• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Dipping my toe into AMD waters

Associate
Joined
13 Aug 2007
Posts
478
Location
Oirland
I've got no particular reason for doing so other than a change from intel stuff.

I'll be needing a cpu, mainboard and memory with a view to playing games like BF3, Crysis 2 and forthcoming titles such as Max Payne 3 at very high (maybe not absolute maximum) settings.

How does this sound for £300?

AMD Bulldozer FX-6 Six Core 6100 Black Edition 3.30Ghz (Socket AM3+) Processor (what would the intel alternative be?)

Asus M5A97 PRO AMD 970 (Socket AM3+) DDR3 Motherboard

Corsair XMS3 6GB (3x2GB) DDR3 PC3-16000C9 2000MHz Triple Channel Kit


I can't afford a graphic card at the moment so how would my reliable old 1gb 5850 go with that lot?
 
Well the first mistake is going for a AMD Bulldozer when Intel have a better competing CPU such as the i5 2500K

Another mistake is the triple channel RAM kit, these are meant for Intel socket1366 systems, current AMD Bulldozer and Intel Sandybridge systems use a dual channel memory controller so you should be fitting RAM in pairs:)
 
Don't be a muppet. Sandy Bridge is a far better proposition.

I can't see the point in buying an inferior product just because you fancy a change.
 
Ah, as I said, first time toying with the idea of an AMD build :p

To be honest I haven't a clue what AMD to Intel alternatives are. I just blindly picked a few bits and pieces based on feedback and price. And I've not upgraded in YEARS. I've pretty much lost track of what's what these days.
 
A few questions.

1) are all your drives SATA?
2) do you want the option of Crossfire/SLI?
3) do you have a good PSU?
 
Yep
Nope
Think its a corsair 650w

Buy this,

YOUR BASKET
1 x Intel Core i5-2500K 3.30GHz (Sandybridge) Socket LGA1155 Processor - Retail £167.99
1 x Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 (Socket 1155) DDR3 Motherboard REV 1 £84.98
1 x Kingston HyperX RED Limited Edition 8GB (2x4GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel Kit (KHX1600C9D3B1RK2/8GX) £39.95
Total : £304.32 (includes shipping : £9.50).




Job done.

You can OC the CPU safely to 4GHZ with the stock supplied heatsink, add a aftermarket heatsink and you are looking at around 4.5GHz with nice temperatures:)

You do have a 64bit OS for the 8GB of RAM?
 
Bloody hell, that's cheap ram! That's partly the reason I was thinking of staying away from intel, I wanted a decent i5 or entry level i7 but they were too dear in comparison to AMD ones. Guess I could make up the difference if RAM is going that cheap.

Not wanting to start a war or owt, but would I be better off staying with intel stuff?
 
Ah, as I said, first time toying with the idea of an AMD build :p

To be honest I haven't a clue what AMD to Intel alternatives are. I just blindly picked a few bits and pieces based on feedback and price. And I've not upgraded in YEARS. I've pretty much lost track of what's what these days.

AMD is a great choice, just not the BD CPU's, apparently, although people say they are great for video encoding and have lots of potential, depending on Windows 8 etc.

If going for AMD now, find a Phenom II 1090t OR much easier to find, a 960T. The 960t has a chance of being unlockable to 6 cores and is ridiculously overclockable.

(Try not to listen to the massive intel club - they are right about sandybridge being a great platform, but i tend to think not many would notice the diference unless they were told.)
 
(Try not to listen to the massive intel club.......

That's great advice if he doesn't want to listen to people who will advise him to get much better performance for less money. :rolleyes:

That "massive intel club" as you call it will mostly consist of people who were members of the "massive AMD club" 8 or 9 years ago when AMD were the best price performance.
 
Last edited:
As an avid amd fan at one stage and currently have 3 gaming desktops , 2 x intel and 1 x amd , I can honestly tell you amd have dropped the ball completely as far as pc gaming goes . My wife and son game with me which is why there is 3 pcs and the amd is overclocked to 4ghz but still struggles compared to my Intels. The once flagship CPU maker really is not competitive with intel for gaming now at all.

I'm not a member of any so called fan club and I'd love good competition as it means better options for us the consumer but sadly it's not the case right now !

You could always buy an amd gfx card just so there is some amd in there hehe ;)

Good luck whichever you choose mate .
 
You could always buy an amd gfx card just so there is some amd in there hehe ;)

No danger of that not happening. I've always gone with AMD/ATI cards ;)

How does this sound for gaming boys & girls?

Intel Core i5-2500K 3.30GHz
Asus P8Z68-V LX Intel Z68
Corsair Vengeance 8GB DDR3 1866MHz Dual Channel Kit

And as I said, unless it'll bottleneck the other components I want to stick with my 5850 (I really can't afford a new card anyway). If all the above could handle something cutting edge like BF3 at high settings running at a minimum of 1680 x 1050/2 xAA I'd be pretty happy. Obviously I'd want it to be cutting through older stuff like Portal 2, Pro Evo, etc at max settings.

I've got a Corsair 650w psu, OCZ Vertex 2 SSD, Win7 64bit Ultimate and all housed within a Coolermaster HAF 932.
 
The Gigabyte board has some excellent reviews and OC's well,

Also with a Gigabyte board you get a 3 year UK warranty with the RMA center based in Milton-Keynes so you don't have to send it abroad if it goes faulty like the ASUS after the initial retailer warranty expires.


Also your RAM selection is a little poor, it works, but Sandybridge systems dont benefit much from the increased bandwidth of higher MHz RAM, 1600Mhz and modest timings C9-9-9- etc is all you need.

http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/memory/2011/01/11/the-best-memory-for-sandy-bridge/1
Conclusion of what to Buy
If you're the type of person that runs dozens of applications all at once, then a higher memory frequency does help, particularly when you're running demanding software. However, our testing shows that memory rated at over 1,866MHz doesn't give much extra performance. Worse still, in some applications only 1,333MHz memory gives a performance penalty, meaning that 1,600MHz memory is fine.

If you're doing anything other than heavy multi-tasking - this goes for gamers in particular - then a 1,600MHz or 1,866MHz kit is plenty. You could opt for CL8, as we saw some advantage in the video encoding test, but we wouldn't obsess over this factor, especially if a CL9 kit is much cheaper.

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/memory/display/sandy-bridge-ddr3_8.html#sect0
Therefore, we believe that inexpensive DDR3-1600 SDRAM with not very aggressive timings would be the most reasonable choice for contemporary LGA1155 systems: in our opinion, memory like that offers the best price-to-performance ratio today.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4503/sandy-bridge-memory-scaling-choosing-the-best-ddr3/8
The sweet spot appears to be at DDR3-1600, where you will see a minor performance increase over DDR3-1333 with only a slight increase in cost. The performance increase gained by going up to DDR3-1866 or DDR3-2133 isn't nearly as pronounced.


Also bare in mind the tall heatsinks that the Vengeance RAM has, so if you were wanting to add a aftermarket heatsink later then it can cause fitment issues.
 
Last edited:
Intel i5's and if you need them, i7's, are the performance kings at the moment, if you wanted a media centre/htpc however then the AMD Llano APUs are a good choice for that price range
 
Back
Top Bottom