• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Help! Designing a system for "mum"

Associate
Joined
5 Jan 2012
Posts
25
Hi all - first post here so please bear with me.

I'm planning to build a PC for my mum who's in her late 60s but really quite computer literate. She does the usual email/internet etc. but also spends a fair bit of time creating videos with Photostory. Now I don't think this is the same sort of processing requirement as full encoding but I'm guessing there will be a bit of processor load: having looked at the software briefly it has an option for CUDA, for example. She also does a bit of photo editing, not full photoshop but retouching and the like.

Her current PC is aeons old, has been upgraded a few times by yours truly and is still grinding. I can't even remember what the spec is, but it's out of date, especially when using Photostory. She uses a fair bit of HDD storage and she recently bought a 1TB external drive, which I'm going to suggest she uses as a backup device for her new rig (it has a one-touch backup button).

It's been years since I've built or spent more than an hour messing around with PCs (although I did recently set up a new Ubuntu box at home). I'm waaaaay out of touch with current processors, mobos, architecture etc., but I've done a fair bit of searching and ploughed through the forum, faqs and the like. Her primary need, IMO, is for it to be as future proof as possible, i.e. limited necessary upgrades for the next 3-5 years but an ability to crank it up a decent amount after that or if her demands change. I live 350 miles away and won't be around to bolt new bits on as easily as might otherwise be the case. I will be setting the thing up at my home, testing it for a week and basically getting it ready for use - then carting it down on my next visit.

Current idea for spec…

Internals:

Intel i5-2500K 3.30GHz (Sandybridge) Retail £184.99
Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 DDR3 Motherboard £84.98
Kingston HGG 8GB (2x4GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel £41.99
Arctic Cooling Freezer 13 High Performance CPU Cooler £17.99

Storage:

OCZ Agility 3 60GB 2.5" SATA-3 Solid State Hard Drive (AGT3-25SAT3-60G) £81.98
Seagate Barracuda 7200.12 1TB SATA 6Gb/s 32MB Cache £109.99

Case & PSU:

Cooler Master Elite 342 Case - Black £24.98
OcUK Swift 650W V2 Silent Power Supply £26.99

Total coming in at £588 inc vat and shipping. Am I right in thinking that I should be able to OC it up to about 4.5GHz stable? If so, that will give her a relative beast of a machine that boots in sub 20s (quite important) and is lightning fast for everything she needs (i.e. anything except gaming).

Yes, it's probably over the top, but the other option is to go for a lower-power rig which she might outgrow within 4-5 years and probably need an upgrade within 2-3, which isn’t as ideal, especially if I’m only saving her about £100.

A few questions: is the case, cooling & PSU combo sufficient for a decent overclock of, say 4.5GHz? I've seen the mobo suggested as a decent budget OC board and the 2500K is a beauty, so that just leaves the bits around them. I really fancy getting her a SSD as she'll love the quick boot times and it'll actually encourage her to use the computer more! 8GB is way more than what she has now and it'll be easy to add another 8GB if she gets into proper video editing etc. She already has an external USB DVD writer, monitor (although I'll need to check it has HDMI input) and the other usuals, so the only extra add on will be Windows 7 which is about £80 for an OEM version, I think.

If any of the components aren’t good enough then I might need to free up a bit of budget, so that could be where I slip down to an i3 (so no OC). That’d be a shame, though and I’d probably be inclined to stick with the i5k even if it costs here a few more £. I don't see the point of adding a GPU; I'm presuming the onboard graphics will be plenty good enough for windows and without hardcore video encoding CUDA wouldn't be worth it?

Alternatively, we could ditch the internal 1TB drive and use the external drive for storage (as she does now) but then that means no backup, which is a very bad idea IMO…

Any thoughts, comments, observations etc.? Have I forgotten something obvious (cables?) as it seems a pretty reasonable price?!?!

Thanks in advance

Paul
 
I would ditch the SSD since it's for your mum they can be temperamental so best to leave that out of the equation (imho). I would go with a 500GB system drive and see if the external can be pulled apart so it can be installed as a internal drive.

