Here is my mini review
I was going to delete this from my Lovefilm list but thought as it was new I wouldn't bother as you never get titles from them within a week of release... never guess what dropped onto my door mat this morning?!
I think I'm a fair way through it now. I'm sad to say that I have to agree with most of the reviews. While it is not an inherently bad game, it is nothing special or innovative. The storyline is weak and the cutscenes don't help either. They are often too long for what they are trying to say, with to much time looking around rather than actual dialogue taking place. The character you play sounds like a 14 year old and generally makes you want to die just to put him out of his misery and your Mantel friends are just down right annoying. Vehicles are horrific. Nectar is rather pointless. As a Mantel soldier it just lets you do everything better and you find yourself using it all the time. As a rebel all you really get is play dead and an extra type of grenade. The gameplay is repetitive and generic that offers nothing new.
The sound effects are poor and the music is pitiful. It's often hard to hear what your squadmates are saying and things like gun sound effects are generic, as are the guns themselves. The graphics are not as bad as I thought they would be, but they could be a lot better. Some places do look good, and others - such as the swamp - are very atmospheric. Sadly though this good places are let down by the much more numerous bad areas and the flamethrowers flame looks like something from the N64 and I'm not exaggerating. Textures are of low resolution, artwork is dull and the level design is angular and uninspiring. I've found a few bugs, but nothing major, apart from being able to walk past the edge of the map in the swamp level.
Multiplayer and co-op are a lot more fun, but sadly not good enough to save this game. Co-op suffers from all of the above only you get to experience it with a friend and the MP has no new or exiting gameplay modes and the levels are very similar to SP meaning they are of the same rather boring design. It has in game squad based voice communication which is quite good and you can access your XMB friends list to check your messages though only when on the main menu. You can have bots too, but as with the SP their AI is, well... crap.
In summery, it's an ok game, though it could have been a lot better in all areas. I'll be completing it and playing it online for a few days with a friend or two, but then I'll be sending it back never to be thought of again. I'd recommend borrowing it or renting it, though I wouldn't buy it and would be quite disappointed if I had done.