hdd,ssd or scsi

Associate
Joined
1 Nov 2010
Posts
20
I am intending building a new system for photo and video editing. I was wondering what would be best either a large ssd, several hdd ins a raid format,or using scsi drives? What would be the advantages of either?

cheers

Gary
 
I am intending building a new system for photo and video editing. I was wondering what would be best either a large ssd, several hdd ins a raid format,or using scsi drives? What would be the advantages of either?

cheers

Gary

If you are video editing, space is the primary concern.

SSDs are too expensive for this and SCSI are not much better.

May i ask why you have even mentioned SCSI drives?
 
I wouldn't bother with SCSI/SAS drives for video editing, they're better suited to high queue depth random I/O situations in servers rather than the sequential I/O, single user ops that you'll get with video editing. For sequential I/O the current crop of SATA drives are just as good.

The one thing that kills video editing is I/O contention so I'd be looking at having multiple spindles/arrays with the source material on one and the output on another. Probably a couple of 2 disk RAID0 arrays to start with as well as an external backup.

By all means stick in an SSD for the OS but, as aproctor says, they're not big enough/cheap enough to use as bulk storage.
 
I only mentioned SCSI as I was considering all my options, and not having the greatest knowledge of computer systems I thought it best to ask the question. Thanks for the replies

Gary
 
LOL I got a pretty snazzy SCSI Raid card that I picked up for a song a year or so ago...

SCSI Drives are still kept too expensive, and so, I bought myself a handful of IDE-SCSI Adapters and now my youngest sons PC is running off it with 4 IDE Drives pretending to be SCSI and its just as quick I recon.

I did use it for a while as a file server with 2x500GB and I did add a further pair of 500GB drives but I shafted it up and lost a load of data but I decided it was a waste of time for my needs and so I just went with IDE and now my server is simply a NAS box. Job done.
 
Back
Top Bottom