B&W PX, Bose QC35, Sony MDR, or Bose QC30

Soldato
Joined
1 Jul 2007
Posts
21,522
Location
Various
I've had the Bose QC20 for a couple of years and they've been excellent, but the wire seems to have an issue (if you shift it at all the music cuts out). I'm therefore after a wireless replacement.

I really like their small size, but understand that the QC30 only has a battery life of 10 hours or so, which is not long enough for a long flight, so I'm probably ruling them out.

My use case is daily on the tube and at work (maybe 3-4 hours a day), and also for long-haul travel (I'll go on a holiday or two each year requiring a 10+ hour flight, plus transport either end).

The other three are a very similar price. I expect them all to sound good (although they'll have different sound signatures, I appreciate), so really my consideration comes down to:

1. Noise cancelling - the more it drowns out the tube the better!
2. Comfort and fit - I understand the B&W are the least comfortable? This is really important to me, does anyone have experience of this?
3. Controls - I really like the idea of the B&W controls, allowing the music to pause when you lift an earpiece etc, but does it work in practice?
4. Battery life - the longer the better, but as long as it's over 18-20 hours I'm happy with anything
5. Durability - having spent £260 on my last pair of Bose headphones I'm disappointed that they only lasted two years (and are just outside their warranty, although I may go into the store for an argument)
6. Other nice to haves - I like that the B&W charges with USB-C. Size is important as well (ideally the smaller the better), but not a dealbreaker

In short, I really like what B&W have attempted to do, but worry that the lift on/lift off controls won't work brilliantly, and that the comfort will be poor. I like the look of them the most of the three, but that's not as important as comfort and quality of noise cancelling.

Does anyone have experience of these headphones? I can find lots online about the Bose and Sonys, but much less on the B&W.
 
Thanks for all your replies everyone! I think I'm probably going to go for the rev 2 Sony set, although still haven't quite made my mind up. I'd like to see them and the B&W in the flesh (I've tried the Bose ones already)
 
I had a look at all 3 in John Lewis today. For me, the Bose sounded notably worse. The B&W have a really lively sound and wide soundstage. Weirdly, I found the Sony least comfy, and the Bose most comfy. The Sony had the best NC.

There are a few more considerations:
1. How long is the warranty on the rev 1 Sony?
2. A midpoint is the rev 1 Bose at around £280, and it only lacks Google Assistant.
 
I think I'm leaning towards the MK1 Bose, although they sound so boring compared to the Sonys. They're much more comfy (based on my trial in store and the size of my head!), and not too horribly priced!

That said, I'm almost leaning back to the QC30s. How easy is it too plug a Bluetooth dongle into a plane entertainment system? That's the only thing holding me off of buying them
 
Found the QC35 MK2 for £275, which alongside their comfort swung it for me over the others. They'll be arriving tomorrow! Thanks for all the replies :)
 
Back
Top Bottom