• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Buying Advice - DSLR

Associate
Joined
20 Feb 2006
Posts
185
I currently have a Canon EOS 300, with a 28 - 300mm Sigma Lens, its not a bad lens+camera but after playing with dad's 300D i've decided to switch to a DSLR. Originally I started looking at the Canon Body Only models 350D/400D to utilise my current Lens, but I realised that the Nikon seemed to be of a lot better value for money from looking at reviews on the base models - especially as the stock Lens is better than the stock Canon. As well as the Nikon cameras being slightly cheaper. My current options are as follows:

1) Nikon D40 Lens Kit 18 - 55mm - £330 (excl. £60 cash back.)
=£270 total including cash back :d
From what I understand the D40 - D40X difference is not worth the £100+ difference. Ken Rockwell loves this camera, but he uses it as a 2nd body and so its small size is Ok for him as he has another (more expensive camera) for serious photography.

2) Nikon D50 Lens Kit 18 - 70mm - £300

3) Nikon REFURBISHED D70S c/w 18-70mm - £349.99 - from a well known high street photography company

4) Canon EOS 350d with 18-55mm - £358.97

5) Canon Eos 400d body only £416.95 excl. £50 cash back...
= £366.95 inlcuding

The varying age of release of these cameras make me wonder if the age is relevant to the cameras ability. I am aware of the D40s lack of internal focusing motor on the body.

I would like a camera that allows me to play with the settings as my skills progress but still produce nice images in auto mode while I begin to develop my skills.


Any advice on these options or any other suggested options would be welcomed. I am looking around the £300 - 400 price range preferably. The higher the price the fewer addons I can get, i.e. new glass, filters etc.

Cheers
 
Last edited:
Nikon brought out the D40X basically because they had to - pretty much everyone else had brought out ~10Mp entry level DSLRs.
Canon probably have the best range of own label glass (esp. when you consider that the D40 series can only use AF-S type lenses) although there are enough decent 3rd party lenses for every mount.
 
Nikon users, please correct me if I'm wrong but I also believe the D40/D40x also omits a Depth-of-Field preview function (handy, IMO) and Auto Exposure Bracketing (personally never use but handy) , as well as the aforementioned lack of autofocus on certain lenses.

At the listed price I'd be all over the D70 if it came with a guarantee. It's in a different class of camera altogether :D
 
drdimmer said:
I currently have a Canon EOS 300, with a 28 - 300mm Sigma Lens, its not a bad lens+camera but after playing with dad's 300D i've decided to switch to a DSLR. Originally I started looking at the Canon Body Only models 350D/400D to utilise my current Lens, but I realised that the Nikon seemed to be of a lot better value for money from looking at reviews on the base models - especially as the stock Lens is better than the stock Canon. As well as the Nikon cameras being slightly cheaper. My current options are as follows:

1) Nikon D40 Lens Kit 18 - 55mm - £330 (excl. £60 cash back.)
=£270 total including cash back :d
From what I understand the D40 - D40X difference is not worth the £100+ difference. Ken Rockwell loves this camera, but he uses it as a 2nd body and so its small size is Ok for him as he has another (more expensive camera) for serious photography.

2) Nikon D50 Lens Kit 18 - 70mm - £300

3) Nikon REFURBISHED D70S c/w 18-70mm - £349.99 - from a well known high street photography company

4) Canon EOS 350d with 18-55mm - £358.97

5) Canon Eos 400d body only £416.95 excl. £50 cash back...
= £366.95 inlcuding

The varying age of release of these cameras make me wonder if the age is relevant to the cameras ability. I am aware of the D40s lack of internal focusing motor on the body.

I would like a camera that allows me to play with the settings as my skills progress but still produce nice images in auto mode while I begin to develop my skills.


Any advice on these options or any other suggested options would be welcomed. I am looking around the £300 - 400 price range preferably. The higher the price the fewer addons I can get, i.e. new glass, filters etc.

Cheers

I think the Nikon D40x and Canon 400D get pretty much identical reviews - each has its own benefits and quirks. From what I read the D40x is a far superior camera to the D40 (it's not simply a case of a new sensor). For £400 you aren't going to get much camera but seeing as you already have a Canon lens you are probably going to get more for your money by choosing the 350D or 400D.

There are loads of threads on here about 350Ds Vs. 400Ds so you can decide which one is for you.
 
sean said:
Nikon users, please correct me if I'm wrong but I also believe the D40/D40x also omits a Depth-of-Field preview function (handy, IMO) and Auto Exposure Bracketing (personally never use but handy) , as well as the aforementioned lack of autofocus on certain lenses.

At the listed price I'd be all over the D70 if it came with a guarantee. It's in a different class of camera altogether :D

Yes they do :(

Check out the reviews on dpreview
 
the d50 also lacks dof preview..

given the choices from the nikons, i'd go with the d70s. i recently bought a d50, had i found a d70s at the price that you have then i probably would've got that instead. but as it was, i had to set a cap on what i was spending and not go *too* much over it!!
 
Many thanks for all your replies, had a go with some ones Nikon D70 and I really liked the build of it, didn't feel as small as the canon 350/400D/D40/D40X as I imagine i would end up buying a hand grip if i got one of those.

Going to email the company and see warranty there is on refurbished stuff...

So the D70s>D40?
 
It might also be worth pointing out that while your camera body will most likely change every other year or so, your lenses wont. It is worth spending as much as you possibly can on the lens!
 
Thanks for all the help so far. Contacted the company and the refurbished D70s includes a one year manufacturers warranty, as do all they refurbished DSLR's they sell :).

Point taken SoapSurgeon, if i was to head down the Nikon route I would then start saving for the 'Nikon 55-200mm f/4-5.6 AF-S VR DX' . Hmm... choices, choices... Think I'll look around for few more reviews. The sensor cleaning on the 400D looks good, but I don't know if its worth it. Canon wise I'd head for the Nifty Fifty first I think...

Image quality wise, and usability, in the opinion of OCUK forum users, which is better, 400D or Nikon D70s. I know 10Mpx -> 6Mpx isn't as a qualitative in picture degredation as the quanititative difference is between the two numbers (if that makes sense...)
 
I am sure that you have already realised this, but choose carefully as you will be making your first investment into a system and you will quickly be "locked in" to the system you choose now - changing at a later stage is ridiculously pricy and to be avoided at almost any cost!


The D70s would be my choice - but I have been using Nikon kit for a very long time now.
 
Get a D70s then eventually add the Sigma 30mm f/1.4 and Nikkor 18-200 VR when you can. Both lenses are amazingly good. Photography is such an expensive hobby though. :(
 
GTRacer said:
Get a D70s then eventually add the Sigma 30mm f/1.4 and Nikkor 18-200 VR when you can. Both lenses are amazingly good. Photography is such an expensive hobby though. :(

tell me about it. keep finding things to buy which doesnt do my bank balance any good.
 
Nikon D70s vs 400D then, some one choose for me :P, pain in the arse thinking ahead... do canon lenses tend to be of greater availability?

Just hope the refurbished body is in good work nick and not had many 'actuations?' - spelling?. (Uses/shutter clicks)
 
drdimmer said:
Nikon D70s vs 400D then, some one choose for me :P, pain in the arse thinking ahead... do canon lenses tend to be of greater availability?

Just hope the refurbished body is in good work nick and not had many 'actuations?' - spelling?. (Uses/shutter clicks)


Canon and Nikon lenses are both readily available. The plus point as far as the Nikon option is concerned is that you can use just about any Nikon lens made in the last 50 years on a D70 (obviosly manual focus lenses will not autofocus) which means that you have more choice when buying secondhand.
 
Back
Top Bottom