Best low heat AM4 CPU?

[GoogalyMoogaly]

So I've got a SFF PC that's currently running a ASRock B350 ITX motherboard and a Ryzen 100 CPU.
I believe the CPU is the only thing preventing the PC from being Windows 11 compatible so I'm wondering what options I have as a drop in replacement.
The issue is that with it being a SFF PC in a Silverstone ML08 case there's not much room for a CPU cooler, so I need something that run at least as cool as the 1400. I'm guessing this means a 65W CPU but I'm not sure if all 65W AM4 CPUs hit similar temperatures or if some run cooler than others? I'd expect less core to be cooler but is that the case?

So in short, as the title says, what's the coolest running AM4 CPU (and in the case of a few similar, which is best)?

 

[Tetras]

This is only one result and I don't know if the conditions were exactly the same, but TPU use the same heatsink for their temperature measurements and the 2600 (Zen+, non-X) runs the coolest by a fairly large margin, then the 5600 (non-X) and some way after that, the 3600.

AMD Ryzen 5 3600 Review

Ryzen 5 3600 is the most affordable Zen 2 processor in AMD's lineup. At just $200, it offers six cores and twelve threads, yielding a significant advantage in applications against the competition from Intel. Gaming performance is also improved nicely as it is around 10% higher than with previous...

www.techpowerup.com

AMD Ryzen 5 5600 Review - Fantastic Choice for Upgrades from Older Ryzens

AMD's Ryzen 5 5600 is a great choice for the value-oriented buyer. It actually offers the best price/performance ratio of all Ryzen 5000 processors on the market. Thanks to recent BIOS updates, you can easily install this processor in first-generation Ryzen systems, making it a super affordable...

www.techpowerup.com

Quite a few on here have owned CPUs of each gen, so maybe they will let you know.

 

[Donnie Fisher]

Remember you can often also throttle the cpu in various ways via the bios to limit power usage as well which will keep temps down.

I do this on a 3600 in a glass sided phanteks shift case using a basic AMD cooler and it works a treat.

 

[kamz]

5600g could work if the onboard gfx is suitable

 

[Bug One]

I've got a 5800x and there's a bios setting to put it into eco mode (max 65w tdp).

It runs very cool with that setting on, and I can't say I've noticed any real performance difference.

 

[LePhuronn]

Or if you really need Windows 11, you can do a custom ISO that rips out all the fake requirements.

 

[jigger]

One of the GE parts. The 5750GE is the probably the best.

 

[Trickle]

So in short, as the title says, what's the coolest running AM4 CPU (and in the case of a few similar, which is best)?

All of the AM4 motherboards have a 45W "eco" (60W total) setting for all of the AM4 chips of any generation. You will see higher temps on the 5000x series. But in essence they are all cool running if you set them to be in the bios.
On the 6 core chips you will 'lose' about 100mhz on single core performance and 10% on multicore.

The cheapest 2nd hand chip that will run win11 out of the box is the 2600. The bottom AM4 chip with integrated gfx for Win11 is the 3000g.

 

[GoogalyMoogaly]

All of the AM4 motherboards have a 45W "eco" (60W total) setting for all of the AM4 chips of any generation. You will see higher temps on the 5000x series. But in essence they are all cool running if you set them to be in the bios.
On the 6 core chips you will 'lose' about 100mhz on single core performance and 10% on multicore.

The cheapest 2nd hand chip that will run win11 out of the box is the 2600. The bottom AM4 chip with integrated gfx for Win11 is the 3000g.

Oh right, I don't think I've seen that setting, I'll have to have a look.
EDIT: Do you know what the setting will be called?

 

[kamz]

Should be listed as ECO mode in the bios, you might need a bios update

**Edit** I dont see it on B550 + 5600x, only see the option on the new 7800x3d setup

 

[Trickle]

You can get more or less the same result by setting PBO package power to 60W on your B550. [I couldn't tell any difference from 80W PBO and the 65W eco settings on 3 different different brand b450/550 boards when mining on 12 core 3900xs]

Strange there is no straight up eco mode setting on your board.

 

[WoZZeR]

The stock cooler with the 5600X is a trifle noisy at full pelt. I put one in a Silverstone SG05 and found it intolerable, you would perhaps need something like the Noctua NH-L9a to quieten it down.
I am having fun with the taller version, switched the fan to a 25mm deep Chromax fan and it is much quieter.

 

[OldKitMan]

not sure if it helps OP but I had my spare PC with a 3200G running Windows 11 and bought a 1600 for very little and swapped them over and Windows 11 hasn't complained.

 

[PishY]

5600G are pretty low power and low heat output I’ve found, good overall I think

 

[Gray2233]

You can pick up a 5700X for £150ish and they don't run particularly hot, you could also check the MM for a cheap 3600 or something too.

Assuming you don't need onboard anyway.

 

[Skilid]

Avoid the higher output single CCD chips such as the 5800x and 5800x3d as these run the hottest (I have a 5800x and it's difficult even with watercooling because of the single CCD).

However bear in mind that you can limit the wattage going to the CPU in the BIOS to lower temps.

 

[eeii]

Avoid the higher output single CCD chips such as the 5800x and 5800x3d as these run the hottest (I have a 5800x and it's difficult even with watercooling because of the single CCD).

However bear in mind that you can limit the wattage going to the CPU in the BIOS to lower temps.

Have you used pbo I’ve -30 all my cores and the temps are much lower

 

[Skilid]

Have you used pbo I’ve -30 all my cores and the temps are much lower

Yes, hasn't made an enormous difference. My 5800x will still reach 90c, just slower.