Soldato
Just like with any form of food consumption: moderation is key.
Is MSG safe? Does anyone use it?
- Thread starter churchhawk
- Start date
Associate
I watched a programme on the BBC about food additives where they showed the "Chinese Restaurant Syndrome" wasn't an allergy to MSG but an intolerance to Glutamate. Which is why people with "Chinese Restaurant Syndrome" will also suffer the same symptoms if they eat food that is high in Glutamate such as Broccoli and hard cheeses such as Parmesan.
As far as I remember, the studies referenced by the shows presenter said that MSG is safe in the same way salt is safe. It won't hurt you in moderation but use too much of it and it's bad for you just like salt. (I'll post the source when I find it)
As for MSG being a lazy, cop out which tastes of nothing specific... surely that's one of it's good points, it adds an unctuousness to food without any unwanted flavours.
As far as I remember, the studies referenced by the shows presenter said that MSG is safe in the same way salt is safe. It won't hurt you in moderation but use too much of it and it's bad for you just like salt. (I'll post the source when I find it)
As for MSG being a lazy, cop out which tastes of nothing specific... surely that's one of it's good points, it adds an unctuousness to food without any unwanted flavours.
Soldato
My personal feeling on MSG is that if you use the proper ingredients you won't need to add manufactured flavourings.
I used to use it for rice flavourings but now use whole/ground spices and tastes much better.
I used to use it for rice flavourings but now use whole/ground spices and tastes much better.
Associate
It depends on what you mean by "manufactured". Ascorbic Acid (vitamin C) is manufactured and is used to make cheese slices for burgers... not exactly the greatest of foods but Heston Blumenthal made his own burger cheese using ascorbic acid. Just because it's manufactured doesn't make it bad.
MSG is extracted from seaweed using electrolysis or fermented from wheat (not all of it, there are other processes). MSG powder is simply a concentrated version of naturally occurring MSG, which as I said can be found in everything from Broccoli and soy bean milk to cheese. It's not unnatural or inherently bad, it's just often misused.
I had some a couple of years ago. You can buy it in Chinatown. I got it specifically to give my stirfry that cheap Chinese takeaway taste, which it did very well 
http://iamaviking.com/2011/01/17/the-war-on-msg/
Pretty decent article on the subject. It seems harmless enough. I might try using some to see what effect it has on food.
Pretty decent article on the subject. It seems harmless enough. I might try using some to see what effect it has on food.
Ordered some from the auction site, will let you know how i get on 
Associate
We got some from the Chinese supermarket.
Don't use it very often and only in small amounts when I do, but it does enhance the food in a subtle, interesting manner.
Don't use it very often and only in small amounts when I do, but it does enhance the food in a subtle, interesting manner.
Soldato
- Joined
- 2 Jun 2004
- Posts
- 18,423
It's like salt in the sense that it's perfectly safe in moderation, but bad for you if you have too much.
It's not nearly as evil as food packaging and ads try to make out.
It's not nearly as evil as food packaging and ads try to make out.
Here's a good blog post on it by my mate Tim (before he made it big 
)
http://iamaviking.com/2011/01/17/the-war-on-msg/
)http://iamaviking.com/2011/01/17/the-war-on-msg/
Soldato
Here's a good blog post on it by my mate Tim (before he made it big
http://iamaviking.com/2011/01/17/the-war-on-msg/
satchef1 beat you to it
He's a super cook that lad, didn't watch that much of the series because the new format annoys me, but he did impress when I saw him. What's he planning to do next?
(sorry, massively OT!)
Soldato
Cool - All the best to him, and if he ever needs an amatuer restaurant tourist to sample his food let me know