Goldeneye vs. Perfect Dark

Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
37,100
This converstion has loomed amongst friends for quite awhile, so in order to end the dispute (Which is the better game), I went out and bought Perfect Dark today (I had sold it previously). They guy in shop even asked me which was better as some kind of test, and my reply made him almost cry with frustration. Seems its quite the divider!

For the longest time I have campagned that Goldeneye has and always will be the far, far superior game. Everything about it was just perfect (aside from the hassel of frame rates *sigh*), Perfect Dark somehow took all the single player elements that made Bond awesome... and wrecked it. Well, this was how I remembered it... so I have just played for a couple of hours to see what I thought.

I was absolutely right on the single player, perfect dark is hugely boring in comparison. Perhaps it helps unfairly that bond is obviously based on a film, but PD has such a wafer thin plot each level seems to have 'text book' written all over it. And why on earth is there so much lighting that drops the framerate, aghhhhhhhhhhh!

Of course... the reason why both are still played today is the multiplayer... and I think this is where perfect dark manages to catch up. Bots, more custom options, and slightly smoother gameplay give me the feeling that once I have everything unlocked and all weapons, perfect dark will be the better multiplayer experience. Just.

But... Bond will still be number one for me! What do you think?
 
goldeneye

proximity mines

paintball mode

oddjob

facility

level with air vents above toilet (maybe facility cant remember)

sean bean
 
Sorry but once Halo was released, its days as top console multiplayer shooter were finished. Perhaps even before but none spring to mind on balance.

But at the time of release I loved Goldeneye and played with my mates countless times, and of course the main game on all difficulty levels. No game has given me so much joy, but I've played it since and it just can't compare to more recent FPS games.
 
Last edited:
Perfect Dark. Story, graphics, experience was brilliant when it first game out.

Goldeneye I thought was skid-marked pants.
 
Back
Top Bottom