Give me a networking solution

Caporegime
Joined
6 Dec 2005
Posts
37,947
Location
Birmingham
It's either going to be homeplugs or wiring up some of the house.


Here is a very crude paint drawing of the downstairs.

XI16X



The blue boxes are power sockets. Need living room, bedroom 2 wired. Maybe bedroom 3 as well.

Fuse box etc is in a cupboard by the front door, the phone master socket (little red box of drawing) is on the end of that with 2 plug sockets above it. Currently powering the phone (cordless, other station is in the kitchen) and the router. Going to get a XTE-2005 to replace the current faceplate of the master socket.

In the living room (bottom right hand corner) there is going to be Sky HD box & HTPC which will need to be connected to the network. Sky box for Anytime+. Now then there is a double socket there which needs to power the TV, Sky box, HTPC, AV receiver and the sub.

Homeplug way would be using a pass through at the router (saves using an extension adapter), then two extension adapters in the living room. One to power stuff, the other for the home plugs. Or would a switch in the living room be better?

HTPC & Sky box ---> switch ---> homeplug

Sky Anytime+ work okay going through a homeplug? And the obvious there isn't going to be a problem with several devices going through one homeplug?

And there may also need to be a NAS connected to the network some point in the future.


Bedroom 2 needs to be connected as well because that's my room. :p

So that's 3 homeplugs at a minimum. Any recommendations on homeplugs?


The other way, which would probably annoy my Mum would be to just connect the router to a switch in the loft and then run Cat5e/6 to the various rooms. But that'll take a bit more time, effort and some planning, but it would be future proof I suppose.


So what to do chaps?
 
If there is no need for any heavy data transfer over the network then you could go the homeplug route, with all homeplugs leading back to a single data switch just outside the living room. I know years ago when the homeplug technology came out it was dire, i certainly had huge problems with it but i think its much better now. D-Link, Zyxel or Linksys would be a good place to start.

Did you consider a wireless solution?
 
As above, If you're just streaming media around (even 1080p x254's) and general internet/gaming access, just homeplug your rooms. The TP-Link 200Mb plugs are good and give you around 80Mb/s real world throughput in one direction (from my own experience)

I did eventually move to a wired network for my living room becasue I needed the homeplugs elsewhere. Takes a little longer to setup, but it's actually cheaper and doesn't look too bad - just pick up self adhesive cable covers that stick on the walls to hide the cables.
 
Back
Top Bottom