal Tournament
13.Unreal Tournament
12.Unreal Tournament
11.Unreal Tournament
10.Unreal Tournament
9.Unreal Tournament
8.Unreal Tournament
7.Unreal Tournament
6.Unreal Tournament
5.Unreal Tournament
4.Unreal Tournament
3.Unreal Tournament
2.Unreal Tournament
1.Unreal Tournament
 
1) Command and Conquer red Alert 2
2) Championship Manager 01/02
3) Skyrim
4) Battlefield 1942
5) LFD2
6) Sim City Deluxe
7) Arma 2 (Dayz & Epoch Mod)
8) Battlefield 2
9) Starcraft 2
10) Rollercoaster tycoon
 
1. Half-Life
2. Discworld
3. Myst
4. Magic Carpet
5. Little Big Adventure
6. Desert Strike
7. Duke Nukem 3D
8. Max Payne
9. Red Alert
10. Total Annihilation
 
1) Championship Manager 01/02
2) Minecraft
3) Transport Tycoon Deluxe
4) XCOM - UFO Defense
5) Half Life
6) Company of Heroes
7) Counter Strike
8) Geoff Crammonds Grand Prix
9) Panzer General II
10) Skyrim

(The oldies are the best!)
 
1) CSS
2) CSGO
2) Half Life 2
3) World of Warcraft
4) SWTOR
5) Minecraft
6) Team Fortress 2
7) Portal
8) Garrys MOD
9) Star Wars Battlefront 2
10) Farcry
 
If it were by hours played about three CoD games would make up three of my top five. Not because they're such good games, but because they're easy to jump into and mess around in for an hour or two every now and then.
 
1) Oblivion
2) Skyrim
3) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
4) Metro 2033
5) Mirror's Edge
6) Crysis 3
7) Tomb Raider
8) Minecraft
9) Portal
10) Gears of War

Subject to change, as I remember other games.
 
PC only or can I add other formats? :)

PC wise:

1. Asherons Call
2. Fallout 3 GOTY
3. Skyrim
4. System Shock 2
5. Dungeon Keeper 2
6. Freelancer
7. Max Payne 2 (purely for the storyline - shame the 3rd sucked)
8. Batman: Arkham Asylum
9. Beyond Good & Evil
10. Little Big Adventure 2

Changes every day depending on my mood though :)



M.
 
I do not think hours played is best way to rate a game as not all genres have long play times or multiple replays value.

Example, I played Max Payne 1 and 2 twice each but will not again (2 of best gamers ever).
 
Last edited:
Eames said:
100.Unreal Tournament
99.Unreal Tournament
98.Unreal Tournament
97.Unreal Tournament
96.Unreal Tournament
95.Unreal Tournament
94.Unreal Tournament
93.Unreal Tournament
92.Unreal Tournament
91.Unreal Tournament
90.Unreal Tournament
89.Unreal Tournament
88.Unreal Tournament
87.Unreal Tournament
86.Unreal Tournament
85.Unreal Tournament
84.Unreal Tournament
83.Unreal Tournament
82.Unreal Tournament
81.Unreal Tournament
80.Unreal Tournament
79.Unreal Tournament
78.Unreal Tournament
77.Unreal Tournament
76.Unreal Tournament
75.Unreal Tournament
74.Unreal Tournament
73.Unreal Tournament
72.Unreal Tournament
71.Unreal Tournament
70.Unreal Tournament
69.Unreal Tournament
68.Unreal Tournament
67.Unreal Tournament
66.Unreal Tournament
65.Unreal Tournament
64.Unreal Tournament
63.Unreal Tournament
62.Unreal Tournament
61.Unreal Tournament
60.Unreal Tournament
59.Unreal Tournament
58.Unreal Tournament
57.Unreal Tournament
56.Unreal Tournament
55.Unreal Tournament
54.Unreal Tournament
53.Unreal Tournament
52.Unreal Tournament
51.Unreal Tournament
50.Unreal Tournament
49.Unreal Tournament
48.Unreal Tournament
47.Unreal Tournament
46.Unreal Tournament
45.Unreal Tournament
44.Unreal Tournament
43.Unreal Tournament
42.Unreal Tournament
41.Unreal Tournament
40.Unreal Tournament
39.Unreal Tournament
38.Unreal Tournament
37.Unreal Tournament
36.Unreal Tournament
35.Unreal Tournament
34.Unreal Tournament
33.Unreal Tournament
32.Unreal Tournament
31.Unreal Tournament
30.Unreal Tournament
29.Unreal Tournament
28.Unreal Tournament
27.Unreal Tournament
26.Unreal Tournament
25.Unreal Tournament
24.Unreal Tournament
23.Unreal Tournament
22.Unreal Tournament
21.Unreal Tournament
20.Unreal Tournament
19.Unreal Tournament
18.Unreal Tournament
17.Unreal Tournament
16.Unreal Tournament
15.Unreal Tournament
14.Unreal Tournament
13.Unreal Tournament
12.Unreal Tournament
11.Unreal Tournament
10.Unreal Tournament
9.Unreal Tournament
8.Unreal Tournament
7.Unreal Tournament
6.Unreal Tournament
5.Unreal Tournament
4.Unreal Tournament
3.Unreal Tournament
2.Unreal Tournament
1.Unreal Tournament
Click to expand...

