Hmrc - ebay/airbnb/vinted etc new rules - 1st Jan 2024

People who buy and sell a lot (I.e clearly trading) but aren’t making a profit are just contributing to the UK economy being so crap so it’s no real loss for them to stop wasting their own and everyone else’s time with nonsense businesses like that.

It made more of a difference before I hit the 50k tax band. Now it really isn't worth my time. So this is probably a blessing in disguise.
I'll just run down what I have over the next few years and get some loft space back.
 
WTF is that.

Jesus I feel old

Yeah. If there's one thing to make me feel. Old it's the state of social media.
Its the only time I can really feel the age gap between my 20 something year old friends and the 30 somethings.

The 20s share tiktok stuff. And I do not understand. Especially the super short stuff.
 
I've sold 3 or 4 high value items and the total must £4-5k, but I'm not trading.

From what I gather you'll be OK this year as it's from 1st Jan 2024.

But if it was in one tax year from now you'd have to fill in self assessment.

(technically)
 
How about FB marketplace is that affected?

I suppose not since it's garbage.

Its going to get a lot more popular.
Then the crack down will happen in there.

I've delisted my remaining items on ebay as its new year. Usually they are up for weeks until they sell. I'll re add some in next tax year and be careful to stay under 1000
 
Last edited:
I have one expensive (not 1k but getting there) old thing left to sell that's appreciated.
The tax on if its CGT or just income is vague. I'd rather just sell. It on FB than have to deal With all the faff. May get a bit less. But if I can avoid the faff.. I'll do that.
 
Last edited:
Where does something go from CGT to trading?

I bet there's a grey area for it.

Probably if it's all relatively low HMRC will take your word for it.
 
Now this is the part that I still want to get to the bottom of. Does it mean that HMRC will not get from eBay a report for a full tax year 2023-2024, and instead will only have 4 months of data for the tax year 2023-2024 (from Jan 1 2024 to April 5 2024)? Which would mean that HMRC will not know how much one has sold from April 6 2023 to Dec 31 2024?
Me too!
 
When it was bought with the intention of trading.

If you bought a painting, hung it in your house for 10 years and then sold it for 10 times the value, it'd be a CGT issue.

If you bought it today and sold it a week later for twice the amount it'd be trading.

This is an issue. Because my selling is a mix. What I sell I hold for a long time. Sometimes years. Wait for it to Appreciate. Then sell It.

With my original buys (years and years ago) the intention wasn't to trade. I just had them and they've shot up in value.

So last couple Of years I've bought a few things to hold for a couple of years then sell.

The few (2 or 3) original items have pushed into and (if I sold) would push over the 1000 trading limit with selling other stuff.
So it's really messy.

For example I've just delisted my old robot vacuum cleaner. It's clearly depreciated and isn't trading. But it adds 100 to the total and pushes ever closer to faff of SA.

What a pain.

There's a mix of a little trading
Where CGT changes to trading
And selling old tat.

If I'm understanding it correctly, if you go over 1000 technically you need to split all this out?
 
Last edited:
I do expect ebay UK to take a bit of a hit from this actually. 1000 is easy to go over now.
Etsy too.

Just selling that old. Robot vacuum is 1/10 of it. Plus unwanted Christmas stuff. Could start the year 1/5 used.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it sounds like you're conducting an activity that HMRC would consider to be trading, so you probably ought to be keeping basic records to identify the things being bought and sold with aim of making some profit and the stuff you're just offloading that are second hand personal possessions.

Luckily I've only sold about 15 things.
So. It wouldn't be too hard to separate.

If indeed it is confirmed that this is coming in from 1st..ie data is supplied from the and not this tax year it will be fine.
And I'll know to be aware going forward to keep under the 1k.

I believe if I was queried about 2023 to 2024 it would be easy to separate trading from old personal Stuff vs house tat. And I would be well under the 1k. In the trading.


Still unsure with this separation if being over 1k in total. But under in trading means I'd get taxed (at 40pc) on the traded stuff.
 
The £1000 is your trading allowance.

Selling your robot hoover or unwanted Christmas tat doesn't contribute to the £1000 trading allowance.

Online platforms will be obliged to hand over your information if you make more than 30 sales or €2000 worth of sales.

Nothing necessarily happens if you sell £1000 worth of stuff.

You'll owe tax and should be filing a self assessment if you make £1000+ worth of sales as part of a trading activity.

If you sell more than 30 things/€2000, then eBay will tell HMRC, HMRC might come and ask you to explain (unless they get data that enables them to see themselves you're mostly offloading junk). At which point you'll still only need to do self assessment if the elements that make up your trading activity are over the £1000. If you were at £500 trade and £1500 emptying the attic, then no self assessment tax return would be needed, but you might need to explain to HMRC which items were personal if they asked.
Really clear. Thanks.

Not seen it written like this before. (unless you wrote it yourself)
 
Dude… just be honest and say your running a side hustle..
we have interacted a bit in recent and I’ve seen the posts you made in other threads, obviously I’m not going to grass you in, but in the stock market thread you have clearly said that Lego was part of your investment portfolio and in the side hustle thread not that long ago, I’m sure you said trading Lego was your side hustle.

i’m not saying this to upset you or be a ****.. just not calling a dog a dog doesn’t stop it from being a dog.

i’m going to look into starting my own LTD as I may need it to rent out a property, apparently I can move all profits of an LTD straight into an employee’s (me) pension and claim it as an expense.

it may be useful to be used to sell some of my collectible…

Yeah it is lego. It started with having some old sets (the high value ones) and seeing those go up I decided to try and buy/sell.

Tbh obviously others have had same. Idea and it hasn't panned out. Ie it's not worth my time. Especially as salary has increased making time even more important.

We are talking sometimes 30 pounds profit on a set after 2 years. Sometimes zero.

So. I've been hoarding stuff and hoping to resell Later. But with appreciation now basically non existent it's a bit of a waste Of my time. Especially with this.

But I still have lots to offload. I was hoping to ramp this up. Never even thought the 1000 was sales (otherwise I'd never have done it).

I've got sets costing 250 that after 2 years are only 270.

The only gems at my unbuilt sets from years ago that I just have. (namely my porsche and batmobile)

This is annoying (and totally my fault) for assuming 1000 was profit.

I'll simply string out the sales of lego over years now to get rid but keep under the 1000 trading.



It was a nice little thing that's turned into a burden. And now is even more of a burden.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe they started collecting till 1st Jan 24, and then dont have to report till 2025.

As far as i am aware, they won't be reporting 2023 stuff.

2024 stuff might still fall in the 23/24 tax year though.

This is what almost every news outlet is reporting. And it clearly says "from 1st Jan 2024".

I suspect if they saw 800 quid in sales between now and April and they were diligent they'd check the rest of the tax year.
 
Possible. However, I'm not sure where that falls in the organisation's obligations to collect and report and/or whether they would bother. ebay don't give a **** about what the UK tax man gets. Working out who has a lot of sales between now and April and then going back through all those accounts of their own volition to find a pattern is just loads of extra work for them.

They will all no doubt do the bare minimum of what is required of them by law.

It probably wouldn't happen. I suspect it would only happen if there was automation set up.

Ie "if sold items > 800 between 1st Jan and 4th April = human check"

It would certainly have to be automated. No ones gonna trawl through that.

In reality I suspect it's mainly giving some warning this is happening tax year 2024-2025.

Who knows.. It may even just be to scare people into it.
 
So for context, it may help;
If your into crypto when the main reporting kicked in there they (exchanges mainly) told you via email that they were reporting activity £x by agreement with HMRC.
HMRC then send a letter saying, we have been told by XXXX that you have used their platform and have exceeded £x. (based on deposits iirc not sales)
You are required to advise us if Z applies to you. Z being a profit exceeding your potential allowance, or if you basically know you should have paid tax.
If you do not understand we suggest seeking the advice of a tax advisor to ensure you are compliant.

I would expect Ebay etc will end up along the same lines.
Give HMRC data for people who exceed an arbitrary amount no matter what they have sold. Say £1250.
HMRC will send a letter to all those people saying if your trading and its exceeded £1k you must report, if you have sold personal items you may be liable.
But in both cases if you are unsure seek tax advice.
That way HMRC undertake little work. They have warned you, so should it later be found you should have paid tax they will likely be able to ignore the statute limiting time as they will say you consciously didn't pay tax as opposed to unwittingly didn't pay tax.

This would be a sensible/clear way of doing it tbh.
 
Yeh. Nothing has changed tax wise. This reporting just helps the HMRC catch potential offenders.

I imagine it is also a pretty large deterrent to stop people regularly trading as private sellers on ebay. Any person that is regularly selling over 30 items year/£1700's worth of stuff year after year, likely is trading.

Its worked on me! I didn't even pay attention to how much I was selling on the past!
And I probably would have carried on!
Now i know I need to be careful and keep under 1k.
 
Last edited:
I thought gross income was the income AFTER product costs:

"What is Gross Income?

Gross income is the total amount of income that your business has gained over a set time period, with only the cost of goods sold (COGS) subtracted.

COGS are the total cost of all the things directly related to providing the goods and/or services sold by your business. For example, the cost of manufacturing, packaging, logistics, and salaries of factory employees would all be included in COGS. But indirect costs such as marketing expenses would be excluded.

This is the formula you can use to calculate Gross Income:


Gross Income = Gross Revenue – COGS"



So if you bought £9000 worth of goods and only sold them for £10000, you have only made £1000 gross income no?

I thought in this case gross income was WITHOUT costs deducted.

Ie if you sold something for 1100 that cost 900 you breach the 1000.
Therefore you need to fill in SA.

You made 200 profit. And therefore get taxed on 200 by 20 or 40 etc percent?
 
Well the question is whether the cost of goods is "allowances and expenses", which i didn't think it was.

It basically says.. You can either use the 1000 exemption Or costs and expenses. Not both.


Say you sell 1100 of stuff and it cost 200
Your profit is 900.
Better to take the 1000 exemption and pay tax on the 100 over it.

If you sell 1100 and it cost 1050 it better to not use the 1000 as then you'd be paying tax on 100 and (1100-1000) vs 50 (1100-1050).


I thought the 1000 was profit. Because I don't get why you can sell 1000 pounds of stuff that has no cost and pay nothing. But sell something for 1001 that cost 901 and have to pay tax on 100.

I understand now. But I still don't totally get why... Expect for making it easier for HMRC
 
Yes the £1k is just to filter off the technically you should have reported some tiny gain that HMRC don't want to have to deal with 30 million of per year cases.
The vast majority are not going to make more than £1k getting a few bungs for helping out on stuff.

They also want to know people who are trading to get them on the radar.

I guess people will fall into the

A) "in just making over 1000 or under 1000..i don't want to bother with SA I'll slow down/stop."

Or

B) "I'm making enough over 1000 or my profit is high enough it's worth doing SA."


Irrespective, for HMRC.. Its worth it as anyone who falls into A or B wasn't reporting anyway.. So no loss.. But anyone in B = more tax income.

I expect, if everyone reported correctly, it could be substantial
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom