ICE scrappage scheme anyone?
- Thread starter stockhausen
- Start date
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2006
- Posts
- 12,130
It is my understanding that the national stations (i.e. BBC Radio) are moving from FM to Digital; is this not the case
As a (genuine) matter of interest, from where have you got this information?
Has the Government ever actually said that the switch-over to DAB is dependent on reliable in-car reception?
you do all realise that when switchred over it will allow for silly coverage and quality, its has nothing to do with money either the technology is better its just at a limited strength , for example now analogue tv is gone it will pave the way for high bitrate freeview and freeview hd, not like freeview wasnt better than analogue anyway.
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2006
- Posts
- 12,130
Whilst it may "allow" superior quality (if that is what you mean by "silly"?); in practice it seems that that is not what is actually being provided:
Even the BBC considers 192 kbps to be unacceptable for quality (e.g. Classical) Music:
Admittedly, nobody will notice this poor quality in a car but the same low quality will apply in your house.
I find that quite incredible
I was listening to Jermery Vine, Radio 2 on erm.. 22nd March, and they had a blokey from the government who is a lot to do with the BBC. I can't remember his name/title, as i missed part of the interview.
But it was from that show, he stated that there were conditions on the change over. One being the in-car issue, and another being % of people using DAB over FM.
Not getting radio1/2/3/4/5 etc on FM does not mean FM is being 'killed off', and as for coverage - don't forget you cannot receive every FM transmission on every square foot of the country anyway.
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2006
- Posts
- 12,130
It seems that you are substantially correct, certainly in that no actual "switch-over" date has been specified and there will not be any "FM switch-off". There is a good blog on the entire debate HERE.
I have two DAB radios at home and I would have to say that I think the use of the claimed extra opportunities available with DAB has never actually materialised. I often have BBC Radio 3 on and from time to time I check the "Info" display in the hope that it will give details (Title, Composer, Performer) about a particular piece of music being played - it never does
I can see DAB going much the same way as Blu-Ray and eBooks - unfulfilled potential.
Love to know how they're going to get DAB to work when there are still parts of the country where even FM is crap and drops out regularly.
Plenty of parts of the valleys down here have problems and there's also that massive stretch of the M6 through Cumbria where there is no FM signal for a good 5 minutes.
(Tested in a large number of cars over the years, so it's not just my radio at fault)
Plenty of parts of the valleys down here have problems and there's also that massive stretch of the M6 through Cumbria where there is no FM signal for a good 5 minutes.
(Tested in a large number of cars over the years, so it's not just my radio at fault)
Thanks for that link. I was trying to find some kind of source for what I was saying but wasn't coming up with much.
I was an early user of DAB, had a Psion Wavefinder and that was awful for signal. I believe that it's vastly improved since them days though!!
indeeed!