• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

macro lens help plz

buzzlightweight

buzzlightweight

buzzlightweight

Associate
Joined
22 Aug 2010
Posts
2,212
Location
In My Command Center
Ok so back on the market for a macro i was thinking about going for the canon 60mm but does anyone have any other suggestions?

Iv also heard about macro extension tubes with AF but im a little unsure how they work.

I have a canon 550d, a sigma 18-200 (walk about lens) and a sigma 18-50 (amazing kit lens)

Im looking to do plant shots and just general qwerky shots :)

Buzz
 
I have the 100mmL on my 550D. It's a brilliant lens. Takes some practice though as the depth of field is wafer thin (so much so that the front of a fly is in focus and the back isn't) but when you get 'the shot' it's a belter.

You can save a fair bit buying from grey import sites like digitalrev.
 
Phal said:
I would definitely say L if money isn't a huge concern :) I mean why not? :D
Click to expand...

Well if with the same money you could get, say, a Sigma 50 1.4 and a Canon 100 f/2.8 Macro Non L.

The non-L is quite possibly Canon's best non L lens, it's every bit as sharp as the L and only falls short of the L on build and the lack of stabilisation.

It depends what macro work you're doing. If you're using a tripod as most macro shooters do, then the IS won't add anything to the lens, however if you shoot in the rain or do a lot of walkabout macro work then the IS and sealing could be invaluable. Both make great portraiture lenses in any case if you don't mind stepping back - I've seen fantastic shots from the 7D 100L combo for portraiture, and both are about as good as c. 100mm macro lenses get in the EOS system
 
Last edited:
Kevin Clark said:
I have the 100mmL on my 550D. It's a brilliant lens. Takes some practice though as the depth of field is wafer thin (so much so that the front of a fly is in focus and the back isn't) but when you get 'the shot' it's a belter.

You can save a fair bit buying from grey import sites like digitalrev.
Click to expand...

Stop shooting at f/2.8 and light your shots then?
 
well on flea bay i bought some macro AF rings, i did some research and thought i better try something a little more inexpensive like £50 rather than laying out nearly £600.

Im going to play with these first and if i think i will pursue this line of photography then i will definitely buy the L 100mm.

thank you for your help ;)
 
Ksanti said:
Well if with the same money you could get, say, a Sigma 50 1.4 and a Canon 100 f/2.8 Macro Non L.

The non-L is quite possibly Canon's best non L lens, it's every bit as sharp as the L and only falls short of the L on build and the lack of stabilisation.

It depends what macro work you're doing. If you're using a tripod as most macro shooters do, then the IS won't add anything to the lens, however if you shoot in the rain or do a lot of walkabout macro work then the IS and sealing could be invaluable. Both make great portraiture lenses in any case if you don't mind stepping back - I've seen fantastic shots from the 7D 100L combo for portraiture, and both are about as good as c. 100mm macro lenses get in the EOS system
Click to expand...

That's why I said the part about money not being an issue :P If it's not an issue then you buy the better of the two options. The weather sealing and IS may not be necessary but they're definitely handy features to have :)
 
buzzlightweight said:
does anyone have any thoughts on the canon 60mm..... google reviews are giving it 4/5 stars?
Click to expand...

Wouldn't worry too much about the likes of google reviews when it comes to choosing a macro. Think more about what you want it for and the focal length required. Maybe you want more reach for insects on your plants so a longer lens might suffice. They're all going to be sharp regardless so again don't worry from that respect. If I was choosing I'd likely go for the 100mm non L.
 
Depends what you're shooting but people would generally use a 180mm/150mm lens of that's your main concern. On a crop, 100 is about good enough though
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom