Soldato
8 and 9 had the same turn base combat as I recall, they just did not have the material system maybe? Been so long that I forgot. I need to replay 8 and 9 at some point. I know for a fact I only play FF 9 only on release and never since. I just remember the card game it had a bit and the main character a little. No memory of the story or side characters whatsoever. Where as FF 7 was very memorable and since played it maybe 5 times.
8 had the awful level system and the draw mechanic which was absolutely awful. Plus the GF boost which ruined my fingers trying to max it out on all but Eden. 9 was amazing though.
Most of the people who complain were either fans of the first or fourth installment, and many of them ended their unwavering devotion around the ages of 7 or 8. From game number one through game number six, every setting was quite identical.
I mean, they're not even remotely identical lol - play three and four side by side and they're set in very, very different places. The only thing was there wasn't as much customisation on graphics back then.