Ion System or HTPC?

Associate
Joined
12 Aug 2006
Posts
59
Been looking into ways to watch HD content on my home cinema set-up in my lounge, but I'm very undecided what to do. Have a decent amp, 42" plasma and blu-ray player already (so don't need blu-ray or hd sound on my computer).
Not convinced by wireless for streaming content and don't have the option of running a cable upstairs to my pc, and not really familar with using that mains socket home LAN thingy.
Considered a western digital hdtv but wasn't convinced it would do everything i wanted, started looking a popcorn but at the price isn't far of a proper pc.
Considered the Aspire Revo but seem to have missed the boat on getting the £150 linux version, and £250 for a single core 1GB running windows seems madness, but it seemed seriously underpowered anyway and needed too much tweaking to get it to run 1080p content.

My current favorite option is the Asrock Ion (1.6Ghz dual core, which will o/c easy to 2.1Ghz) as for only £250ish it will allow HD playback, has a bit of storage (320GB) and an optical drive, has audio output, and will allow a bit of web browsing. Although small and cheap i suppose with its specs it has limited functionality and will not allow me to do any gaming. My main computer needs replacing in the next 6months anyway, so i could either get a decent htpc that will allow gaming at 1080p on my plasma and home cinema speakers or just get the asrock and get a decent gaming rig and monitor for the office later

So the main dilemas are:
1. If I want to accept that all I really need is the ability to play 1080p with dts/5.1 output and web browsing, Do I go with the Asrock? or is there a better system at a similar price?
2. If I do get the Asrock is there any point upgrading the 2GB memory to 4GB? (planning on running Windows 7)
3. Or should I just spend double the money and get a full blown HTPC and possibly add decent gaming possibilties?
 
How about an Xtreamer?

As for Powerline Mains Plugs - I run 200Mbps D-Links and they are fine for HD -just require a socket and an ethernet port at either end. Not much configuration required.
 
Get the Asrock ION, throw CoreAVC on there for h.264 playback and your laugthing.
May aswell upgrade the memory while your at it for what little extra it will cost.
No point in spending any more on something more powerfull as the IONs where made for HTPC use, they do it flawlessly.
As it just a PC at the end of the day you could even just throw a USB wireless dongle on there for your networking.
 
Last edited:
Why would you bother putting CoreAVC on an ION machine? They are designed to play HD material, they don't need software assistance doing it.
 
I tried a ion system and dual core atom. Although they can do file playback well. They totally fail at web based video. Such as Skyplayer/Iplayer/flash. They dont have the power and its a jerky mess. I suppose you could blame the flash/silverlight system, but whoever is to blame it just doesn't work. Maybe the codec's will be updated in the future to work with the basic cpu's, at the moment they just cant perform, especially at HD res.

If you just want file playback get a western digital TV unit and save yourself ££

A real HTPC at the moment is the only real option.

Even this bundle for £120 from overclockers would vastly outperform a ion/atom system - you could get a cheap case/psu remote keyboard/hd/cheap 3d gfx card and still come well under budget of the asrock system.

a old rundown of a lower spec single core atom vs single core athlon64 shows the differences in performance can be seen here.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom