Is fish a meat?

Psyk · 21 Mar 2008 at 17:11

Le_Petit_Lapin said:
Besides you'll get odd looks if you go into the supermarket, and go looking for some meat at the fish counter.

Yes you would get odd looks because not all meat is fish. So it would be pretty silly to go to the fish counter and ask for some beef. It would not be quite as silly to go to the meat counter and ask for some fish.

romperstomper · 21 Mar 2008 at 17:26

Lysander said:
The reason is that a lot of vegetarians choose to eat fish purely because they think it's not a meat. Which is incorrect. So a lot of them are wrong, or in denial.

I don't think so ,its because most feel that killing a cow,lamb ,pig etc is a lot worse than killing a fish ...think about it ,which would you rather kill !

Anksy · 21 Mar 2008 at 17:43

romperstomper said:
I don't think so ,its because most feel that killing a cow,lamb ,pig etc is a lot worse than killing a fish ...think about it ,which would you rather kill !

hmmmm, im probably totally wrong and stupid for saying this lol, but ill say anyway

, cows and pigs are often than not bread and brought up on a farm, purposely for selling to the highest bidder and then killed, they really have no life, 99-100% fish are not brought up anywhere and are not purposely for killing, they are in the sea having a life. so for me killing a purposely bread cow would be easier than killing a fish.

im probably totally wrong anyway

but thats what im thinking. (and will more than likely change my mind in a phew minutes

)

EDIT: Why in gods name did i just write all that crap

RetiredGreyFox · 21 Mar 2008 at 17:48

romperstomper said:
think about it ,which would you rather kill !

It was coming for me.
Yum yum.

romperstomper · 21 Mar 2008 at 19:26

AmateurJimmy said:
hmmmm, im probably totally wrong and stupid for saying this lol, but ill say anyway , cows and pigs are often than not bread and brought up on a farm, purposely for selling to the highest bidder and then killed, they really have no life, 99-100% fish are not brought up anywhere and are not purposely for killing, they are in the sea having a life. so for me killing a purposely bread cow would be easier than killing a fish.

im probably totally wrong anyway but thats what im thinking. (and will more than likely change my mind in a phew minutes )

EDIT: Why in gods name did i just write all that crap

But if select humans were bred for eating would you be happy to eat them ?

Wicksta · 21 Mar 2008 at 19:31

Do vegetarians who eat fish eat crab meat?

RoboCod · 21 Mar 2008 at 20:01

Fish was redefined as not being meat by vegetarians I believe

pitchfork · 21 Mar 2008 at 21:11

i don't care its yummy.
Bludgeoned to death with a big old rock, skinned boned battered and deep fried with chips.