Battery Grips - 1st party or 3rd party?

Soldato
Joined
8 Oct 2006
Posts
5,784
Location
Midlands
I post this thread as someone who already owns a grip and is very happy with it. I just wanted to see if others had had similar experiences which might help those looking for a grip, especially those with Christmas money and vouchers to spend!

I bought a D80 shortly after it was released, my first SLR. Over the next few years I bought lots of bits for it including the official MB-D80 grip. Not long ago I sold the D80 and grip and purchased a second hand barely used D7000 which came with a Meike grip (I think sometimes sold as Neewer). The gentleman that sold me the camera mentioned that he had used Meike grips for several years as they were excellent and much much cheaper than Nikon official ones. At this point I'd never used one so I couldn't comment.

My experience thus far is that I will never buy another full priced grip again.

Some detail. My MB-D80 grip was excellent. I paid about £120 for it several years ago, it added the size and balance to the camera that I needed and the control dials all felt and behaved exactly like the ones on the D80 itself and the rubber matched that of the camera. The shutter release however did not feel the same.

It seemed like they had used a different button between making my D80 and making my MB-D80, I do not know if they also changed the shutter button on the D80. My D80 shutter was a very definite half press, followed by a definite full press. The MB-D80 shutter button was featherlight, and anything other than the softest of touches would release the shutter. It wasn't a major issue, you adapt and get on with it, but never the less it was a niggle on for me the most important part of having a grip.

My Meike grip for the D7000 is also excellent, it's light but solid, the rubber doesn't match the camera and is coarser but I think I actually prefer it. The dials feel and perform identically to those on the camera and while the shutter release is slightly different, it does at least match the main one. A definite half press, a definite full press. This one sells for about £30, £120 cheaper than the MB-D11 which is the official Nikon grip (Amazon prices).

So, I didn't choose this Meike grip, I actually asked the seller before buying if it was an official one and had he got back to me before the auction closed (I asked very late) I might have pulled out. But I'm glad I have it and I'd gladly buy another and recommend to others.

I probably won't be buying another grip for 5 years for whatever I replace the D7000 with, but when I do I'll not be buying an official grip if the price differential stays as it is right now.
 
I was looking at grips yesterday, as well as other accessories for the D7000 interesting. I'll take a deeper look in to it and read up further. Just a quick Q regarding the D7000, just purchased one myself too and the 18-105mm VR lens that came with it, the manual focus ring when turned is slightly squeaky . Is this a known normal issue? Its almost as if the ring is slightly too tight if you get me. Maybe I should ring up and see.

Merry Christmas :)
 
Last edited:
I too bought a meike grip for my 7d and it's really good. Ok, the buttons are not up to the same quality and it doesn't have a magnesium frame but it does the job just as well while costing significantly less, saving money that can be put to more useful things.
 
I dont buy any official accessories, don't see the point really, £2 for a 3rd party battery or £60 for an official one? £15 for a 3rd party battery grip or £110? if it doesn't affect the pictures outcome then who cares.

The only thing I would buy official is a memory card.
 
I picked up a BG and 2 batteries for 25 quid for my 550D, and all have been excellent value with no quality issues whatsoever. I just can't see what you could get for an extra 100 quid.
 
I'm not really sure what to think personally.

The only camera I only a grip for is my 7D and that is the official one. It fits the camera nicely and is really nice in the hand, but its far more of a hinderance for anything other than controlled shooting in a studio type environment. The extra bulk isn't necessary for walkabout type shooting, so I'd always remove it. I'm also yet to be in a situation where I've ran out of battery during a shoot and having a battery grip that would auto switch to the next battery would be an advantage. Of course it would be very useful for video which eats batteries.

So with the 5D mkiii, I've been in two minds about what to do, as the official battery grip on this one is like £300-something, I'd only be using it when doing studio type work where I want the orientation advantage it offers. I'd looked at the Pixel Grips, which are supposed to be some of the best ones, but all the YouTube reviews I've watched seem to show that people aren't that happy with them really.
 
I gripped my 600D as I've got stupidly big ham hands and it felt awkward trying to get both hands around the 600's small body. Since the Meike grip has been added it's a lot more comfortable to use and I don't really notice the extra weight either TBH.
 
I gripped my 400D with the official grip and it made a huge difference to my comfort when shooting. With my 5Dmkiii I don't think I need to. I have huge hands but the 5Dmkiii feels quite good as it is in the hand.
 
I'll add that I had a second battery in my D80 grip. However I never used it so I have not bothered to buy a second battery to put in the D7000.
 
I have put grips on all my DSLR's for years, I just prefer the heft and the easier portrait shooting.

I never used to buy anything non OEM, but tried a Meike grip on a D300 a few years back. I was very impressed with it, and although I have an MB-D10 on my D700, I have just purchased a Meike grip for my D7000 and am very pleased with it. Good quality for the price, and functionally identical to the OEM one.

So, for me, 3rd party all the way from now on.
 
A certain retailer has 5D3 grips at something like half price if bought with a camera. Seems reasonable. I couldn't justify £300 on one.
 
I think accessories are where companies try and make a killing over pricing stuff, sony wanted some crazy amount for a remote shutter, like 49 quid
 
I use a third party grip and I have some third party batteries.

My usage is such that I shoot video for 8 hours a day on some days, so I have some ability to say with confidence that the battery grip is absolutely fine, but the batteries last significantly less than the official ones. I can sometimes get as little as 20 minutes on them.

They are great for emergencies, and for shooting stills you might find them fine, but for long periods of time they're of little use to me.

Id buy more, but I wouldn't depend on them.
 
Nikon don't make grip for my D5100 so 3rd party the only option
just picked one up for £24.99, fitted it this morning and it fits great and works fine with an extra 3rd party battery
helps with the balance with my 300mm lens
 
Last edited:
Nikon don't make grip for my D5100 so 3rd party the only option
just picked one up for £24.99, fitted it this morning and it fits great and works fine with an extra battery
helps with the balance with my 300mm lens

I'd love to get one for my D5100 but I really hate the idea of having an external wire to use the new shutter button.
 
I got the official Canon BG-E8 Battery Grip for EOS 600D with two official Canon batteries which i prefer as it looks and feels nicer in my hands. :)
 
I have both my 60D and 550D fitted with 3rd party grips.
The 60D one seems to be better made, the 550D one was nice when I first got it but it has worn pretty badly, the matt finish on the camera is fine, but the grip has gone shiney
if the appearance of your equipment is important to you, buy OEM
 
I went with an official grip for my 650d too but got the cheapest one I could import and got the free shipping option which resulted in a delivery time of about 2-3 weeks lol :) I think the term 'Shipping' was probably quite literal in this case and my grip probably had a nice cruise from HK to the UK before I got my hands on it.

Overall pretty happy with it and it definitely makes a big difference. I took the grip off yesterday whilst I was charging batteries and tried to hold the camera without it. It was an OMG feeling of 'Jeez, how small is this lol'
 
I'd love to get one for my D5100 but I really hate the idea of having an external wire to use the new shutter button.

yeah that's the only let down to it but I'm not that bothered about using the extra stutter release so haven't put the little cable on, I got it for the extra battery power and balance with larger lens
 
Back
Top Bottom