• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Car borked

Soldato
Joined
14 Jul 2005
Posts
9,744
Location
Birmingham
Car broke down 5 mins away from home.

Engine is just whirring when turned over.

RAC man says there is no compression on engine. Being towed to a garage now, obviously they will be closed so wont know anything till morning at best possibly Monday.

There was no prior signs of anything wrong with it, sudden failure.

Anyone any ideas what I can expect here?

It's a ford Mondeo 2.5T petrol, 2007 model.
 
Last edited:
If the engine has actually failed out of nowhere it suggests it's serious, especially if all you can hear is a whirring noise on the starter and not the normal sound when it's turning over. Timing belt possibly, crank or camshaft failure at worst.

Good chance any repair is going to be more than the car is worth if it's any of them.

Fingers crossed I'm talking out of my ass though...
 
I fear you're right and it's serious. The timing belt was turning though I think, but yeah the usual sound of pistons being cranked was totally absent.
 
It’s got to be the cambelt. Hopefully that’s all but be prepared it could have done a lot of damage.
 
when was the cambelt changed?

Dec 2019 when I bought the car (supposedly - it was part of the deal of me buying it that it was done).

I took the cambelt cover off and the belt seemed to be intact. The RAC guy looked at it whilst cranking and said it was turning at least one of the camshafts (he could only see one).

There was no bang or crunch or other noise that would indicate major damage when it happened, the engine just died on me 5 mins after leaving home.
 
Had a valve go on my motor, 2 seperate cars..a4 avant, it still ran but had no power(luckily happenned when i was only a mile or so from audi dealership and managed to limp there..my disco, refused to move..valve had something to do with diverting power or something when turbo kicked in..as car gets to a certain age, can get jammed as gets clogged with soot/dirt..both times fixed within couple hours..still wasn't cheap but cars ran fine afterwards...had a saab 9000 explode on me on the m3..engine seal went, had engine oil spew up onto inside windscreen and fill car up with smoke..that was scary..
good luck, hopefully simple fix
 
If cambelt is still intact it could be missing some teeth or have a failed tensioner pulley which has allowed timing to jump.
 
If its just stopped, that'll likely be a fuel or ignition issue!

The RAC guy probably just meant it's not making any effort to turn over.

If the cambelt broke you'd likely have heard it.
 
Did the RAC man do a compression test on each cylinder?
Generally this involves removing each plug, and inserting a pressure gauge into each cylinder, cranking the engine and seeing what the reading is.
If he did this sort of diagnosis then he is probably right and there is no (or very low) compression, which can only mean catastrophic failure (complete head gasket failure (unlikely to result in no compression at all),broken piston/valves/rods - most likely valves and most likely caused by a cambelt failure)

If its just stopped, that'll likely be a fuel or ignition issue!

The RAC guy probably just meant it's not making any effort to turn over.

If the cambelt broke you'd likely have heard it.

This is not what "no compression" means.
Also, the OP specifically stated the engine is just whirring when turned over, which is not the same as not making any effort to turn over.

The symptoms the OP describes do sound like a failed cambelt of some description.
 
This is not what "no compression" means.
Also, the OP specifically stated the engine is just whirring when turned over, which is not the same as not making any effort to turn over.

The symptoms the OP describes do sound like a failed cambelt of some description.
Without the pops and bangs, the sound of an engine turning over (cranking) could be described as whirring

I think you have a higher opinion of the RAC than me.

I've just assumed he's taken a look determined there's nothing obvious to fix and passed the problem on.
 
The sound of an engine cranking with no compression is very different to the sound of an engine cranking normally. I would expect any mobile mechanic/RAC-type body to be able to tell the difference immediately.

This does seem like jumped teeth. The other alternative is a snapped camshaft but that's pretty unlikely
 
Can you check for codes?
The RAC guy plugged into my car but I don't recall if he found anything or what he said.


Did the RAC man do a compression test on each cylinder?
No, he said it sounded like there was no compression.


Im off to collect my courtesy car now so will then pop into the garage its been towed to and see what they say, probably they haven't looked at it yet though.
 
Back
Top Bottom