Here is a quick spec for you:

YOUR BASKET
1 x Intel Core i5-2500K 3.30GHz (Sandybridge) Socket LGA1155 Processor - OEM £173.99
1 x EVGA GeForce GTX 460 Superclocked 1024MB GDDR5 PCI-Express Graphics Card £119.99
1 x Seagate Barracuda 7200.12 500GB SATA 6Gb/s 16MB Cache - OEM (ST500DM002) £89.99
1 x Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 (Socket 1155) DDR3 Motherboard £84.98
1 x Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64-Bit - OEM (GFC-02050) £79.98
1 x Cooler Master Silent Pro Modular 600W '80 Plus Bronze' Power Supply £64.99
1 x Cooler Master HAF 912 Case - Black £52.99
1 x Kingston HyperX Genesis Grey 8GB (2x4GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel Kit (KHX1600C9D3X2K2/8GX) £41.99
1 x Gelid Tranquillo CPU Cooler (Socket 754/939/940/AM2/AM2+/AM3/LGA775/LGA1155/LGA1156/LGA1366) £25.99
Total : £747.49 (includes shipping : £10.50).
  • Use the voucher code "CMDOUBLE" (I think it is still running) to get a reduction in price since using a Coolermaster case and PSU.
  • Having a dedicated video card is always better than using on board and frees up the CPU to just processing rather than having to handle graphics too.
  • I would not over clock just yet since if it goes wrong one day then you will have to trek down there to fix it. Leave it all stock for now until she needs the extra power.
If the Coolermaster offer is not available we can change the case and PSU to Antec in which case you then get 15% off :D this system is way way way more than she probably needs but I would bet good money it will last her for over 5 years.

Stoner81.
 
Last edited:
Firstly, swap the PSU for something branded, 500w corsair builders series would do nicely at £50 for example (will link stuff in an edit)

After having a read, its abit pot luck with the OCZ SSD's with firmware changing every few weeks, Crucial M4 is a stable bet.

Rest of it I see no issues with IMHO.

For the graphics, theres the ATi 5450 (I think) for circa £20, its passive and doesnt require any extra power other than whats provided through the PCi slot.
 
Thanks for the quick responses...

Re: the laptop, she already has one but prefers to use a desktop for most of what she's doing! (She also finds the laptop too slow for doing some of the things on Photostory etc.)

Based on the aggregate of the comments so far, I reckon I should ditch the SSD (can always add one on later as part of the upgrade path if she wants/needs it). I'll also add a cheap as chips graphics card to reduce the load on the CPU. Fair call on the PSU, I'll go with a Coolermaster based on the discount offer they're doing at the moment - presumably 500W will be enough for what we have in the box at the moment? I like the HAF case Stoner has suggested, even though it's more money - looks like it'll be plenty big enough as well and has decent fans already built in (rather than as options). Out of interest, why the Gelid CPU cooler - is it really a lot better? not that it really matters, cost-wise of course!

I want to stick with 1TB as she already has well over 250GB of stuff, so I don't see a 0.5TB drive lasting long enough... I know we can always add more but I feel it'd be a false economy to go lower. She also wants to use the external drive for her laptop sometimes, although I'd need to check how the "backup" thing works - if it makes a proper copy of all files then fine, but if it's doing any sort of incremental / databased backup then that won't work...

Again, out of interest, why the suggestion of a fancier GPU? I'm not disputing it but just wonder whether it's necessary / worth the £ today?? Always happy to be put in my place though! :D

So, I think that leaves me with:


Intel Core i5-2500K 3.30GHz (Sandybridge) Socket LGA1155 Processor - Retail £184.99
Seagate Barracuda 7200.12 1TB SATA 6Gb/s 32MB Cache - OEM £109.99
Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 (Socket 1155) DDR3 Motherboard £84.98
Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64-Bit - OEM £79.98
Cooler Master HAF 912 Case - Black £52.99
Cooler Master Silent Pro Modular 500W '80 Plus Bronze' Power Supply £29.99 (inc discount)
Kingston HyperX Genesis Grey 8GB (2x4GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel £41.99
Gelid Tranquillo CPU Cooler £25.99
HIS ATI Radeon HD 5450 Silence 512MB GDDR3 PCI-Express Graphics Card £23.99

Total £649 including Windows 7 64-bit.

