What does "works better" mean?
Easier?
More size?
More carry over into a lift?
I personally think you would be better off with a barbell of done description, or something heavy for 8-12 reps.
More size (albeit not that important in my view, but always nice nonetheless).
More carry over into the deadlift (general grip strength and I've noticed better lockout strength too).
My initial reasoning for doing Kroc's was with the intention of improving grip initially and they were kept in since I was already barbell rowing twice a week so a dumbbell variation was nice.
What would your preference be as an alternative? BOR, T-Bar?
If you are going for size, then bodybuilder rows and t-bars are relatively standard. My general suggestion would be 10-12 reps for heavier weights... As heavy stuff is just awesome.
My personal preference is for snatch grip work (snatches, deadlifts, from-floor stiff legged deadlifts, etc.) where the lats get roasted trying to hold the bar back, but each to their own. I also do Pendlay and single arm rows, too, depending on what else I am doing...
If you want strength, the best - IMHO - is snatch pulls, followed by other snatch work and then Pendlay rows for 'regular stuff.
I thought you mentioned size in your previous post?
You don't needs platform to pull from - you won't be doing much more than a fast deadlift, really.
I would suggest snatch grip dead lifting as a start.
Not necessarily.
My suggestion for snatch stuff would be instead of your current deadlifts, because you will fry your nervous system. Snatch grip work does a lot more than work your lats, and you might well notice your whole upper back being pulled apart by it.
I simply think swapping your Kroc rows for something heavier in the 10-12 rep range would be more productive.
To be fair, deadlifting followed by snatch grip RDLs is a perfectly fine way to go.
Regardless, your programme should do what you want it do and address your own weaknesses. Only you know what your objectives are in this - I'm just trying to give you ideas as to what may work better... but ultimately, it's your routine, so your call.
If you think that snatch grip deadlifts would work the hamstrings and produce the same glute activation as stiffed legs would then I'd happily swap them out. I have only been doing stiff legged deadlifts for the additional hamstring work as I'm sceptical about doing good-mornings with my injury. And these exercise were only picked out because they seemed to be the 'go-to' accessories for deadlift work, although my hamstring and glute activation has got a lot better as a result.
They will ruin your hamstrings. And upper back.
Don't say I didn't warn you.
Sounds perfect for what I'm after. As long as hamstrings and glutes get destroyed all is good and upper back development is definitely needed. What sort of rep/set/progression scheme would you recommend?
No different from regular SLDL/RDLs, tbh. If you want strength/size, adjust accordingly.
Crikey - a bit early in the morning for percentages?
I wouldn't necessarily worry about tapering on your assistance work, however, and the percentages you work at are somewhat irrelevant as if you've not done snatch grip work before, you will likely find sticking to a given percentage pretty tough.
Regardless, try it and see how it goes.