• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Low end Ryzen 3 vs 5

Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
10,422
Location
Behind you... Naked!
Ok, a while back, I built up a Ryzen setup for my son. Today, he told me that he has swapped it for a better system.
The system I gave him was low end for sure, but he has been given an even lower end one and the guy has in my opinion, completely blagged his head.

The Setup I gave him was a Ryzen 2400G
The setup that he sawpped it for is a Ryzen 3600G

So, on the face of it, 3600 is obviously higher than 2400, however, the 2400 is a Ryzen 5 with 11MB Cache and the 3600 is a ryzen 3 with only a 4MB Cache

Not only that,. but the Ryzen 3 is 4 core and the 5 is 4 Core with HT, so 8 Logical.

They are both 3.6Ghz

I told him that he was shafted, but he wont believe me.

One bunuis I suppose, is that his was a HP with a HP Board and case, while the board he has, is an ASUS and the case is a decent looking thing, and so sure, he has gained on that.

I have looked at benches for these 2 CPUs and they are very much on par with each other, but I dont see that at all... They are both 3.6Ghz ok, but one has 111MB cache plus HT and other has only a 4MB Cahce and not HT so surely those alone would make a sizeable difference surely?

Anyway, just a whine really, but can anyone back me up or shall I just accept the exchange and consider getting him a better CPU?

Oh, and yes, they both have 8GB RAM but his new board has 4 slots, the other one had just 2 so RAM can be upped too!
 
Sounds like neither you or your son know what's going on as the 3600G doesn't exist. I think you mean a 3200G which is indeed worse than a 2400G. The 2400G is 4c8t and zen 1 whereas the 3200G is 4c4t and zen+. The igpu on the 3200g is vega 8 rather than vega 11 that's on the 2400g too. So it worse in ever way other than single thread.
 
Bugger yeah the 3200G sorry.
And yes, the GFX are Vega 11 vs Vega 8 the cache is smaller 4M over 11M and the fact that the 2400G has Hyperthreading too!

But yeah, I get confused with numbers... I appologise, but I had an accident in Dec 2012 and I now have serious issues with many things physical and mental.

I do know what I am doing though ... mostly ... LOL
 
Back
Top Bottom