• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Free Speech -A Victory?

Are they actually scrapping Section 5 or just amending it?

It does annoy me that the police can effectively use it to arrest anyone they want given taking offence is purely subjective.

Arresting people for swearing for example is just plain stupid. Pretty much all adults swear now and then, being arrested for it is the definition of a nanny state and makes the police more akin to strict parents than it does to keepers of law and order.
 
They are just removing the word 'insulting' from Section 5, nothing else. You can still be arrested for being abusive, threatening either in language or behaviour. I suspect that in practical terms there is little difference as most insulting words/behaviour can be categorised as abusive as well.

Ahead of the Lords vote, Director of Public Prosecutions Keir Starmer wrote: "We are unable to identify a case in which the alleged behaviour leading to conviction could not properly be characterised as 'abusive' as well as 'insulting'.

"I therefore agree that the word 'insulting' could safely be removed without the risk of undermining the ability of the CPS to bring prosecutions."
 
They are just removing the word 'insulting' from Section 5, nothing else. You can still be arrested for being abusive, threatening either in language or behaviour. I suspect that in practical terms there is little difference as most insulting words/behaviour can be categorised as abusive as well.

The fact that insulting has been purposefully removed gives a clear new interpretation - merely being insulting is not enough.

There is a big distinction between insulting and abusive. To be abusive is to be above and beyond insulting. I have no problem with protection against those being abusive.

Big thumbs up from me.
 
The fact that insulting has been purposefully removed gives a clear new interpretation - merely being insulting is not enough.

There is a big distinction between insulting and abusive. To be abusive is to be above and beyond insulting. I have no problem with protection against those being abusive.

Big thumbs up from me.

It was only really a problem if you believed the crap the daily mail spout.
 
The fact that insulting has been purposefully removed gives a clear new interpretation - merely being insulting is not enough.

There is a big distinction between insulting and abusive. To be abusive is to be above and beyond insulting. I have no problem with protection against those being abusive.

Big thumbs up from me.

Hmmm, I think that anything that could have got you arrested under a Public 5 before will still be the case after. Which is pretty much was the CoPP stated. You still won't be able to go about swearing at people (or police) or calling them all sorts of nonsense as some seem to think is their right under free speech, also what might seem a trivial insult to one person can be considered abusive or threatening or both to someone else.

It might limit arrests for some of the silly stuff like the chap with his Scientology Placard (was he even charged?) but I doubt it will allow someone to hurl insults at someone just because they are different (colour, creed, weight, and so on) as that can easily be construed as abuse (even though it is an insult).
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, I think that anything that could have got you arrested under a Public 5 before will still be the case after. Which is pretty much was the CoPP stated. You still won't be able to go about swearing at people (or police) or calling them all sorts of nonsense as some seem to think is their right under free speech, also what might seem a trivial insult to one person is considered abusive or threatening or both to someone else.

It might limit arrests for some of the silly stuff like the chap with his Scientology Placard (was he even charged?) but I doubt it will allow someone to hurl insults at someone just because they are different (colour, creed, weight, and so on) as that can easily be construed as abuse (even though it is an insult).

The fact it has been removed is indicative of change. Judges do not look at language in a vacuum. Of course, some, many or most previous arrests will still be possible post-change.
 
i'd rather not unless pushed..

i dont agree with them scrapping it at all, i think the police have a hard enough job without being insulted and not being able to do a thing
 
i'd rather not unless pushed..

i dont agree with them scrapping it at all, i think the police have a hard enough job without being insulted and not being able to do a thing

If strangers calling you names gets to you that much I'd imagine the Police isn't a ideal line of work for you. You should have the right to be a dick to others if you want, they need to stop arresting people who have posted a few dick things on facebook/twitter to.
 
Back
Top Bottom