help me decide

[davew]

i'm thinking of replacing my 400d kit lens with either a tamron 17-50mm or a sigma 17-70mm

i've read a good few reviews but still can't make my mind up ,i'm mainly going to be using it at the wide end for landscape shots

i already have the kit lens, a nifty fifty, a sigma 70-300

 

[davew]

damn i hate this camera so many choices
i'm now wondering as most of my shots are at the wide end and a lot are landscapes that i might just get a wide angle sigma 10-20mm

 

[davew]

Nah, you want the 17-50 more than the 10-20.

Remember you don't NEED wide focal lengths to do landscapes. How many of Ansel Adams' photos have that stupid 10mm distortion tarred over them? None.

thanks for that ,your right .....i suppose the 17-50 will be a better all rounder as well.
i'm off to order it now before i change my mind