Oh man, this thread brings back memories.....
Being such a big B5 fan I loved Freespace 1 & 2.
It's only by chance I actually found the game, as I got it free with my Logitech Interceptor Joystick (The BEST joystick I've ever used, buttons everywhere but all correctly place, 3 hat stwitchs, it was bliss).
Cracked open the box of my Interceptor and out plonks a free game "Woo" I thought "Bet it won't be much good...Decent Freespace...hmm".
I set my joystick, install the game, and am greeted by one of THE best Intro movies I've ever seen, brilliant music, I was already hooked.
I couldn't fly worth **** when I started, I pretty much rammed the enemy ships to death, but alas, I soon mastered the controls and then played through the campaign, again and again and again and again.
And now suddenly I realise I'm not talking to my grandchildren and feel slightly embrassed

.
To cut a long story short yeah, Both FS1 & 2 are great, I do prefer 1 though, only because the Lucifer is the Best bada$$ ship ever.