Educate me about NAS.

Consigliere
Joined
12 Jun 2004
Posts
151,030
Location
SW17
Freecom 1TB USB 2.0/Ethernet NAS Hard Drive - Retail (30725)

This is a possible purchase and i understand a few things about NAS but not a lot...i know anyone on the network can access it but what about if i went to an internet cafe? Could i 'log in' to my hard drive that is sitting on my desk at home?
 
I believe that the standard solution is to build a small, low power computer and fill it with hard drives since a good NAS costs a ridiculous amount. There are some very good operating system options, so you are not bound to windows unless you wish to be.

With regards logging into it, it depends rather on what operating system you use, and your technical skills/available time to learn new tricks. VPN is a virtual private network, it convinced your current computer that its directly wired to the physical network (with your NAS on it). This works well, I've had success with hamachi. FreeNX is what I would recommend to actually log into the machine.

If comfortable with linux, ssh'ing into a network machine is straightforward. That only gives you a shell, but sshfs will mount a remote drive as if it's internal, and freenx will allow you to actually sign into a computer on the home network.

FTP/SCP will let you copy files, VPN/sshfs will let you browse it normally. You log into one of the machines attached to the NAS, not into the machine itself. Unless you've gone down the build-your-own approach, in which case you can log into it directly.

Depending on what you have in mind, you may discover bandwidth to be an issue. Streaming video over a mobile broadband connection (for example) doesn't really work, and remote desktop can be very slow.

I'm quite interested in things like this, and happy to help, but must ask for more information on what you wish you achieve. And none of the solutions are that easy as such :)
 
You also need to check that your broadband connection has a fixed IP address. It gets a bit tricky to VPN/FTP/whatever in if you don't know where it is today.
 
if you're willing to make a small outlay, you can pay for LogMeIn Pro and access your computer (and thus any file on your network) from anywhere in the world...

http://logmein.com/
 
I have the Netgear ReadyNAS Duo and its great. It has Raid 1 so gives disk redundancy. The best bit is I can access my NAS via the web using a free dyndns account and access all my files. I can also access a bittorrent client installed on the NAS and monitor, add, remove and view RSS torrent feeds. Very useful. I can also set up user accounts for users internal and external of the NAS to store/read files. Its a bit on the pricey side but getting the empty box + 1TB hdd cost about £300 which I think is well worth it.
 
Wow lots of information...my goal is to be able to access my laptop with the NAS back at my student house and be able to listen to it wherever i am - mate's house or a computer suite somewhere around the campus... :)
 
I don't fully understand your goal.

My best guess is that you want a laptop to be able to access a stack of drives wherever the laptop happens to be?

I'm in the process of setting up something similar, I wish to be sitting in the library playing a film that is stored on a desktop computer at home. The laptop arrived today, so this is not yet working.

The current plan however is to set up ssh on the machines in order to be able to access the desktop remotely. I'll then mount its hard drive using sshfs. This should be all I need to do, but routers are giving me some trouble

edit: works excellently when the machines are connected directly together. any chance you use linux? im not sure if sshfs works through putty
 
Last edited:
I have a synology NAS, which I have found to be very good. But what's more important is that they are very proactive in updating/improving their firmware, with features and fixes.
 
get a low powered cheap server instead, like those cheap shuttles ocuk sell, or an atom based pc

home NAS are cack, with rubbish speeds

if someone can show me one with ~80mb/s transfer rates, i'll retract this comment.
 
Is it all about the speed?

For me the services that it runs, within a small box are a key here. I just need the disks to provide constant speed to serve up data into gigabit switch.

yes I could throw a disk or 2 into a shuttle, but it's not the thing for the job. Those shuttles make excellent PBX servers for the home btw :)

It's worth remembering that your design criteria may not match other peoples. Personally I am not interested in spending thousands on a SAN just so I can have ripping speed. So to say all NAS are cack is rather a sweeping statement.

I wouldn't deny some are not great.

Check out www.mpcclub.com for great work/reviews on home NAS's.

PS - At what price do we move out of the home to the small business setting? £400/600/800 ?
 
buying a fast drive and putting it in a NAS that can't get over 10mb/s (when it claims to have gigabit) is like getting a 2 legged dog, and setting up bear traps around it
 
so dont buy a fast drive

scenario with the dog and the traps doesnt apply for this OP, a cheap nas is going to work its just not going to be as fast as something more expensive and complex.

It could easily be fast enough to transfer files for 'listening' anywhere the OP can connect from and much more power efficient that using an existing PC.
 
I went down the NAS route but found it to be far less configurable for what I wanted to do. Ended up spending £50 more and building a cheap Shuttle (K45, 1.6ghz Celeron, 2gb DDR2), putting the HDDs in that and installing Windows Home Server. Still not totally sold on the OS (and I have the advantage of an MSDN subscription so have a nice range of choice), but I'm much happier with it over the NAS I had.
 
I have a QNAP 209 II with a couple of mirrored 500GB disks in it. Yes it doesn't get 80mb/s over gigabit lan but it is significantly faster than some of the cheaper home NAS units you see on the market. It also has a nice selection of services available and pre-configured. The only downside I have with it is the noisy 40mm fan.

I also have a K45 Shuttle box, (K45, E2220, 2GB, 1x 500GB) ... again not the quietest system in the world (even with a quiet 92mm fan taking some strain off the PSU fan) ... it's a nice little box but it's not a complete plug in and go NAS solution which is what some people want. Yes you could drop a NAS OS solution on, like openfiler, but there would still be configuration to do. Personally mine is looking like it will be running Ubuntu Server or Opensuse, but that's because it will be doing some things which are outside the normal NAS remit as well as serving a few files (which are also stored elsewhere so not having disk redundency is not an issue). Hence it is more of a general server than a dedicated NAS.

I'll probably put in the same combination of devices for my parents when they move as currently their network storage consists of AMD Thunderbird based PC's with raid5 arrays of 120GB disks ... these work great and are really flexable and fast ... but drink power like it's going out of fashion.
 
Late reply. :)

It would only be used so when i wasn't at home, i don't have to take my iPod with me and instead i could access my entire music collection.

I think i am after a server...thought a NAS was a basic 'set-up' version. :o
 
Back
Top Bottom