Eufy CCTV

Your question was why I went the wifi route, I explained why. It's not about how long it would take you, it's about how long it would take me not just to run the cables but to do all the other legwork. I've never run or terminated cables, not got an SDS drill or cable fishing wires, not got a ladder that reaches the eaves, don't have any existing ethernet runs and don't want to be crawling around in the loft space. I just wanted basic CCTV which Eufy does with a much simpler install. I understood PoE is superior, but not superior enough for me to want to go to the trouble or paying someone else to do it.

To then go off on a rant about how easy it is for you just comes across as rude/arrogant and completely irrelevant to your initial question or to the thread in general. What's it achieved?

Are you sure that was what my question was, or like your assessment that I went off on a rant and was rude/arrogant is that something you think you read? I didn't use an SDS drill, my daughter didn't help me, no cable fishing wires or have to install anything in the eaves, you've imagined a much more complex job than the one I did, which only required me to go as high as a garage roof. I've done six cameras over two properties in the last few months and have another 6-7 to do this month over another two properties.

I have to ask, how is having to retrieve a camera to sort the battery twice a year not a hassle, but spending 20-30 minutes cabling in a PoE camera properly, that you don’t need to touch again a hassle? I can see an argument for less destructive install on a listed building or a rented property, but beyond that using batteries is something best left to TV remotes, children’s toys or a trail cam. I’m glad it works for you, but it’s something anyone considering installing probably needs to give some thought to before going either way along with the recording limitations of Eufy. What’s right for me clearly wasn’t right for you in your opinion, neither may be right for op.

To me, that's asking why you perceive dealing with batteries twice a year as easy, but spending 30 minutes running a cable is as hassle - nothing to do with why you 'went the wifi route' as you suggest - followed by exceptions where I can see your approach actually being more suitable. Personally, I thought that was pretty balanced just as my original comparison was :confused:

Lets just savour the moment, two people who haven't installed hard wired PoE cameras (one openly admits he has no experience) are telling someone who has as recently as yesterday that the timescale suggested is unrealistic for most people. Got to love the internet :D


Again, you don't need to be an experienced installer, pinning a cable along a mortar corse where it isn't an eye saw isn't really a skill, it's basic common sense (though sadly not a requirement of employment at OR judging by the state the recent re-pull on the property was left in). Heck even my 13y/o daughter can do that, just don't ask her to drill a hole with an SDS drill, she wanders all over the place. If you aren't capable for whatever reason or choose not to, then as said previously fair enough, but suggesting the vast majority of people are incapable of something in a timescale provided by someone who has actually done it when you haven't, surely you can see the irony in that? Lets be honest, the issue isn't 20-30 minutes, it could be 10-20 or 30-40, you just don't want to do it and are happy with what you have, again, nothing wrong with that. I like my cameras to work 24/7 and record everything in high enough resolution so that it's useful even if an event isn't triggered by something that isn't comparable to a webcam, if the power goes down my system still records and I really like my video to be useful if the worst happens, the 4-5mp ColorVu in near pitch black is genuinely a game changer, the 6mp DarkFighter's are a big step up in quality as well. Clearly you're happy with what you have, but no matter how you look at it, it's a compromise, perhaps it works well for you and you'll never be stung by it's shortfalls, but as a security product, i'd rather pay for better kit and know someone walking in with a £5 wifi jammer didn't render the whole thing useless.

So this must be the rant, right? Are you butt-hurt because I pointed out admitting to having zero experience in doing something, then making a flawed assertion that my timescales are inaccurate and beyond most people is the kind of stupidity that deserves to be called out. You're literally offering an opinion on something you admit to having no knowledge of what's involved, what's required or how long it takes in opposition to someone with direct personal experience and making a sweeping generalisation that's laughable. Will every single install take 20-30 minutes? No, some will take less, some will take a lot more, but having installed external cable runs on everything from a bungalow to a three storey town house, a first floor flat and reasonably large homes, 20-30 is a reasonable starting point for most external runs that are straight forward in my experience. A more sensitive soul with such low thresholds for offence could term such statements as being 'rude/arrogant' - I wonder where have I read that recently?

I have nothing to gain here, I don't sell cameras or do installs for others unless we have a decade of shared history, share a bed or a family tree (don't combine them, that's illegal :D ). It's not like if it took me 19minutes you and everyone else will race out and buy a hard wired kit or that i'll care one way or the other. If you want to see any of my posts as a rant, feel free, but as I said multiple times, if it works for you (or me), that's great, but for the op to make an informed decision the pro's and cons should really be offered up for discussion and however well meant comments along the lines of 'I have one and it works' are, they are devoid of relevant considerations that are needed for op to make an informed choice. I'm sorry you can't seemingly can't see that and choose to take it so personally.

Do you need a hug or can we move on?
 
We tried some Eufy 2C Pro cameras.

They worked pretty well, although I ended up replacing them for a Reolink POE NVR system because the Eufy ones that run off a battery don’t record 24/7. This wasn’t an issue until someone bumped my car outside the house and the Eufy didn’t pick it up.

We’re in the process of moving home so I’ll probably go with HikVision next as I understand they support colour night vision.
 
Back
Top Bottom