• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Greece Elections

Yeah they do tend to make it sound like the big nasty EU took their money away from them and won't give them it back rather than the EU giving them 250B Euro as lender of last resort.
 
Just wanted to post a comment from someone on the guardian which pretty much sums up the basic reason why we are in this situation and ties in with my previous comment on Germany wanting its pie (devalued currency to increase exports) and eat it (no singular backing of the currency), which also goes against Europe ideals that we are all European, we are all the same.


Sooner or later, someone will take a loss. Either voluntarily or when Greece defaults and goes bankrupt

This is why single currencies have to be backed by a single state, or they fail. A currency must be unconditionally supported by it's issuer - there should be no such thing as Greek or German debt, only Eurozone debt, backed absolutely by the united strength of the whole Eurozone. A Eurozone in which every citizen regards themselves as a euro-citizen first, a common identity and shared destiny that allows for direct transfers of cash from rich to poor areas, where dumping a weakest link (no matter how "badly behaved") is literally unthinkable

Instead the euro has shown itself as being 19 separate countries, where national identities are paramount, where there is no sharing of risk or debt let alone transfers of cash - and where in a time of crisis, disunity prevails as each member looks after it's own interest sand stuff everyone else

In the USA, all regard themselves as American, all states back the dollar unconditionally, there is a centralised federal government and treasury, big transfers between rich and poor states - and no one would even think of chucking out a State from the Union

Europe has shown itself a paper tiger, no one will ever take it seriously again. Yugoslavia, the migrant crisis, the euro - they have all shown that European unity is a fantasy, it does not exist
 
I don't see how they can leave gracefully, unless they give them some form of, go, leave, make your own currency, but you owe us £300B in 10 years, so a delayed debt until you setup your own country again in the messy fashion it might envelop.

I think the Greeks who voted No, fully expected Europe to come running with a new offer which didn't involve austerity. They seem unaware as to why anyone doesn't remotely want to give them anymore money.
Even in this thread. Also in the statements they made on the news, you'd think Europe gave them the debt, rather than their own governments over the past 30 years.

they had their chances and burnt their bridges. They had had several years to reform and have chosen to do nothing, so why do they now think it is the EU's responsibility to keep them liquid ? That's insane, it's like rocking up to a bank to get a loan defaulting, asking the bank for help, defaulting again and then expecting that they will carry on giving you cash. Gracefully or not Greece need to go, as a tax paying UK citizen whose government coughs up billions to be part of the EU I have a serious issue with giving those parasites for free cash. free because they have no intention of paying it back.
 
they had their chances and burnt their bridges. They had had several years to reform and have chosen to do nothing, so why do they now think it is the EU's responsibility to keep them liquid ? That's insane, it's like rocking up to a bank to get a loan defaulting, asking the bank for help, defaulting again and then expecting that they will carry on giving you cash. Gracefully or not Greece need to go, as a tax paying UK citizen whose government coughs up billions to be part of the EU I have a serious issue with giving those parasites for free cash. free because they have no intention of paying it back.

hang on, so are you implying that in the many pre-money releasing investigations that the Troika has done before releasing ANY money to Greece, they have not done their due diligence AGAIN?! or is it MAYBE POSSIBLE that Greece has implemented what they were supposed to, and instead hasn't worked like the Troika said it would?
 
hang on, so are you implying that in the many pre-money releasing investigations that the Troika has done before releasing ANY money to Greece, they have not done their due diligence AGAIN?! or is it MAYBE POSSIBLE that Greece has implemented what they were supposed to, and instead hasn't worked like the Troika said it would?

Define worked.

As it stands Greece is still a member of the EU.
 
hang on, so are you implying that in the many pre-money releasing investigations that the Troika has done before releasing ANY money to Greece, they have not done their due diligence AGAIN?! or is it MAYBE POSSIBLE that Greece has implemented what they were supposed to, and instead hasn't worked like the Troika said it would?

What you mean like every other time the imf have deflated an economy hasn't worked either?
 
Define worked.

As it stands Greece is still a member of the EU.

Sorry I'm confused by your comment.

I never said Greece is not a member of the EU.

What happens when a bailout is agreed is every X amount of time before releasing a part of the bailout money agreed the reforms have to become legislation. The Troika checks this and then reports back to the Eurogroup and the Eurogroup votes to release the funds.

So, Greece HAD TO HAVE IMPLEMENTED REFORMS before funds were released.

So what happened is the Troika's plan didn't work as they said it would (they said there would be growth after sometime.. and debt would come down.. neither of which have happened)
 
hang on, so are you implying that in the many pre-money releasing investigations that the Troika has done before releasing ANY money to Greece, they have not done their due diligence AGAIN?! or is it MAYBE POSSIBLE that Greece has implemented what they were supposed to, and instead hasn't worked like the Troika said it would?

so how come we don't see Spain doing what Greece are doing and they were under Troika measures as Greece. To date Spain have not defaulted on their loan agreements and haven't risked the economy of an entire region by wanting to retire at 50 without actually paying into their own system...................

The EU has a lot to answer for, but Greece has even more to answer to. I hope Merkel et al. keep their balls and tell Greece to do one. There is only so much free loading the EU can continue to absorb before it brings the entire region down again.

No one can keep a straight face and say Greece has tried to reform, because if they had really tried they would be in much better shape similar to Spain. Not necessarily out of the woods but not looking bankruptcy in the face as they do now.
 
so how come we don't see Spain doing what Greece are doing and they were under Troika measures as Greece. To date Spain have not defaulted on their loan agreements and haven't risked the economy of an entire region by wanting to retire at 50 without actually paying into their own system...................

The EU has a lot to answer for, but Greece has even more to answer to. I hope Merkel et al. keep their balls and tell Greece to do one. There is only so much free loading the EU can continue to absorb before it brings the entire region down again.

No one can keep a straight face and say Greece has tried to reform, because if they had really tried they would be in much better shape similar to Spain. Not necessarily out of the woods but not looking bankruptcy in the face as they do now.

If what you say is true this means that the Troika has failed to implement the checks it was formed to do, thereby throwing in the toilet taxpayer's money.

Is it possible that different economies require different measures?

Which one is it? Has the Troika of lenders failed to do what it was supposed to do BEFORE releasing funds?

Or has the programme devised by the lenders simply not worked, which has NOW (before the last release of funds of the second bailout) sparked outrage as it is evident that any measures taken so far are not working, so why should they carry on with the same strategy?

It makes the debt even more unsustainable which is not good for the people of Greece and in the end for the lenders as they will never see the money if it carries on like it is.

Also I fail to see any comments about Germany's position benefiting from the currency bloc but refusing to give back some of its gains by introducing a proper monetary union!
 
Spain debt to GDP has increased from 69.2% in 2012 when they had their bailout to 97.7% at the start of 2015

Deficit: from -9.4% to -5.8% (improvement here I'll give you that but still massively away...)

Unemployment: from 24.4% is now at 23.78%.. this has increased up to 26.94% in mid 2013 and dropped to 23.67% in mid 2014 but has since slightly rised.

Is this the thriving economy of Spain? 1/4 of unemployment after 4 years and a deficit of nearly 6% still with debt of nearly 100% of GDP?
 
Been to Birmingham and back today, actually had a fair few long trips.
So listening to radio 4 has been interesting

The Greeks (mainly young) voters who rejected the eu offer are living in a dream world
Calling the Germans terrorists
Believing the rest of Europe should come to their rescue
Genuinely believing they are going to get something better
This evening it seems different.. Reality is sinking in
This crowd cannot comprehend it is their country that isn't pulling is weight.
And that the rest of Europe owes them more, should help them, and that eurozone is as bad off as them

This referendum was a shambles
Eu should have made it clear no meant out

Something like 70pc want to stay in the euro but the tards voted against it genuinely believing they would be in a better place?
I wonder how the current government will be remembered
I bet they are bricking it

I don't blame the public for the anger, it just has been funneled at big bad Germany

They also show no sign of change. No pointing at their own government.

If Greece wanted money off me.. I damn sure wouldn't give any!
 
hang on, so are you implying that in the many pre-money releasing investigations that the Troika has done before releasing ANY money to Greece, they have not done their due diligence AGAIN?! or is it MAYBE POSSIBLE that Greece has implemented what they were supposed to, and instead hasn't worked like the Troika said it would?

I am sorry, you Greek apologist ;)
You fire around the term due diligence like it matters now.
It doesn't, what has passed has passed.
If they do any diligence now, it'll be to dump Greece, as hard as they can.
 
Been to Birmingham and back today, actually had a fair few long trips.
So listening to radio 4 has been interesting

The Greeks (mainly young) voters who rejected the eu offer are living in a dream world
Calling the Germans terrorists
Believing the rest of Europe should come to their rescue
Genuinely believing they are going to get something better
This evening it seems different.. Reality is sinking in
This crowd cannot comprehend it is their country that isn't pulling is weight.
And that the rest of Europe owes them more, should help them, and that eurozone is as bad off as them

This referendum was a shambles
Eu should have made it clear no meant out

Something like 70pc want to stay in the euro but the tards voted against it genuinely believing they would be in a better place?
I wonder how the current government will be remembered
I bet they are bricking it

I don't blame the public for the anger, it just has been funneled at big bad Germany

They also show no sign of change. No pointing at their own government.

If Greece wanted money off me.. I damn sure wouldn't give any!

Watching Panorama it seems to me it is not so much the young but the more wealthy that wanted the yes vote.

They have more to lose with leaving the single currency as the Drachma was a basket case.

Greece has very little in the way of welfare and with unemployment so high they would stand to lose the most.

Many of them rely on charities and there was one single parent who had an extension lead to neighbours property just so she could run a fridge.

Very sad as these are not the people responsible for this mess.
 
Been to Birmingham and back today, actually had a fair few long trips.
So listening to radio 4 has been interesting

The Greeks (mainly young) voters who rejected the eu offer are living in a dream world

Youth unemployment in Greece has risen from £20% in 2008, peeking at 60% in 2013.

It is currently running at 50%

Why would they vote for more austerity?
 
The Spanish people are increasingly unhappy with austerity as the votes for Podemos shows.

maybe, but they took some pain and are slowly managing to come out of "the dark"

http://uk.businessinsider.com/spanish-gdp-growth-q4-20-2015-1

Spain's GDP has shown small, yet consistently positive gains over the last year. Granted it's no rose garden over there with the high levels of unemployment, specifically in the younger generation. But consistent positive growth figures are the start to turning the corner.

To answer M1k3H, forget Troika, the mistakes were made on Greece's original entry to the Eurozone. It is highly unlikely they met any of the criteria to enter a monetary union with EU power houses like France and Germany. So on the first hand I hold the EU, EC, IMF and ECB to task for doing little to no due diligence at the start and for trying to force political union through currency.

I then hold Greece even more to task, they must have thought they had won the lottery being given all those EU grants and as a country remained fiscally irresponsible through not even attempting reform in all the years they were part of the Euro.

Troika was always going to be pointless as Greece were already screwed on the day they entered and then willingly took one up the arse through their complete unwillingness to make any changes even before the meltdown hit in 2008.

I would hazard a guess that Greece didn't implement a lot of what they signed up to in Troika and in the early stages of the recession the IMF and ECB kept throwing money at them because they simply couldn't afford a Greek exit at that stage in the game with Italy, Portugal and Spain all on the ropes. Now that the "at risk" countries have started making some gains, the risk is probably less and the IMF and ECB are probably getting to the point where they have had enough of this situation and are going to effectively throw the book at them. Whilst it is not a risk free strategy, it would be a calculated one based on the risk of contagion now being very much reduced from what it was back in 2009 - 2013.

Italy and Spain are in the top 5 economies of the EU. Keeping them in by turning a blind eye to Greece early on likely made economical sense if the goal was to save the Eurozone. Now that this mission is almost complete they can likely afford to take a hit by losing Greece rather than continue to throw money at what is effectively a bankrupt country. I guess it all depends on how the maths works out and what overall impact of losing a country whose GDP is a tenth that of Italy.

Greece might think they have got leverage with the result of their referendum, but it looks more like they just bought themselves a few extra coffin nails for the likes of Germany and the ECB to hammer the lid down properly. Whilst it might sound derogatory, Greece just aren't important enough or big enough financially to merit saving at any cost. Spain and Italy were and Greece got themselves a free pass in the process. The party is over now and Greece find themselves in an untenable position, which the rest of the EU can no longer or simply don't need to keep hold of anymore.
 
Youth unemployment in Greece has risen from £20% in 2008, peeking at 60% in 2013.

It is currently running at 50%

Why would they vote for more austerity?

True, but in general they seem to want to be rescued, I cab understand wanting out. But to believe they are going to get a better deal? Genuinely believe it?

To me you play ball with Europe and accept the probable lifetime of hardship
Or roll the dice but expect exit
 
Spain debt to GDP has increased from 69.2% in 2012 when they had their bailout to 97.7% at the start of 2015

Deficit: from -9.4% to -5.8% (improvement here I'll give you that but still massively away...)

Unemployment: from 24.4% is now at 23.78%.. this has increased up to 26.94% in mid 2013 and dropped to 23.67% in mid 2014 but has since slightly rised.

Is this the thriving economy of Spain? 1/4 of unemployment after 4 years and a deficit of nearly 6% still with debt of nearly 100% of GDP?

thats a question i would like to be answered by the good lad in this thread who claimed only greece is doing badly
 
Back
Top Bottom