I just don't know why the other half adores this show.
TBH it is a show you either are into for the interpersonal drama and characters i.e. soap opera (not my cup of tea) or for the vibe and immersion (which is why I watch it), anyone actually wanting a focussed developing story it isn't the show for. Though some aspects are getting a bit tedious or implausible even for me i.e. the earlier mentioned lack of belief and surprise, etc. when someone sees/mentions something strange right after experiencing something strange themselves in a town full of strange happenings.

. I'd like to think we will get a lot more answers in the final season.