Doesn't matter. The form may have said that the design was "at the artist's discretion" but there's no way a "reasonable man" would expect that to mean that when asked for a scene from Narnia the tattoist would draw a pile of poo.
The fact that he appears to have plied her with drink is hardly going to go in his favour either.
How does a man do that? Did he held a gun to her head and forced her to drink?
I hate when women blame men: "Oh he gave me so much to drink I couldn't control myself", you drink if you want to, nobody is forcing you to do it.