Fixed Penalties!!

Associate
Joined
23 Jun 2005
Posts
2,495
Location
On the Edge*
Parking: You park on double yellow lines and a traffic wardens issue us ticket, and a fixed penalty fine that if you do not pay within a required time limit, will double. It will continue to accumulate until you pay. The circumstances upon which you needed to park on the yellow lines are not taken into consideration. You parked on double yellow lines, you know the rules, you have to pay the penalty.

Speeding: If you break the speed limit on the road, you receive 3 points on your license and again a fixed penalty. Same rules apply. The circumstances, whether that be driving a friend to a hospital in an emergency are the same. You broke the rules, you pay the fine.

If you continue to break the law, your points build up which eventually leads to you losing your license. You are hit financially, more points generally means an increase in car insurance.


So there you have it. Fixed penalties, do they work? Well; yeah!

Which leads us to…?

Burglary: When a burglar breaks into your house or your car, and steals your possessions.

Vandalism: People who graffiti walls, smashing bus shelters and telephone boxes. Public disorder and anti social behaviour causes misery to the lives of the people who live in the surrounding communities.

Joyriding: Someone who steals your car that may have cost you thousands of pounds, that of which you are working hard to pay for. Driven on the road without insurance and often dangerously. (What a god awful expression joyriding is when its causes so many people such despair)

Why not fixed jail terms?

Mitigating circumstances: What mitigating circumstances?

If you burglarise someone, surely you are fully conscious and aware of what you are doing. The law says that “you could” face jail if caught. I want the law to say that “you will” go to jail, and for a long time if caught.

By what scale do you think the reduction in crime would be if there where fixed penalties issued to people who are convicted of such crimes. If burglary was a 5 year jail sentence, hard labour? Joyriding and Vandalism 5 years, no parole

Are my thoughts to draconian?

As you can probably tell, I don’t know the inns and outs or the law. But, I do know right from wrong, and so do those who commit these crimes. In Countries where crimes of this nature are dealt with harshly, the problems are massively reduced. Personally I would prefer bringing back public flogging and have those who thinks its funny to steal your car and burglarise your house whipped in the market on a Saturday afternoon, and while they cry, there friends can be reminded of what will happen to them if they get caught.
 
-|ScottFree|- said:
I don’t know the inns and outs or the law. But, I do know right from wrong, and so do those who commit these crimes.
For sake of provenance - I'm not fully up to speed with the ins and outs either, I also know right from wrong.

As far as I'm aware, however, there's far less black and white, and far more grey area - Various crimes do indeed have statutory sentences (some of which are blatantly too short, others too long - but that's not at issue here), but these may be commuted (or extended) due to other factors - Just because you don't believe in mitigating factors, it doesn't mean that they don't exist.

-|ScottFree|- said:
In Countries where crimes of this nature are dealt with harshly, the problems are massively reduced.
That' s not actually true, although I would be more that happy to defer to a verifiable citation.
 
Your ideas are sound my friend. The criminal justice system is a joke and PERSISTANT offenders get let off most things, get away with most of what they get charged for and if they do get convicted the punishment is laughable. As such they do not fear the system and have no problems re-offending time and time again

It's all a game to them and some of them play it very well
 
Borris, I digress

My brother studied East Asian business & finance at Sheffield University and left here 6 years ago to finish his degree and work in Japan. His intention was to continue to study while obtaining employment which would hopefully open doors for him on his return back to this country.


During his first 18 months, my brother was homesick. On his return, he realised that he wasn’t missing a thing, and could not wait to go back to Japan.

Educated British people are leaving these shores in droves. One of the fundamental reasons for them leaving is to improve there standard and quality of life, lower crime levels are a major contributory factor. People are getting sick of the criminal being treated as victim.
 
Back
Top Bottom