Is that a sunflower or super flower pus?
Not heard of sunflower.... If it's a cheap pus, it may not matter if it is 'rated' at 750w.
Also, you are a little quick to dismiss certain possibilities. Just because reviewers had no problems with more volts and temps on that board, doesn't mean it won't necessarily be the problem. Not all electronics are created equal.
Also, CPUs don't always clock the same on different boards. So it is quite feasible more volts may be required than your previous.
Same goes for ram. Just because it ran 2400 on previous doesn't mean it will do same here.
It's entirely possible that you may have reached limit of what that CPU/board/memory combo will do.
Forget about what you got fom previous board - as you are no longer using it...