• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

does any one have a 5870?

Associate
Joined
11 Jun 2009
Posts
1,354
Location
Bridgwater, Somerset, UK
At the mo i have a 4870x2 and tbh.. i can cook an egg on it until i put the fan above 50% ... at that point it sounds like a bike reving up -_- whats the noise like on the 5870?? and temps? Are they any better over the 4870x2? if so i may sell mine and get one -_-
also.. this is a stupid question really lol but i went into a pc shop today and the guy said you can crossfire 4870x2 with the 5870... I said i didnt think that was right but he was adamint you COULD.. i have a feeling he was just saying it to sell one lol -_- is that true?.. or am i a noob and u can ><
 
Last edited:
Maybe in dx10.1 and lower?
Yes 5870 is very cool and quiet, you won't be disappointed. A Vapor x will be even more silent and cooler.
 
Yeah the 5 series are much better in terms of cooling so you shouldn't have a problem there, as for crossfiring a 5870 with a 4870x2, I'm pretty sure you can, there are certain limitations, you can't hook any old cards together (example: 3870 with 4870) BUT you can 100% do it with the correct combination, not sure how reliable it is and I think it's a fairly new feature too, that was introduced in the 4 series, I think anyway

I did see a chart about it once but I'm not sure I could find it again for you >.<, I'm sure someone knows of the combinations
 
hmmm sounds good then :D ... now.. should i sell my 4870x2 for one 5870... i dont plan on playing any dx11 games anytime soon.. i think ill wait for them to come down :D .. tho i did see a 4870x2 go for £168 on an auction site the otehr day second hand... >< oh the hard decisions lol
 
I upgraded from a 4870x2 to a 5870 and it was a worthwhile upgrade imo.
The x2 is a leaf blower and runs very hot.
The 5870 is cool and quiet.
Performance wise id say nothing in it dx9 games and with dx10 the 5870 edges it.
dont change if you thing you will get a performance gain because you wont.
The heat and the noise and dx11 is why i upgraded and im very glad i did.
 
:), Not yet but should do in a few hours, I went and got a 5870 so my bfg gtx 285 ocx is going to be up for sale very soon.

I just got sick of no real news on fermi, nvidia dropped the ball on not giving enough info to keep customers and I was itching to upgrade, have been for a couple of months so I guess I might skip fermi at launch and get a better revised fermi later in the year like I did with getting the gtx285 rather than the 280, the main thing I'm glad ati have sorted out is the cooling whilst at the same time have boosted performance greatly over the 4800 series, I know the 5870 is just a minor upgrade rather than a big leap forward from last gen with dx11 thrown in and yes I do doubt it being a good performer once heavily used dx11 come into play but I doubt that will be for a fare while tbh and I could always get another for crossfire if it's worth doing.

Still the best gpu I ever owned was the 8800gtx, I guess it spoilt me with it lasting almost 3 years of great performance until the likes of crysis and gta iv came along and made it feel old lol, and nvidia has built fermi from the ground up so is bound to be better than 5870 in many ways only now I don't have to get frustrated with looking up info and just enjoy some kick a$$ gaming :D and just check it out once it's been released.

Another thing I took into consideration is most reviews of the 5870 are somewhat unjust as they seem to be done from win 7 rc os and with beta drivers, I don't understand why review sites don't go back to the reviews and re-do them once drivers and all are better.

I was kinda happy with the gtx 285 but there were some games I had to tone down a little to keep fps silky smooth, well I'm a sucker for full eye candy and fluid fps :D.

I have seen in the forum some people are coming from a 8800gtx or 4870 or even older cards to a 5870, those people are in for the best gains and are really in for a very nice treat :).
 
imho.....i just upgraded to the 5870 from a 4870x2 and the performance is equal to, if not better, especially on the newer games....and you have the bonus of a single card performance on a par of a crossfired dual card
 
Running 2 xfx 5870s in crossfire and the temps are good im well happy with them so far.
 
My 5870 does run cool and Quiet.

As of now - per gpu-z- 33c with fan at 21%(i.e. cannot hear). I have not checked gaming temps , other than occasionally testing after when temps have never exceeded 65c. and fan speed has not exceeded 30%.(can hear but not disastrous). I assume you can use CCC or Riva and set own speeds if you wish but have not felt need.

Although it may be possible to run a 5870 xfire with a 4870x2 I would not personally consider it. (different gen's of tech , one card unable to run dx11 (may be important 6 months hence) , heat and noise (partic of 4870x2) etc). You could still get semi-decent money for the 4870 so sell and use towards second 5870 ?
 
Uh oh, hope someone might be able to help me on this, can't seem to log into ati's forum to get help at the moment.

My win 7 experience index looks very wrong, cpu, mem, disk is same as it were before I pulled my gtx 285.

Both the graphics scores are 6.0, I've not tried a game yet, I seen people mention powerplay in ati's forum, is this why it is scoring bad. If so how do I get around this so I get the correct score, please help :).

Here is exactly what I did.

I uninstalled the nvidia drivers through cp add/remove, removed the gtx 285, put the 5870 in.

Installed ccc 9.12, ran the experience index, scored 6.0 on both graphics, I also note in device manager it just says "ati radeon hd 5800 series" should it not say 5870.

Got worried, had a google for what I should be getting on the wei, found a thread with someone else who was having the exact same problem, someone said run driver sweeper and get rid of the old drivers, installed it, went to safe mode and cleaned out nvidia traces, tried the wei again and stayed the same 6.0.

I uninstalled ccc and I rebooted into safe mode and ran driver sweeper to remove traces of ati and then installed ccc 9.12 again and still get 6.0.

I tried loging into the forum to post the above, but could not, said it was full?

here is the message I'm getting when I click on login.

Service Unavailable
The requested service is temporarily unavailable. It is either overloaded or under maintenance. Please try later.

-------

So, I had a mess with overdrive, clicked unlock.
Went to profiles manager
Created 2 profiles
Edited 1 of them so it would put the 3d clocks on
Activated it, it worked.
ran the wie again and still it gives 6.0?????

Everything seems fine except the WEI graphics score but Still not tried a game yet.

Need help, hope it's not a faulty card.
 
Weird, just tried dirt 2, done a benchmark and had everest doing a log of activity and temps, it ran fine and checks out as it should in the logs as working fine so could the WEI just be iffy, I'll look into clearing the old records of past WEI.
 
Yeah, don't worry about the WEI. My 5850 score varies switches from 6.0 to 7.7, but performance in games is exactly the same regardless of what WEI is showing. I've run the Dirt2 gaming benchmark and 3dMark@06 on both settings, with no noticeable difference. It seems to be a WEI glitch.
 
Soo does that mean the 5870 wont run as well as the 4870 on dx9 games? I do play a lot of dx9 games too (oblivion, roller coaster tycoon 3, as well as dx 10 games :( P.s will the 5870 ..viper?... the one with the added cooler , is that just as good as the normal 5870? and is it just as quiet.
 
Last edited:
Waynio, are you using Win7 RC or Retail mate?

I've just moved from the RC to retail, and with RC my graphics card scores were like 6.4 on both, but since going onto Retail they are now 7.4 and 7.6..

Like the others have said, WEI isn't worth worrying about.
 
Back
Top Bottom