• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

EV general discussion

Hello, was the ID3 Pro Max a big seller? I like the combination of electric seats and DCC as standard, but Autotrader reports only 12 being available from £10,000 to £20,000
I had a 2021 ID.3 Pro Max (from new).

The problem was originally they were overpriced to a point they cost the same as a Tesla Model 3.. I negotiated £6k off list which made it 'OK' but imagine when spending over £40k on one, it was really poor VFM..

However, as you have spotted it comes with a lot of kit, the Travel Assist/Heads Up/Pan Roof and DCC all made it that bit better, and we miss ours a little (moved to a Tesla Model Y as the kids became adult sized)..

Compared to driving a standard ID.3, it's really the DCC that only marginally differentiates itself, it certainly can be slight more comfortable through to slightly more sporty than a regular ID.3, but it's not necessarily night/day.

But for the money, I prefer the Ioniq 5 Ultimate, those have come down now and I was almost going to get one over the ID.3, but they wanted closer to £50k with terrible finance rates when brand new..
 
Fwd EV are terrible in winter though

My Leaf is by far the best and easiest car I have ever had for winter driving. We had a lot of snow up here last winter and it was a joy to drive, no sliding, no lock ups, no wheel spinning, just worry free motoring. I have Dunlop Allseason 2 tyres on all four corners so that would have helped but I have had either full winter tyres or all season tyres on the previous three cars I have owned and they were nowhere near as planted as the Leaf.

I was out on the road when my neighbour couldn't even get his BMW M2 out of his drive.
 
Ok my comment was in the context of acceleration and more performance oriented cars, we were talking sub 5 cars and then need for performance and how EVs tend to have very good traction control (for obvious reasons as they just spin up if left uncontrolled) I guess my ‘winter’ meant cold crappy roads when fwd struggle with grip and torque steer all over the place.

A heavy car with narrow, all season tyres will be good in the snow.
 
Last edited:
The basic warranty just expired on our Model Y. I’m mildly nervous to say the least :eek:

#YOLO

Other than the suspension (which is cheap), they are generally considered reliable and you have 8 years/120k on the battery and motor.

Absolutely shed loads of cheap used parts available also.
 
Last edited:
I had a 2021 ID.3 Pro Max (from new).

The problem was originally they were overpriced to a point they cost the same as a Tesla Model 3.. I negotiated £6k off list which made it 'OK' but imagine when spending over £40k on one, it was really poor VFM..

However, as you have spotted it comes with a lot of kit, the Travel Assist/Heads Up/Pan Roof and DCC all made it that bit better, and we miss ours a little (moved to a Tesla Model Y as the kids became adult sized)..

Compared to driving a standard ID.3, it's really the DCC that only marginally differentiates itself, it certainly can be slight more comfortable through to slightly more sporty than a regular ID.3, but it's not necessarily night/day.

But for the money, I prefer the Ioniq 5 Ultimate, those have come down now and I was almost going to get one over the ID.3, but they wanted closer to £50k with terrible finance rates when brand new..

Yes, list price was crazy, but lucky for me so is depreciation.

Thanks for the comments on DCC, did you notice the progressive steering, good/bad?

The Ioniq 5 is certainly impressive and is also good value used (under 20,000 as well) but far too big for the work car park.
 
Well a totally different experience with Tesla. All arranged online then meet at a "pop up" center in a shopping mall. Within minutes the car was set to the Tesla app and I was told where to find it and see you in an hour!

I was told the car was a M3 Highland Dual Motor as last year I took out a single motor. This car felt very quick, no rattles, very comfortable and I liked it a lot. However, when I got home i put the reg into Total Car Check and it came up as the Long Range Rear Wheel Drive. Now either they have it listed wrong or that's what I was given to test drive. If it was the LR RWD then I'm impressed.

Although I cant stand Musk the car was very good!
 
Thanks for the comments on DCC, did you notice the progressive steering, good/bad?
I used to throw ours around on the limit to see how it would react and the steering always felt slightly less connected than ideal, but that would be mainly as my other car was a BMW M3 Convertible, so I'd say it was OK.. the DCC was (for me) more obvious.

Remember, EVs have their weight low down, so when cornering hard, there is less weight transfer side to side, you don't get that progression on the front end, so front end feedback is always a bit numb before it starts to wash wide..
 
