Crackle noise when accessing a external hard drive is it normal?

Soldato
Joined
24 Oct 2005
Posts
16,474
Location
North East
Bought a new Seagate 4tb Backup Plus a few weeks ago during a half price sale as i thought 4tb hdd for 75 quid down from 140 ish, hell yeah.

Anyhow when it accesses the drive i notice a slight crackle noise but when idle its nice and quiet.

Ive filled about 3 quarters of it now with stuff from my old hdds as they were all almost full and really needed moving to a larger drive so they had some space back to get some speed again as you know if there full their speed suffers.

So yeah. Should i be worried or not about this slight crackle kinda noise. Maybe cos of my internals are quiet and unnoticeable that i just forgot that hdds make a noise or should this external be quiet all the time and make no mechanical noises at all?

For example i go in to the hdd through my computer, i click on a folder i hear a click noise or somit, when i click on a episode of somit to watch on the drive its quiet enough, and im just transferring a 5gb film from it to one of my internals and it didnt make much of a noise there either, but say hd pro, if i do a quick scan its very noticeable also if im transferring a large amount of files from a internal to the external then that usually makes the noise crackle.

I have checked hdd failure noises online but they dont seem to be like what im experiencing. Or do most external hdds make this noise and i only hear it now because its my first external and with it being so close to me and out of the computer i hear what hdds usually make with noise?
 
Just checked event viewer history and noticed some of these. About a row of 10 and then another row of 10 a bit earlier.

"An error was detected on device \Device\Harddisk4\DR4 during a paging operation"

Also two entrys of "The driver detected a controller error on \Device\Harddisk4\DR4."

Still normal? If i was to guess its when the hdd is at idle or somit and power saves which it shouldnt as i turned off hdd power saving or sleep functions so should always be on and ready to be accessed.

Btw in policies for this drive it has Better performance ticked, quick removal unticked, and Enable write catching on the device ticked tho it has a warning under saying "this device does not allow its write caching setting to be changed" and also turn off windows write-cache buffer flushing on the device is unticked.

Does that all sound about right for external drives for storing stuff on?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom