• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

ATI 4850 or 4870

Associate
Joined
23 Aug 2006
Posts
264
Location
North Wales
Hi i am thinking of geting a new card as mine has just died :mad: (ATI 2900XTX)

I was thinking of either a 4850 1Gig or 4870 1Gig.

Is there really much difference in the two apart from price? and what would be the best buy.
I am in the middle of playing fallout 3 at the moment which i want to get back to. So i need to know what would be the better card.

Thanks.
 
for 1680x1050, an overclocked 4850 512mb will do VERY well in most games, yes you might not get 8xaa, but 2xaa and max settings in most games at that res and it should be pretty damn good, at £100-110, its a massive saving tbh and easily a better value card.

The other cards are faster, theres no question of that, but so what. Have a look through reviews, see what games can't be played in relatively high settings with that card, basically Crysis and 1-2 others, which will also not play great on the 4870 or a 260-216 either.

You will 100% gaurenteed NOT see a what, 70-80% performance bump from a 4850 to either of the other two cards mentioned at that resolution at all. 4850 is easily the best choice.

If you're likely to get a newer higher res tft in the next 4-5 months then "maybe" one of the other cards would be a good idea, but for now, no way in hell frankly.

http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/graphics/2008/11/28/gigabyte-gv-r485mc-1gh-radeon-hd-4850-1gb/5

hard to actually find reviews as far to many sites are leaving off everything under a 4870 these days. But mostly, it offers more than playable performance and thats with 4xaa, thats about the level the card will start to struggle(0 to 2xaa shows a massive difference in image quality whiel 2-4x and 4-8x show ever decreasing differences anyway), at 2xaa it will be pushing 60fps average, and 45fps min, in one of the harder new titles.

If it were 1920x1200 and call it 2xaa minimum I probably wouldn't buy less than a 4870 and a 1gb version at that now, but for 1680x1050, you can save a lot of cash for very good performance.

EDIT:- its also worth bearing in mind that, that review used 8.10's and we've seen across the range increases in recent drivers, and lots of reviews will use older numbers added in rather than retest, so newer better drivers will likely only mean you get slightly better performance, sure across all cards, but it means the minimum performance of the 4850 should be even better and more playable in more games.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom