• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Call me a madmad...

Soldato
Joined
5 Mar 2006
Posts
3,975
Location
Nottingham
Call me a madman...

But I'm really tempted by the new Black Edition Phenoms which should be out sometime next week.

I know they're slower than the big blue but the black editions should clock better than the current stock and I've got 2 3870's on the way which would slot into a Spider platform quite nicely.

Is there any logic to my madness or do I just need a good slap and a q6600?
 
Last edited:
Well if you had an AM2 motherboard as it is then I'd understand, but your sig lists an A8N which is Socket 939 so I don't see why you'd want a Phenom. Q6600 is the better CPU - you're clearly going to overclock and although the CPUs are fairly even at the lower clock speeds, most Q6600s hit 3.2GHz and over - Phenoms don't hit speeds that high.

Up to you of course, but given that you're going to need a new mobo and RAM anyway and that you're going to overclock, I don't see why you'd want to buy the setup that won't perform as well when overclocked.
 
Well if you had an AM2 motherboard as it is then I'd understand, but your sig lists an A8N which is Socket 939 so I don't see why you'd want a Phenom. Q6600 is the better CPU - you're clearly going to overclock and although the CPUs are fairly even at the lower clock speeds, most Q6600s hit 3.2GHz and over - Phenoms don't hit speeds that high.

Up to you of course, but given that you're going to need a new mobo and RAM anyway and that you're going to overclock, I don't see why you'd want to buy the setup that won't perform as well when overclocked.

It's more of the fact that I've heard that due to the way spider was designed the phenom and hd38xx's add up to more than the sum of their parts
 
Get a Cor2Duo with a good Motherboard for now and then upgrade to the new 45nm's when they come out! Or stick with what you have got for a few months.
 
You could always get a good Intel mobo that will accept the new 45nm's and buy a nice cheap Core2Duo. This is what i have done. Very happy so far.


Me too, the overclocked E2180 is that good, I'm not in any rush to upgrade it!
 
I'm interested in getting one of these although it's against the grain. I can wait until the new steeping comes out no problem, but I'll probably buy the cheapest Phenom now and overclock it then upgrade just the processor at a much later date.
 
I'd recommend waiting for the new revision if you're dead set on the Phenom which should fix all the bugs in it.

I'm not dead set, I just like to be different on occasion and I thought maybe the Spider platform would make up for the Phenom being a bit of a wet blanket :p
 
Don't. Wait for the new 45nm Quads that are coming out very soon. They will be much better / cooler.

When is very soon? as from what I've read March is mentioned.

Do we know how much better than a Q6600?, and they big question is how much more are they likley to be?

These factors will depend on whether it is worth waiting for, as if they are only little quicker but cost a fair bit more then I would say your better off shelling out £150 for a Q6600 now, use it and upgrade when the 45nm market is known and the price settles.

Launch prices are always inflated as we all know.
 
Back
Top Bottom