Backup : Myboob or drive plus enclosure ?

[conuk]

Backup : Mybook or drive plus enclosure ?

is it better to get something like the WDG1C5000 Mybook - or buy a better drive and an external enclosure?

Ive a desktop and a laptop and wish to make the data available to both ?

Ill be taking the backup drive with me when I stay at another house along with laptop.....

if enclosure+drive is better idea can you spec me the two please ?
TIA

 

[conuk]

is there a problem with the Lacie ?

or are the external caddies just as good - think Ill take the plunge withe the seagate ...