How often should you change PSU?

So you are advocating the replacement of a part that is working absolutely fine, on the premise that it "might" give problems later? Sorry man, but lifes too short to be scared all the time, worrying about what might happen.

If you know that item has a high % of failure, with it taking out of the rest of the stuff I would change it. Especially if you've just spend several hundred quid on components.
 
I think enthusiast sites like this have scaremongered people into buying very expensive, over powered PSUs that are not actually necessary.

Absolutely. Since all these 800W+ PSUs became mainstream there have been more and more posts asking if an 8800GT will be OK with a 400W PSU, etc. With the focus on efficiency these days, a mid-range PC of 2007 probably uses less power than one of 2005! I think it's unlikely that a dual-core 8800GT rig will use more than 250-300W.

The other hardware manufacturers aren't helping either. My X1800XT box recommended a minimum 400W PSU :confused:
 
Well, ordered Corsair HX 620W. Partly cause I wantd to spend money, partly cause I would like to know if it will truly make any difference to things like OCing my Quad.
 
Well, ordered Corsair HX 620W. Partly cause I wantd to spend money, partly cause I would like to know if it will truly make any difference to things like OCing my Quad.

Let us know if it allows you to overclock further, as compared to the cheaper PSU. Should be interesting.
 
If you're running a Hyper Type R 580 you're on borrowed time, you only have to search the forums and you'll see enough posts detailing the issues users have had with them to understand that they aren't worth the risk.
 
Should I replace my 3yr old enermax 600watt psu for my next amd build in the new year? Its been used 12+ hours everyday, sometimes left on for a few days to a week.
 
I would say dont bother unless its acting up, does it have built in protection stuff?

If it starts making noises or switching itself off, then yeh get shut.
 
My PSU is steam powered!
You live in/above a bath house/sauna? :D

I've had my PSU for just over three years. It's an Akasa 400W jobbie and has always performed flawlessly. Should I get a new one yet or wait a bit longer?
No! Unless you are upgrading to a PC it can't handle.
 
Care to give us some reasons why you prefer the Corsair (in actual, day to day usage), over your old PSU?

Well, I obviously don't notice any difference day to day, but I can now rest assure the chances of my PSU blowing up have been massively reduced.

sunama said:
I think enthusiast sites like this have scaremongered people into buying very expensive, over powered PSUs that are not actually necessary.

Agreed. I'm only running 520W with 3 HDs, an X1800xt, 4x2GB and it runs fine.
 
Well, I obviously don't notice any difference day to day, but I can now rest assure the chances of my PSU blowing up have been massively reduced.

Ahh. So in otherwords no "actual" change. The only thing you got by replacing your psu was the assurance (more a mental thing than physical).

It would be interesting to see the failure rate of the Hyper psus. Obviously there are a lot of anecdotes, but for every negative anecdotes, Im sure there must be 10s if not 100s of Hyper PSUs that are functioning without a hitch. Without actual numbers though, we will never know. A Poll would go some way to giving us a some sort of idea.
 
Ahh. So in otherwords no "actual" change. The only thing you got by replacing your psu was the assurance (more a mental thing than physical).

It would be interesting to see the failure rate of the Hyper psus. Obviously there are a lot of anecdotes, but for every negative anecdotes, Im sure there must be 10s if not 100s of Hyper PSUs that are functioning without a hitch. Without actual numbers though, we will never know. A Poll would go some way to giving us a some sort of idea.

A simple poll would not be enough. It would require a full survey covering different makes of PSU, the longevity of each, whether it was replaced because it died or for other reasons, time before failures, etc, etc.

But personally I feel that they are probably not quite as bad as people make out. not that it matters to me any more once I get my corsair installed :)
 
But personally I feel that they are probably not quite as bad as people make out.

That is what I think, too. The problem is that reports of failures spread like wild fire on forums. As an example, no one in this thread has yet reported having had a problematic hyper psu. I thought that perhaps Mulder had one, but this was not the case. He was acting purely on what he had read on forums.

not that it matters to me any more once I get my corsair installed :)

I actually think you are wasting money here. But do let us know if it allows you to overclock further.
 
Instead of creating a new thread, will just ask in here, what is the best free utility for monitoring voltage when OCing?

Currently use Speedfan 4.33. IS that OK? I never trusted the voltage readings in CPU-Z.
 
My antec 420w started making a nasty smell after two years I powered down my PC and didn't power it back up until my new Corsair 520 was installed. Hopefully the antec will get swapped under warranty but I didn't want to be computer less while I waited for a swap out!
 
Last edited:
Ok, I fall into that category. However, as much as I have read the "horror stories", the damn thing just seems to be working flawlessly.

I keep deliberating though on whether or not to replace it.

I know that some people have had them take out other components, but how often is that?

I mean, I bought this PSU cause it had nothing but good reviews, and people thought it was great in general...


same here, ive had the 580w type r for about 16 months now 24/7 and it has worked without fault.

maybe one day it will blow up and take out my entire system, however.
 
So you are advocating the replacement of a part that is working absolutely fine, on the premise that it "might" give problems later? Sorry man, but lifes too short to be scared all the time, worrying about what might happen.

If its working fine now, then run with it. What would happen if you replaced a perfect functioning PSU (albeit with a bad reputation) and the replacement ends up giving you problems? It could happen, just as your tyre situation could happen.

Also consider that around the world, most of the computers are OEM builds. And these OEM built PCs invariably use cheapo PSUs (try opening up a DELL and see what they use). The reason why OEM companies use these PSUs are because they are cost effective. If they found that they were creating problems (especially during the warranty period), they would be losing too much money on replacing the PSUs (and any components damaged), they would eventually realise that it isnt worth saving pennies on a cheap PSUs as later on, it comes back to bite you in the backside. This clearly has not happened. We can therefore assume that it is safe to use the cheaper PSUs, once the PSU is up and running fine.

I think enthusiast sites like this have scaremongered people into buying very expensive, over powered PSUs that are not actually necessary. The only people who win are the PSU makers and their bank accounts.

OEM's including Dell mainly use FSP PSU's built for them that's why Dell's are reliable.

And I can say 100% that EVERY single cheapo PSU I have ver had or fitted whilst building a PC has failed, not one or a few EVERY one and this is in 10 years of building PC's and part of it for my income like I build around 100-150 PC's per year.
 
Ive only ever used one cheap psu. It came with the case, 235w, 9yrs ago, £30 (including the case). I think it's name is 'Suntech'.

I used it for 2.5yrs solid with no problems and now only use it when Im testing fans or hard disks. I still occassionally use it to power up full systems (which it does), during testing. Never had a problem with it.

It was cheap and hasnt failed yet.
 
Back
Top Bottom