Sounds good?!
 
Ok, sorry to resurrect this with more ideas / change of plan, but...

Having had a conversation with aforementioned mum, it seems I misinterpreted her storage needs - she currently only has about 50GB used, not 250GB, so a 0.5TB drive should be fine.

Also, I've been reading up about the Pentium G series - although they're pretty crummy compared to the i series (especially a 2500K running at 4.5GHz!) they are cheap as chips and £125 difference is quite material. Best of all, they're completely compatible in terms of boards and sockets.

My new thinking is to get one of these instead (and ditch the CPU cooler) and upgrade her to a 2500K (or a 2600K) in a couple of years time... that way I save probably close to £150 today which we can use to get all of her desired upgrades in the future (RAM, CPU, cooler). I'll keep most of the rest the same, barring reducing the memory:

Intel Pentium G620 2.60GHz (Sandybridge) Socket LGA1155 Processor - Retail £49.99
Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 (Socket 1155) DDR3 Motherboard £84.98
Western Digital Caviar Blue 500GB SATA 6Gb/s 16MB Cache - OEM (WD5000AAKX) £79.99
Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64-Bit - OEM (GFC-02050) £79.98
Cooler Master HAF 912 Case - Black £52.99
Cooler Master Silent Pro Modular 500W '80 Plus Bronze' Power Supply £49.99
Sapphire ATI Radeon HD 6450 512MB GDDR3 PCI-Express Graphics Card £29.99
Kingston HyperX Genesis Grey 4GB (2x2GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel Kit (KHX1600C9D3X2K2/4GX) £23.99

Total £444 inc shipping and CMDOUBLE discount.

Key question: how much performance degradation do you think she'll notice for normal desktop use vs the 2500K o/c? I'm presuming minimal if any, except when encoding video and, perhaps, slightly slower boot times. Basically, the 2500K was ridiculously overkill for what she probably needs...

Any further thoughts - and apologies again for moving the goalposts? Also, am I right in thinking there are pretty much no overclocking possibilities with a G620?
 
Intel Pentium G620 2.60GHz (Sandybridge) Socket LGA1155 Processor - Retail £49.99

i'd go with the i3 2100 and use the onboard graphics as they are perfectly sufficient for non-gamers


Gigabyte Z68AP-D3 Intel Z68 (Socket 1155) DDR3 Motherboard £84.98

way overkill imo, go with h67 or h61, you dont need z68

Western Digital Caviar Blue 500GB SATA 6Gb/s 16MB Cache - OEM (WD5000AAKX) £79.99

Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64-Bit - OEM (GFC-02050) £79.98
Cooler Master HAF 912 Case - Black £52.99

your mother likes the styling of this case? i;d have chosen something more plain like the elite 430


Cooler Master Silent Pro Modular 500W '80 Plus Bronze' Power Supply £49.99

Sapphire ATI Radeon HD 6450 512MB GDDR3 PCI-Express Graphics Card £29.99

no point, use onboard graphics, cheaper and just as good

Kingston HyperX Genesis Grey 4GB (2x2GB) DDR3 PC3-12800C9 1600MHz Dual Channel Kit (KHX1600C9D3X2K2/4GX) £23.99

Total £444 inc shipping and CMDOUBLE discount.
 
Thanks for the comments, Panyan - always appreciated.

Without wanting to disagree with you, the reason I went for the mobo was because it's only bit more than a cheaper one, has Sata 6Gb support and, most importantly, will allow us to overclock a 2500k/2600k/2700k when we eventually upgrade in a couple of years time. I don't like wasting money knowing I'm buying something redundant. I recognise I'm doing that with the processor, but it's only £50.

That's also the reasoning behind going for a G620 rather than an i3. If the former is sufficient for desktop use with some occasional video encoding, then that's good - it'll be a huge improvement over her current rig (a P4 running XP). When she needs her next upgrade, I can bin the CPU and get something meaty and OC it.

With the GPU, I was thinking the processor will need all the help it can get, so taking the graphics away from it, especially for a dual desktop setup wouldn't be a bad idea. Also, it's something which will always be there (even after a CPU upgrade) so it's not "wasted" unlike spending another £45 on a slightly better processor (the i3).

Good point on the case - that choice was based on a recommendation but you're right it might be a bit "hardcore" for her tastes! I did like the idea of it being good for cable management, but we can live without it.

Does the 430 take the ATX size mobo ok?

Thanks again - very helpful and if you think I'm smoking crack with what I'm planning to do please do tell me!
 
overkill I think. Get a £400 pre-built system. She has plenty of time, performance will be leagues ahead of what she had before regardless what you spend.
 
Agree with Panyan generally.

Also, unless I missed it you never mentioned a screen. Depending on what she has at the moment, a decent 24" screen could well be, in terms of the experience of actually using the computer, the best upgrade you could make - far more noticeable than any GHz, multi-cores or MBs! My dear mum, not yet 60, hasn't the best eyes, and has a piddly old 17" or something flatscreen from roughly when flat screens were invented, and has to set all the fonts and icons etc in windows to mahoosive to see them properly, and therefore barely fits anything on the screen. I keep suggesting a good screen would be awesome, and one of these days will just get them one myself. A part of the user experience not to be overlooked, imho, especially not for the more... er... senior users. :) Buy a decent screen with some of the saved money from reducing the massive-overkill spec.
 
I would go for the cheaper cpu (G630?). But have you considered using a smaller ssd for ssd caching? If your mum only uses 50gb of space a 30gb ssd as cache would actually make a large difference.

I am a big fan of the ssd caching on the z68 chipset though :)
 
Thanks again guys... all helpful input. The real difficulty with speccing is that it's just such a slippery slope - for an extra £50 we can get a fair bit better processor, for an extra £60 over that you can get an awesome one... etc. etc.

Not sure about the SSD - I did think about one first of all, but I'm not sure about it being value right now (both in terms of opportunity cost and the general cost of SSDs right now, especially considering reliability etc.)

The thing I'm trying to look out for is my mum's increasing needs in computing. She used to just do web & email, then started creating movies using photostory and then moved into photo retouching and editing. The next logical step will be video editing.

I can realistically see the scenario where she says "I need more power" at some point, unless I have specced her an OCed 2500K. At least with this current spec all I'd be throwing out is a processor and, hopefully, by then a 2500K or better should be less than £100.

1) should I spend twice as much (£95) on an i3 instead of a G620?
2) should I ditch the GPU (may depend on the answer to 1) and get one if needed later? I would like to set my mum up with a dual display as I have a spare 19" display I can give her - but, it doesn't have HDMI and the mobos I've been looking at don't have a VGA output (whereas the card does).
3) is there a cheaper MB which will still allow me to OC a K processor further down the road?

Re: screen, she does have one - pretty new and although I can't remember, I think it might be a 22"...

Cheers guys.
 
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/289?vs=406

The i3 is obviously better, whether it's worth the money is your choice. I'd probably get a Z68 board if you can afford it, then like you say, you can get an i5 later and overclock it. I wouldn't get anything other than the Gigabyte board you mentioned earlier. Only other option for overclocking is the p67 but they're more expensive.

You've got nothing to lose trying the onboard GPU first i'd say.
 
I agree with horrorwood on the SSD caching, get a crucial m4 set it to cache the mechanical drive and it'll seem as though the G620 is performing like an i7 2700K on speed :D
 
I think you have to be honest with yourself and please don't take this the wrong way but a question - Are YOU looking forward to the excitement the planning and building a pc gives you? I think it is all very much overkill for what your mother needs it for and if you have her best intentions in keeping cost as low as possible I have to agree with billysielu get a pre-built machine.

If you do have to build one go for an i3 and ditch the SSD your mother is never going to notice the difference and why bother upgrading it later, she isn't going to suddenly get into gaming is she? I really cannot believe overclocking is going to be called for either.

The only future upgrade I can see being required is a larger storage HD if she needs one
 
Last edited:
I think you have to be honest with yourself and please don't take this the wrong way but a question - Are YOU looking forward to the excitement the planning and building a pc gives you? I think it is all very much overkill for what your mother needs it for and if you have her best intentions in keeping cost as low as possible I have to agree with billysielu get a pre-built machine.

