• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Fun petrol for under £8k

Soldato
Joined
15 Aug 2010
Posts
8,998
Location
N. Ireland
Hi all,

After "owning" a 14 plate 1.2 TSI Leon for the last 4 months of which half of it was spent at the dealers trying to fix an engine issue, I'm on the lookout for a replacement. My circumstances have also changed during this time where I went from travelling 200+ miles a week to work to just driving to the train station.

Here's my current use and requirements;
- 2 miles every weekday with the weekends possibly doing 100 miles round trip
- big enough to carry two bikes(tow bar carrier) and camping stuff
- cruise control
- have power when I need it yet returning 30+ mpg doing the above miles(is this even possible?)

I have looked at the following cars below and would appreciate any opinions on them or any other suggestions worth looking at.


Ecoboost Focus 15 plate - has the power/mpg/space

Leon FR Mk3 DSG - exception on price as this is the dealer in question

I've also looked at more "grown up" cars below;

a5 2.0TFSI, short MOT

bmw 320i, not the fanciest dash

lexus Is250, not sure about the wooden trims


As a curved ball(being sensible), would a FN2 1.8 Type S GT for £2k be worth a shout considering the amount of miles I'll be doing. It has the usual toys bar bluetooth, good compromise on the performace/mpg, reliable v-tec engine?

Any help/suggestions are appreciated.
 
Not sure any of them are all that FUN tbh.

A mk2 Focus ST will get 30mpg if you are really careful, just about :p

I guess fun is subjective. I'm coming from 100bhp hatch so anything faster in the same size will be fun for me.

Before anyone suggests I'm sure mx5s and s2ks are fun for a lot of people but it's not practical in my situation. I could probably just make an exception for Mk7 fiesta st, cooper s/jcws, 208gti but still prefer the bigger models.
 
The A5, 320 or is250 are never going to define anyone's idea of "fun" so bin them straight away. They all will also come with potentially crippling dealer costs (albeit Lexus is less likely). If you wanted relative luxury and build quality for the size the posh Toyota would have been more sensible.

The civic (not an fn2 btw) will likely be a decent car and they're very reliable, but again just won't be fun as they're slow but economical. If you want a Civic buy an actual FN2 - good to throw around and new enough that you can still find a decent car , just don't pay over the odds.

Leon's are decent cars but come with VAG breaking potential, whilst the Focus would be fine tbh

In your position I'd probably buy a Swift Sport or maybe even an old Panda sport and rag the **** off the thing every day (little Abarths also look hilarious).

Alternatively if you can find a decent one the C30 T5 makes a relatively interesting choice
 
Lexus dealers are probably the best around for service, so I wouldn't worry about that (they also never break so you probably won't need them). But they aren't fun cars unless you're going for the big engined sporty ones, which cost a lot more than 8k.

Tiny hot hatches are fun, but less practical.
 
You should be able to get a decent Golf GTI (mk5) Edition 30 for that budget. I loved mine. I found mine excellent to be fair, and one of the few cars I'd consider getting again.

Close to mk6 GTI money there too though. So a bit more modern. Still think I'd go for the ED30 though.
 
The 1.6 and 2.0 ecoboost engines have been quite reliable so far (the smaller ones not as much). As long as the recall for the cooling issue has been done.
 
Last edited:
No recall for the 2.0 btw, that car looks quite suspiciously cheap but i'm saying that from a slightly (perhaps unrealistic) skewed viewpoint of what I would expect my estate to be worth despite being a year older.

Not sure the mileage is any sort of issue other than the fact the car will be harder to shift on again in future for you as people still have a fear of cars approaching/over 100k.

I'd want to check the history to make sure it's really a full history, double check the MOT thoseas apparently it expired in November, wheels are a horrible colour and you need to drive it to see if it feels loose/baggy as a full suspension refresh isn't particularly cheap if you want oem (mine is starting to feel like it could do with a refresh at 60k).
 
As mentioned, fun is subjective. I'd love to hoon around in one of the hot superminis but I need the space of the bigger models.

I guess the question is better asked as
"Could I do better than the focus/Leon posted for my usage"
 
I've owned my 2008 is250 for over a year now. I won't classify it as fun it does do alright and drives perfect but it isn't fun.

It is super reliable and very well equipped compared to anything from germany or anywhere else, drives great and is very comfortable. Mine is an SE-L trim so basically top spec other than sunroof.

Mine has done 115k+ miles and in the last 8 years only needed a battery cable and servicing. Which all in is not too bad at the main dealer, £250ish for interim service and 400ish for major.
 
This sounds very much like Golf GTI territory to me OP.

Fun, practical, 30mpg, easily comfy enough to do 100 mile trips and should have cruise control.

The downside being the GTI badge premium leaves you with an older car than other hot hatch options.

Not sure I'd want an £8k Audi or BMW.
 
Obligatory Mazda 3MPS mk2 recommendation here...you'd get two bikes in the boot by dropping the back seats. Ticks all the boxes and has loads of toys, cruise, really comfy, excellent sound system and IMO looks much better than it's cousin, the Focus ST (both cars share a lot of DNA)

30MPG is achievable on longer trips...if you can behave :D

Did a 350 mile round trip on Sunday down through the welsh valleys and it is definitely a fun drive.

Also coming from your 100bhp to circa 260bhp, you'll see quite a difference.
 
There's a few Vauxhall Astra GTC/Turbo's floating around on Autotrader for less than your budget. 1.6 petrol turbo, 197bhp. I've driven the latter and it felt fairly nippy.
 
After ahing and uhming about my choices and an annoyed GF, we sort of agreed that we can fit the tow bar on her diesel Corsa to take on trips with the bikes.
This leaves me with a new shortlist of "fun" less practical cars.

MK5 GTI
https://rmsmotoring.com/classifieds/used-cars/volkswagen/golf/volkswagen-golf-20-gti-sa08uom/3705

RS250 Cup
https://rmsmotoring.com/classifieds/used-cars/renault/megane/renault-megane-rs/3689

Mk7 Fiesta ST
https://www.usedcarsni.com/2014-Ford-Fiesta-1-6-Ecoboost-St-2-3Dr-254952567

Cooper S
https://www.usedcarsni.com/2011-MINI-Cooper-S-1-6-3-Door-Hatchback-255328218

Jack of all trades? Octavia VRS estate
https://www.usedcarsni.com/2013-Skoda-Octavia-2-0-TSI-vRS-5dr-255025993
 
You should be able to get a decent Golf GTI (mk5) Edition 30 for that budget. I loved mine. I found mine excellent to be fair, and one of the few cars I'd consider getting again.

Close to mk6 GTI money there too though. So a bit more modern. Still think I'd go for the ED30 though.
Just to add...


Tr4MIwq.webp
Clicky


I3XjZm7.webp
Clicky
 
Back
Top Bottom