These threads irritate me, why is it that people who don't have a clue what they are talking about act as if they are experts and give out advice as if it's fact?
The situation regarding premium increases seems to depend on the insurance driver as highlighted in my own experiences below:
1.) My wife got rear ended by a MAP Plant van driver as he wasn't paying attention when approaching a fork in the road - I could see him looking down whilst rolling a cig in the rear view mirror instead of looking ahead. Wife let her own insurance company deal with the claim and there was no impact on her renewal or mine (as I had to declare her accident due to her being a named driver).
2.) I was involved in an accident with a sleepy bus driver on a Sunday morning who cut a round about which resulted in him scraping up the inside of my car. A non fault specialist (Europa) took on the case and said there was sufficient evidence to proove I was not at fault but I was not happy with the way the case was being dealt with (long delays and Europa recommended I did not repair the car (which was barely a week old! in the interim) and then the bus company maliciously put a claim in with my insurance despite no damage. Bottom line was that to protect my no claims I foolishly removed my claim against them and paid for the cost of repairs myself.
I did the above thinking that I would be out of pocket for the repair work (~£800) and that would be it, how wrong was I? My insurance come renewal went up ~£150, I called admiral and asked why and they explained I was statistically more likely to be involved in another collision due to being a non-fault driver despite having never raised a claim (I just informed them of the incident as per my legal obligation).
So, to summarise, I paid £800 out of my own pocket for a half arsed repair (new wing, repaired bumper, polished wheel and light cluster) vs replacements and now have to stomach ~£150 extra a year on my insurance premium where as if I had of pursued the insurance claim at worst I would have been out my excess at ~£300 and about ~£50 /year for declaring an accident that was my fault.
People seem to assume/expect the insurance system to be fair, it's not and nor is it designed to be!