• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Ati 5850 or 5870?

Soldato
Joined
24 Aug 2009
Posts
2,931
Hello, sorry for another "oh which one" thread. On the 29th of this month, I get a nice paypacket of £250 and want to change my graphics card. I bought my 4890 around 3 months ago, becasie I said "DX11 will just be shambles so no point", but now I know its not! I play Dirt 2 a lot and will want to play the upcoming games that will run on Dx11. So my plan is, sell my 4890 around 29th and should get atleast £90 for it, and that leaves me with £340 in the hand.

I have had a look at reviews on both cards, and not sure what to do. From what I can search in google, I can pick up the 5850 for around £220 and pick up the 5870 for around £300. Now my point is, should I get the 5850 or the 5870. If I get the 5870, I know I won't need to cf them, as they run dirt 2 very well etc, but with the 5850, I would have to cf, but not sure?

My system specs:
Core i7 860 @ 3.6ghz
4gb Viper 5 2000mhz
Crucial 128gb SSD
Samsung F3 500gb
850w Corsair Hx PSU
Asus Max Formular 3
Corsair 800D

I know the board can run it crossfire no problem, and can't detect any "bottle necks". Any help guys :D

Thanks.

B
 
Last edited:
What resolutions do you play at?

Difference between a 5850 and a 5870 is 10-15% but the price is 40% more.

Imo the 5850 is the winner assuming you can get a hold of one.
 
The 5850 is cheaper, both in real terms and bang-per-buck, quieter, cooler and draws less power. Unless you are desperate to play the very latest games at the highest settings and with huge framerates, I think it probably makes more sense to get a 5850 right now.
 
Prices for these cards has creeped up over the past few weeks due to lack of supply. Which enabled e-tailers to apply whatever mark up they wish on these cards, knowing people are still looking to buy and upgrade before Xmas.

I would personally wait until after the new year for fresh supplies to come in. Prices should be at a more reasonable level since the festive shopping madness will be over by then.
 
Sorry guys for not replying, I had internet issues.

From what I can read, there is around 10fps difference in dirt 2 when playing the game on max settings. (Atm, I'm playing on 1680 x 1050 rez, but will be moving to a 24"ips Hp montior that has 1920 x 1200) I am going to go with the 5850, and then crossfire them around 2 months later, then I won't touch them for a while. I believe they can overclock like mad? If they do, which brand/make should I get. I've been reccomended the Xfx 5850 by a friend that said "get the xfx version, they have the best RMA service". Any one comment on this?

Thanks for your views, and will be purchusing a 5850.

B
 
Sorry guys for not replying, I had internet issues.

From what I can read, there is around 10fps difference in dirt 2 when playing the game on max settings. (Atm, I'm playing on 1680 x 1050 rez, but will be moving to a 24"ips Hp montior that has 1920 x 1200) I am going to go with the 5850, and then crossfire them around 2 months later, then I won't touch them for a while. I believe they can overclock like mad? If they do, which brand/make should I get. I've been reccomended the Xfx 5850 by a friend that said "get the xfx version, they have the best RMA service". Any one comment on this?

Thanks for your views, and will be purchusing a 5850.

B

Good choice!
 
Back
Top Bottom