I am well aware that I could connect my PC to my telly, and then watch whatever I downloaded (and paid for a second time via bandwidth charges

) but without buying a spankin HD telly you wouldnt be getting anything other than a pretty horrible picture via a composite or at best svideo connection. Then theres the bit that it just doesnt work like a household appliance the same a Sky digi box does. I have tried HTPC a couple of years back for the purpose of putting my DVD collection to hard disk, it just wasnt a very seamless experience. Turn it to this channel, plug this lead in to the Svideo connection, press this button etc etc every time you want to use it. True with a HD LCD it would be pretty good I imagine.
So HD is basically bringing an enhanced picture quality? Not really the leap of VHS-DVD though is it? Extra content features, 5.1 sound, a sizeable an noticable difference in picture quality, no more rewinding

, chaptered playback, instant pause, smaller packaging and hence reduced distribution costs, doesnt degrade like tape.
In order to get into HD then I require the following:
An LCD or Plasma screen (though there are some CRT based sets in the UK, not many though and even less that are worth buying as I understand it).
A new Sky box plus extra £10 a month subscription
A HD DVD player (plus associated HDMI/Component cables).
DVD cost me a DVD player and an RGB scart lead

Plus I didnt have to pay the BBC any extra money to get it either LOL
Dont get me wrong I see the point in progress, I am up to the hilt with technology in my house, but lets not make out that HD is some be all and end all. You have already said in your closing paragraph thats its already out of date so why are we even bothering with this generation of it?