I disagree with the order of your list it should read like this...

101.Unreal Tournament
100.Unreal Tournament
99.Unreal Tournament
98.Unreal Tournament
97.Unreal Tournament
96.Unreal Tournament
95.Unreal Tournament
94.Unreal Tournament
93.Unreal Tournament
92.Unreal Tournament
91.Unreal Tournament
90.Unreal Tournament
89.Unreal Tournament
88.Unreal Tournament
87.Unreal Tournament
86.Unreal Tournament
85.Unreal Tournament
84.Unreal Tournament
83.Unreal Tournament
82.Unreal Tournament
81.Unreal Tournament
80.Unreal Tournament
79.Unreal Tournament
78.Unreal Tournament
77.Unreal Tournament
76.Unreal Tournament
75.Unreal Tournament
74.Unreal Tournament
73.Unreal Tournament
72.Unreal Tournament
71.Unreal Tournament
70.Unreal Tournament
69.Unreal Tournament
68.Unreal Tournament
67.Unreal Tournament
66.Unreal Tournament
65.Unreal Tournament
64.Unreal Tournament
63.Unreal Tournament
62.Unreal Tournament
61.Unreal Tournament
60.Unreal Tournament
59.Unreal Tournament
58.Unreal Tournament
57.Unreal Tournament
56.Unreal Tournament
55.Unreal Tournament
54.Unreal Tournament
53.Unreal Tournament
52.Unreal Tournament
51.Unreal Tournament
50.Unreal Tournament
49.Unreal Tournament
48.Unreal Tournament
47.Unreal Tournament
46.Unreal Tournament
45.Unreal Tournament
44.Unreal Tournament
43.Unreal Tournament
42.Unreal Tournament
41.Unreal Tournament
40.Unreal Tournament
39.Unreal Tournament
38.Unreal Tournament
37.Unreal Tournament
36.Unreal Tournament
35.Unreal Tournament
34.Unreal Tournament
33.Unreal Tournament
32.Unreal Tournament
31.Unreal Tournament
30.Unreal Tournament
29.Unreal Tournament
28.Unreal Tournament
27.Unreal Tournament
26.Unreal Tournament
25.Unreal Tournament
24.Unreal Tournament
23.Unreal Tournament
22.Unreal Tournament
21.Unreal Tournament
20.Unreal Tournament
19.Unreal Tournament
18.Unreal Tournament
17.Unreal Tournament
16.Unreal Tournament
15.Unreal Tournament
14.Unreal Tournament
13.Unreal Tournament
12.Unreal Tournament
11.Unreal Tournament
10.Unreal Tournament
9.Unreal Tournament
8.Unreal Tournament
7.Unreal Tournament
6.Unreal Tournament
5.Unreal Tournament
4.Unreal Tournament
3.Unreal Tournament
2.Unreal Tournament
1.Unreal Tournament
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom