• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

EV general discussion

2.2 - 2.3 last few days but also 90mph cruising. Charging finishes just before I leave so I’m sure tha helps with some residual heat in the pack
 
I got 3.4 over my 45 mile commute this morning, expected it to drop considering it was minus 3 for most of the drive in.

Looks like I got a drop from 4 to 3.5ish once the summer finished then I'm assuming it's going to hold around there until it gets properly cold, so much better than I expected and means an even bigger cost saving than I originally worked out.
 
Ioniq 5 was being a derp this morning. 5 miles into the journey and the rated efficiency was showing as 1.1 (:eek:) but the "since charge" was in the low-mid 3's.

The efficiency "bar" below the dials was showing the same as the "since charge" rating so I think the journey efficiency was factoring in the climate blasting for a few mins before setting off as 0m/kWh.

Not really bothered, jut thought it was a little funny.

The 5 does seem to have an efficiency range of between 3 and 4.5 from the ~1.5-2k miles we have done so far.
 
There are other examples as well comparing EV and ICE performance in snow I just linked to that one.

They also looked at things like hill climbing and braking distances, etc. it all plays into how well the different vehicles handle in the snow - while 0-60 times alone don't mean much you can combine all the data points to see how they cope in challenging conditions.

My main argument has been that it is a mixed bag with a lot of conditions/variables and while EVs can do better when the electronics can cope i.e. often the limits of an inexperienced driver it can be a more complicated story when pushing the limits and with a more experienced driver actively managing the situation, depending a bit on the features of the car.
So it’s mainly the tyre then. As I tried to summarise when I said heavy car and narrow tyres.

long posts aren’t helpful especially when they aren’t really saying anything and just posting random videos and derails everything as evident by mods actions
 
Last edited:
Ioniq 5 was being a derp this morning. 5 miles into the journey and the rated efficiency was showing as 1.1 (:eek:) but the "since charge" was in the low-mid 3's.

The efficiency "bar" below the dials was showing the same as the "since charge" rating so I think the journey efficiency was factoring in the climate blasting for a few mins before setting off as 0m/kWh.

Not really bothered, jut thought it was a little funny.

The 5 does seem to have an efficiency range of between 3 and 4.5 from the ~1.5-2k miles we have done so far.
Does the 5 still have the winter mode setting? I think turning that off reduces the amount of battery heating for max performance and charging, clearly not really needed for a commute (unless it includes frozen lake time trials)
 
Does the 5 still have the winter mode setting? I think turning that off reduces the amount of battery heating for max performance and charging, clearly not really needed for a commute (unless it includes frozen lake time trials)

I believe the Ioniq 5 can have the Winter mode setting but not sure if its tied to having the optional battery warmer / heat pump. Ours is a 2021 RWD 58kWh model* so I don't think it has either. Need to check if we have the Winter mode option in the EV settings as not I can't remember seeing it.
 
Thanks The one I had for a weekend had it a while back. Can’t recall the spec but I thought it was handy. My ipace is trying to get into race car mode heat every drive. Would rather turn off for a commute.
 
Charged the Leaf last night and discovered the problem with having the charge flap in front of the bonnet, it was packed with snow this morning!! Once I cleared that lot out I got into the car to turn it on while having the door open because I still had to clear the car. The idea was to whack the heating up to help thaw the snow from the windows and roof. What actually happened was the windscreen wipers came on and dumped a load of snow on me and the inside of the car, bloody automatic wipers!! It's been one of those days.
 
After being assured by one of the EV team at my workplace that our new to us Kona EV will not explode if I charged it to 100%, I took the plunge and charged to 100% overnight instead of up to the usual 80%.

Happy to report that there was no explosion and it cost £7.44 to charge from 40% - 100%
Now we just need to get you on a run and you arrive back home with less than 5%, without breaking into a sweat
 
I passed one of these on the way to the airport this morning - a Mustang Mach E stretched limousine:


I have many questions about stretching a battery pack…
Recently buried my mate, he requested one of these electric hearse and limousine, didn't really pay much attention to it with more going on, but they did look really nice!
 
ICE pleb here. I've been in negotiations with my wife for a while now about getting a small EV to replace her ageing Tiguan; I'm thinking Renault 5 or the like. Just to add an arrow to my quiver, am I right in saying that the wading depth of an EV drastically beats just about any ICE vehicle? She was recently griping about not being able to (or rather not feeling confident that her vehicle could) cross a flooded section of road recently.
 
So it’s mainly the tyre then. As I tried to summarise when I said heavy car and narrow tyres.

long posts aren’t helpful especially when they aren’t really saying anything and just posting random videos and derails everything as evident by mods actions

I wasn't just commenting on what you posted but also related to the post chain you replied to. I find there is a curious inability to follow context in these motors threads.

It wasn't a random video, the content is directly relevant to the original post on the subject, though it is only a piece of the whole subject.

The tyre is a crucial element but you need to then do something with that contact point - it doesn't mean much if the car then lacks the refinement to preserve traction.
 
We are talking about modern cars not a model T. The tyre contact patch and force on it is the critical. F=mu.R after all. This is why EVs are good in snow. Generally narrow tyres and higher mass than ice vehicles. Physics wins.

I have no idea what you mean by refinement or going on about driver experience being a factor But I’ll leave it here as you have only added third party links and info rather than your own. The video you couldn’t even remember the result of it so I’m still perplexed. Not sure it’s within the context of ice vs EV

Reminds me of people who answer Facebook questions by copying and pasting a AI reply. I don’t understand the pleasure of being a conduit ?
 
Last edited:
ICE pleb here. I've been in negotiations with my wife for a while now about getting a small EV to replace her ageing Tiguan; I'm thinking Renault 5 or the like. Just to add an arrow to my quiver, am I right in saying that the wading depth of an EV drastically beats just about any ICE vehicle? She was recently griping about not being able to (or rather not feeling confident that her vehicle could) cross a flooded section of road recently.

EVs are far less likely to be damaged by flood water, wading depth kind of has a different meaning with them as you can't kill the engine via water intake from the air box though depending on drive setup thing like axle breathers may be a consideration. At the end of the day though if the water is above the ground clearance and/or poor driving approach there is a big luck factor unless the vehicle is built for wading - I won't rush to enter water deeper than half way up my wheels even in off-road vehicles.

She might find the change from the Tiguan to the Renault 5 quite considerable though and not everyone is comfortable with that degree of change.
 
We are talking about modern cars not a model T. The tyre contact patch and force on it is the critical. F=mu.R after all. This is why EVs are good in snow. Generally narrow tyres and higher mass than ice vehicles. Physics wins.

I have no idea what you mean by refinement or going on about driver experience being a factor But I’ll leave it here as you have only added third party links and info rather than your own. The video you couldn’t even remember the result of it so I’m still perplexed. Not sure it’s within the context of ice vs EV

Reminds me of people who answer Facebook questions by copying and pasting a AI reply. I don’t understand the pleasure of being a conduit ?

Unfortunately it isn't that simple - take the latest incarnation of the the X-Trail for example which Nissan are desperately trying to market as a lifestyle off-roader - it will just spin up the motors until drivetrain malfunction in some challenging circumstances where other vehicles with the same weight and tyres can manage.

It isn't just about vehicle weight but the contact patch - a lighter vehicle with more weight over the driven axle and/or depending on ability to divert power to different wheels can do better than a heavier vehicle and after a certain point the weight can be undesirable in managing the overall dynamics and getting moving.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately it isn't that simple - take the latest incarnation of the the X-Trail for example which Nissan are desperately trying to market as a lifestyle off-roader - it will just spin up the motors until drivetrain malfunction in some challenging circumstances where other vehicles with the same weight and tyres can manage.
And you talk about people not following context, I am talking generally. Why is everying so Nissan-centric in your posts? Again massive derail
 
Last edited:
And you talk about people not following context, I am talking generally. Why is everying so Nissan-centric in you posts?

It is just one example that things aren't as simple when it comes to vehicles and snow capabilities as you are making out. I could use other examples but it is one of the more contrasting ones.
 
Back
Top Bottom