The basic warranty just expired on our Model Y. I’m mildly nervous to say the least :eek:

Other than the suspension (which is cheap), they are generally considered reliable and you have 8 years/120k on the battery and motor.
Absolutely shed loads of cheap used parts available also.
^ this

the main components are covered for 8 years (HV batt + motors)
i think the only thing i would be wary is if the heat pump goes...but then AC failure is not unheard of even in ICE vehicles, so basically much the same as in any car
 
Corsa nicely told us that our free six months of whatever it’s called is up and the app is now useless unless we pay £8.99 a month. Bit crap but only really used it to check the charge level before setting the charger. The Ioniq 5 is nearly 3 and have full app access. Stellantis being a bit tight.
Yeah, same happened on my Astra. I'm absolutely certain that when I got it remote key (which I only ever used to switch on the climate control) was included for life free of charge, but I didn't screenshot the page. Maybe it has always been the case but it now is part of the connected plus pack. Also had things showing in the app as "available" yet when you go to activate them they are paywalled.

The app is rubbish anyway so that is no loss but it was nice to have a backup sat nav with traffic information for those times you set off in a mobile dead spot. Combined with the fact it used to try and push me accessories for my "Peugeot" and swapped to French at random I binned it off my work phone and will just have to schedule the pre-conditioning in the car when it gets frosty. Seems a big waste of energy though, especially when I get held up and the thing is sat there cooking for 20 minutes.

Talk of updates, again another Stellantis fail - five times my car has said it needs to do a 21 minute update and five times I hit install and it fails at the 5% point with a nice white square in the dash that was an uh-oh moment the first time I saw it. This stuff just needs to work, or simply don't bother. I only went to install it in the first place to stop getting the prompt on the dash. Until an OTA update can sort the **** build quality, rattles and key that doesn't work just leave me alone!
 
Sounds like you have had a bad time with the Astra. Corsa apart from the app has been ok so far. I did an update yesterday and it took about 15 mins updating the sat nav I think might be the same one but it went ok. I’m sure once it ages a bit the rattles and stellantis quality will come through but the wife likes it so I can’t really complain.
 
Sounds like you have had a bad time with the Astra. Corsa apart from the app has been ok so far. I did an update yesterday and it took about 15 mins updating the sat nav I think might be the same one but it went ok. I’m sure once it ages a bit the rattles and stellantis quality will come through but the wife likes it so I can’t really complain.
Yeah, I'm glad your experience has been different to mine. It is a company hack that I stick 25k a year on so on the one hand I'm not too worried but I certainly wouldn't recommend a Vauxhall based on my experience. Doesn't help that it turns out my local dealer is utterly useless as well.

When you are more worried about getting your "Vauxhall &YOU" branding up than actually serving customers and completing the work that the car is booked in for you know you are on the downward slide.

My next car budget will be as poor as the last one and I'm determined to go full EV now HMRC have sorted themselves out so I'll probably end up looking to one of the Chinese brands :(
 
Just a heads up to anybody trying to onboard an EVSE with IOG, it will fail and you will need to get the option added by Octopus Energy customer services, they are trying to get people to integrate the car, rather than the charger.
 
They want to integrate with the car if both are supported so they can read the SOC.

This is due to all the above of people gaming the system by setting their chargers to +100% with an early ready time daily so the only way they can possible charge the car in time is to charge it at peak times. The car only charges for a few hours in reality because it only needs a 20% charge.

P.S. if you object to this, the trick is to select a non supported car with a similar/larger battery size and your charger will be enrolled.
 
They want to integrate with the car if both are supported so they can read the SOC.

This is due to all the above of people gaming the system by setting their chargers to +100% with an early ready time daily so the only way they can possible charge the car in time is to charge it at peak times. The car only charges for a few hours in reality because it only needs a 20% charge.

P.S. if you object to this, the trick is to select a non supported car with a similar/larger battery size and your charger will be enrolled.
it does worry me that people gaming the system will ultimately ruin it for everyone else by forcing octopus to tighten up and then none of us get as good a product.

directly supporting the car (at least when my car was supported) was not a great experience. I only had to put up with it for a short time whilst my zappi was still unsupported, but i found when my car was controlling it i would get up to 10 mins of charging at full price before my car correctly reported to octopus and they took control.

10 mins may not sound like much but it was probably getting on for 1.5kwh of energy which charged me at full bubble and added up over time.
 
Back
Top Bottom