• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Cheap upgrade

Associate
Joined
19 Nov 2008
Posts
412
Location
carnmoney outside Belfast
Im looking to put a breath new life into an old PC with a cheap upgrade. Basically Im going from a sempron LE 1200 and onboard GPU to an athlon x2 5400+ and I can't decide what GPU. Whats the best between

HD5450 512mb DDR3 £38.42
GPU Clock 650 MHz
Stream Processing Units N/A
Memory Bus 64-bits
Memory Speed 1.0 GHz

or

HD4650 1gb DDR2 £34.99
GPU Clock: 600 Mhz
Memory Bus: 128
Memory Speed: 800 Mhz

The comp will mainly be used to play the sims and a few older games unreal etc. Screen res is also 1280 x 1024.
 
HD5450 offers newer technology Dx11, but dont think it will be used on this card, imo.
I would get 2nd handed card in that case
 
Well if you could post a total budget then we can all hunt for the best components available for your money ;)
 
Budget is £40. Im sorta interested on how the new HD5450 performs compared to the HD4650. I can't find any benchies that run the same games for both cards meaning its kinda hard to compare them. The 9500gt is around the same price but is slower than the HD4650.

EDIT: Just found benchmarks on toms with all cards in question looked at.
 
Last edited:
Budget is £40. Im sorta interested on how the new HD5450 performs compared to the HD4650. I can't find any benchies that run the same games for both cards meaning its kinda hard to compare them. The 9500gt is around the same price but is slower than the HD4650.

EDIT: Just found benchmarks on toms with all cards in question looked at.

I meant a budget for the total build, unless you have already purchased the other components.
And the 5450 for sale at overclockers is above budget anyway and the cheapest 4650 on here is definitely worth the money, elsewhere they are closer to £60.
 
A secondhand 8800gt would be much more powerful than either and you should be able to pick one up for less than £40.
 
Budget is £40. Im sorta interested on how the new HD5450 performs compared to the HD4650. I can't find any benchies that run the same games for both cards meaning its kinda hard to compare them. The 9500gt is around the same price but is slower than the HD4650.

EDIT: Just found benchmarks on toms with all cards in question looked at.

In terms of raw gaming performance the HD5450 is utterly trounced by the HD4650 (even the DDR2 version).

The advantages in favour of the HD5450 are in this instance not worth the massive performance drop.
 
Yea, HD5450 is almost like specific tailored for HTPC...most likely it will not perform too well for games. I'd agree with most people here...HD4650...or like Gribs and niggyg suggested have look at the 2nd hand gaming cards.
 
Thanks gys

Sorry about that bJN, lack of sleep last night lol. The total upgrade was £100. The cheapest I can get the 5400+ is £47 and tbh couldn't be annoyed trawling through the bay for one especially after a couple of bad experiences on it. Ill have another look at the members market tho and see whats there. I would have thrown up a link for those cards but its not from OCUK.
 
another vote for the 2nd hand 8800gt or 4770. anything less powerful is going to disappoint if you try anything semi-recent.

with a budget of £40, I can say one thing with confidence: there is no point buying a brand new card. what you get for £40 new is, realistically, a hunk-o-junk.
 
Back
Top Bottom