Do you find overweight people attractive?

[TW]Fox;10953776 said:
A better analogy would surely have been penski-cars - some people like old cars covered in rust in much the same way that for some people, no girl is complete with some rolls of fat.
Well not at all - A BMW5 series may look like a stunning model to you, but to others its just another well engineered vehicle that gets you from A to B.
 
Being overweight is not attractive at all no.

However it might not stop me from finding them attractive through their personality, although the chances of this will probably be greatly reduced.

[TW]Fox;10953746 said:
Come on, does anyone honestly find THIS attractive? This is clearly a whale
One mans gristle is another mans poison ;)
 
Last edited:
My ex was a size 8, and my current is a 14.

Both around 5'6".

My current, apart from being prettier in general, has boobs and a nice butt.

Body structure comes into play a lot as well, as a size 14 girl who is 6' will look way more in proportion than a 5' size 14 girl.

I'd say size 14 is my limit, giving allowances for pregnancy of course ;)

I'm also quite slim (5'11", 13 stone), so that also plays a part.
 
[TW]Fox;10953776 said:
A better analogy would surely have been penski-cars - some people like old cars covered in rust in much the same way that for some people, no girl is complete with some rolls of fat.

To be fair any car could have been used as a comparison, however I wanted something that was specific to you.
But yes, that analogy is a good one :p
 
No one is saying that a person who is obese because of their fat is healthy. People can be obese because of Muscular and Skeletal build, but people can be in cases be Overweight and healthy. I'm classed as 'ok' by the BMI index, yet I can't run more then a quarter of a mile before I die.

I'm arguing a point that Morba raised

you can be healthy and obese, the 2 are not directly linked.

If we are discussing an obese rating on the BMI index for person who carries a lot of muscle mass then fair enough I'd agree with you both, but the arguement is evolving from where Morba made the above comment and made references to the woman in the DM articles size not being unhealthy
 
No they can't.
Actually according to BMI they can. I know someone training to qualify for the olympics (shot put) who can squat over 300kg yet is classed as morbidly obese, when clearly he is extremely fit.

It doesn't take into account those which train for such goals. However this is quite off topic, for the perpose of this thread obese should obviously mean 'fat'. BMI should be taken with a pinch of salt.
 
My ex was a size 8, and my current is a 14.

Both around 5'6".

My current, apart from being prettier in general, has boobs and a nice butt.

Body structure comes into play a lot as well, as a size 14 girl who is 6' will look way more in proportion than a 5' size 14 girl.

I'd say size 14 is my limit, giving allowances for pregnancy of course ;)

I'm also quite slim (5'11", 13 stone), so that also plays a part.

Not all size 8 women don't have a figure though. Also pregnancy is used a lot these days as the blame for putting on weight. I think it's rubbish, you'd have to eat like a pig to put on 4 stone in 9 months, seriously.
 
Thin > Fat.

Maybe because I am young but I duno what fat peopl eat to get so fat. I eat an average amount, I don't have time to eat more.
 
If we are discussing an obese rating on the BMI index for person who carries a lot of muscle mass then fair enough I'd agree with you both, but the arguement is evolving from where Morba made the above comment and made references to the woman in the DM articles size not being unhealthy

Yes, this is about the woman in the article and similar shape / size women rather than people whos BMI is distored by above or below average muscle mass.
 
I'd always dated stick thin women and never quit felt that great with them. Then I dated a lass who was quiet chunky, but not obese and now I can't even look at skinny lasses. She was absolutely awesome - great in the sack, always up for a laugh and bag after bag of personality.

Now I have absolutely zero interest in thin women at all. I don't like the look and I generally find their attitude doesn't quiet gel with mine.
 
Lets sum up:

a) BMI is useless
b) The girl in the picture who prompted this thread is fat
c) This thread is based on 'fat' as defined in b) not a).

Carry on!
 
Back
Top Bottom