If you do have to build one go for an i3 and ditch the SSD your mother is never going to notice the difference and why bother upgrading it later, she isn't going to suddenly get into gaming is she? I really cannot believe overclocking is going to be called for either.

The only future upgrade I can see being required is a larger storage HD if she needs one

I disagree, low end cpu + ssd is going to be better than an i3 with a standard hdd only.

I do agree it is pretty overkill to be considering an i5 etc
 
I disagree, low end cpu + ssd is going to be better than an i3 with a standard hdd only.

I do agree it is pretty overkill to be considering an i5 etc
I didn't say it is going to be better, I am talking of keeping the costs low. We are talking of a PC for a lady in her late 60's who currently uses a PC that is aeons old.
 
Hi all - first post here so please bear with me.

... but also spends a fair bit of time creating videos with Photostory.

Assuming your new system will run Windows 7 64-bit, Photostory may be in need of an update. Current favourites are:

Photo Gallery - Windows Live

and

Movie maker - Windows Live.
 
I think you have to be honest with yourself and please don't take this the wrong way but a question - Are YOU looking forward to the excitement the planning and building a pc gives you? I think it is all very much overkill for what your mother needs it for and if you have her best intentions in keeping cost as low as possible I have to agree with billysielu get a pre-built machine.

If you do have to build one go for an i3 and ditch the SSD your mother is never going to notice the difference and why bother upgrading it later, she isn't going to suddenly get into gaming is she? I really cannot believe overclocking is going to be called for either.

The only future upgrade I can see being required is a larger storage HD if she needs one

Damn right! (the bit in bold)

Seriously though, I am looking to get her something which works best - both now and in the future (as far as any of us can predict it). If I can get something off the shelf which offers best bang for buck and decent optionality then I'll go for it.

The biggest surprise for me has been the rate at which her computing abilities have improved over the last 8 or so years. When I first got her previous computer she could switch it on and fire up internet explorer. Since then she's pretty comfortable downloading software, installing it, learning how to use it etc. While none of this might seem particularly impressive, for someone "of that generation" with no formal training, I think she's done remarkably well.

Now, the problem this creates for me is what she might want to do next. As I've said, she's got into photo editing and I do suspect the next step will be video editing (now that she has a grandson these things become more interesting). I know enough about computers to understand where the limits of my knowledge are, hence the reason I'm asking for guidance! Your opinions have been really welcome and helpful - collectively you've already stopped me spending £650 on a way-overspecced system!

I'll be completely honest and admit that if there are two options at broadly the same price point and one of them involves a self-build in exchange for a slightly better spec than I'm going to be inclined to plump for that. What I do need reining in on is going overboard, so your comments have been very much appreciated - my first idea at the top of this thread was way OTT and I realise that now. Still, I don't see much merit in spending, say £300 only to find it might need substantial further investment (> £250) within the next couple of years. Sure, a larger HD, a bit more memory and even a faster processor are fine, but I don't basically want to be building her a brand new PC again in 3 years time - and she wouldn't appreciate having to switch to a brand new system with slightly different settings etc.

So, a sensible the off-the-shelf option (http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=FS-270-OK) is just £383 and gives her probably everything she might need now. I can still upgrade the memory, the HDD, add a SSD (but no caching), a GPU and also upgrade to a faster 1155 socket processor if needed. It would also have a slightly faster processor with hyperthreading out of the blocks.

Alternatively, a home-built rig is coming in at £403 (so £20 more) and is more or less exactly the same spec, but has a slightly slower processor (G620 rather than i3 Clarkdale) but a weaker MB (H61 vs Z68) as well as case/PSU. All of this stuff probably only matters if I ever replaced the processor with a K and overclocked it - something a couple of you have suggested is not likely to happen / hugely sensible / necessary.

The cost difference is not particularly material. The relative benefits are not particularly material. So maybe it doesn't matter which one I go for and just toss a coin?!

Aargh!
 
Back
Top Bottom