AsusUpdate is perfectly stable!
Also I have read many an occasion when a DOS update has gone wrong due too dodgy corrupt floppys and unstable memory problems.
Ive been here since 2002 according to my profile, and have seen few BIOS upgrades fail when using floppys.
I have seen many on this forum have failures with the ASUS updater though.
This updater was released around the time of the ASUS A7N8X board (nvidia AMD socket 462)
That board was very prone to BIOS failures just by changing a setting, but the ASUS updater seemed to work on that board.
The ALT + F2 was a different story, and only launched for 50% of those who tried it.
Recently ASUS have stopped fitting a removable BIOS chip, and its around this time we get many people with failed flashes using the updater.
I'm not suggesting that has anything to do with it, BUT its the same time as the socket 775 board becomes popular.
If this forum stored stuff for 3 years or more I could show you what I mean, but I'm afraid you'll just have to take my word for it as a regular forum user!
It is NOT a good idea to use the ASUS updater as it's prone to failure.
A USB stick and ALT + F2 is far better IMO.