MCU - general discussion thread

rp2000

rp2000

rp2000

Caporegime
Joined
11 Nov 2002
Posts
83,690
Location
Barcelona
I thought I would create this thread. I know each movie or TV show gets it's own one, but this is more a general one. Might help to keep the movie specific ones cleaner, might not!

Anyway, for starters, for people who have watched all, or most of the movies, I created my own ranking. Might create a 2nd post to include the Disney+ TV shows that begin in Phase 4. I tried to make it so it's easy to copy/reply and just change your ratings. YMMV.

Phase 1
8.5 Iron Man
7.5 The Incredible Hulk
7.0 Iron Man 2
7.5 Thor
7.5 Captain America: The First Avenger
8.5 The Avengers

Phase 2
7.5 Iron Man 3
6.0 Thor: The Dark World
8.5 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
8.0 Guardians of the Galaxy
8.5 Avengers: Age of Ultron
8.0 Ant-Man

Phase 3
9.0 Captain America: Civil War
8.0 Doctor Strange
7.0 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
8.0 Spider-Man: Homecoming
8.5 Thor: Ragnorak
8.0 Black Panther
9.0 Avengers: Infinity War
8.0 Ant-Man and the Wasp
8.5 Captain Marvel
9.0 Avengers: Endgame
8.5 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
7.0 Black Widow
8.5 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
6.0 Eternals
9.0 Spider-Man: No Way Home
7.5 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
6.5 Thor: Love and Thunder
Black Panther: Wakanda Forever


edit: I tried messing around with tables and other stuff, but failed. If anyone can make this into a tidy table with fixed widths or something that would be great.


rp2000
 
Last edited:
Phase 4 TV Shows

7.0 Wandavision
8.0 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
8.5 Loki
9.0 What If...?
8.5 Hawkeye
7.5 Moon Knight
8.0 Ms. Marvel
7.5 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
 
Last edited:
Phase 1
8.0 Iron Man
6.5 The Incredible Hulk
7.0 Iron Man 2
7.0 Thor
7.0 Captain America: The First Avenger
9.5 The Avengers

Phase 2
7.0 Iron Man 3
6.5 Thor: The Dark World
10.0 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
8.5 Guardians of the Galaxy
8.5 Avengers: Age of Ultron
8.0 Ant-Man

Phase 3
9.0 Captain America: Civil War
9.0 Doctor Strange
7.0 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
8.0 Spider-Man: Homecoming
8.5 Thor: Ragnorak
7.0 Black Panther
9.5 Avengers: Infinity War
8.0 Ant-Man and the Wasp
7.5 Captain Marvel (I really need to watch this one again actually)
9.0 Avengers: Endgame
8.5 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
7.0 Black Widow
8.5 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
7.0 Eternals
9.0 Spider-Man: No Way Home
7.5 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
6.0 Thor: Love and Thunder
7.5 Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

A few to explain, I think I generally like Dark World more than most people do, I don't think it's the worst MCU film and actually think it's probably level with the first Thor. Both Incredible Hulk and Black Widow I loved the first half of the film but the second half drops the score dramatically. I also kind of liked Eternals, I think most of the criticism was harsh. I do think it would have worked better as a tv show and the Deviants plot kind of fizzled out but I thought the cast was great and it's a beautiful film.

MCU TV Shows

9.0 Wandavision
6.5 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
9.0 Loki
7.5 What If...?
8.0 Hawkeye
8.5 Moon Knight
8.0 Ms. Marvel
7.5 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
 
Last edited:
Shamikebab said:
snip...

A few to explain, I think I generally like Dark World more than most people do, I don't think it's the worst MCU film and actually think it's probably level with the first Thor. Both Incredible Hulk and Black Widow I loved the first half of the film but the second half drops the score dramatically. I also kind of liked Eternals, I think most of the criticism was harsh. I do think it would have worked better as a tv show and the Deviants plot kind of fizzled out but I thought the cast was great and it's a beautiful film.

...snip
Click to expand...

Added Phase 4 TV shows now (copied your layout so thanks!).

I would give Dark World even less, if it wasn't for the London setting, which I'm a sucker for as a Londoner! Eternals, I can never see myself rewatching a 3rd time, I was generous in watching it twice hoping my opinion would improve, and it didn't, and the London scenes couldn't save it :D All big actors and very little substance or real links to the rest of the MCU. Cast salary was probably humongous!

My TV shows may change ratings. They are so new I have only watched them once apart from What If.... which i've watched twice already, Whereas every single film from Phase 2-4 I have watched at least 3 times if they are rated higher than 7.5.


rp2000
 
Last edited:
Finners said:
Non Agents of SHIELD TV show? I loved that!
Click to expand...
Hmmm... I must admit I have left out Agents of Shield, all 6 of Netflix shows, Inhumans. Runaways and anything else that wasn't on D+ originally! I believe all of these are no longer part of MCU anyway, unless i'm mistaken!


rp2000
 
Phase 1
8.0 Iron Man
6.0 The Incredible Hulk
4.0 Iron Man 2
6.0 Thor
8.0 Captain America: The First Avenger
9.0 The Avengers

Phase 2
5.0 Iron Man 3
6.0 Thor: The Dark World
8.5 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
8.5 Guardians of the Galaxy
7.0 Avengers: Age of Ultron
7.0 Ant-Man

Phase 3
8.5 Captain America: Civil War
7.0 Doctor Strange
5.0 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
7.5 Spider-Man: Homecoming
8.0 Thor: Ragnorak
6.0 Black Panther
9.5 Avengers: Infinity War
6.5 Ant-Man and the Wasp
7.5 Captain Marvel
6.0 Avengers: Endgame
8.0 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
6.0 Black Widow
8.0 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
6.0 Eternals
8.5 Spider-Man: No Way Home
6.0 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
3.0 Thor: Love and Thunder
Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

MCU TV Shows
9.0 Wandavision
6.0 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
8.5 Loki
7.0 What If...?
7.5 Hawkeye
8.5 Moon Knight
7.0 Ms. Marvel
7.0 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
 
Phase 1
Iron Man8.5
The Incredible Hulk6.0
Iron Man 27.5
Thor6.5
Captain America: The First Avenger8.0
The Avengers8.0

Phase 2
Iron Man 36.5
Thor: The Dark World6.0
Captain America: The Winter Soldier8.5
Guardians of the Galaxy8.0
Avengers: Age of Ultron7.0
Ant-Man7.5

Phase 3
Captain America: Civil War9.0
Doctor Strange8.0
Guardians of the Galaxy: Vol. 27.5
Spider-Man: Homecoming7.0
Thor: Ragnarok8.5
Black Panther6.5
Avengers: Infinity War9.9
Ant-Man and the Wasp6.5
Captain Marvel6.0
Avengers: End Game9.5
Spider-Man: Far from Home7.5

Phase 4
Black Widow6.0
Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings6.5
Eternals5.0
Spider-Man: No Way Home8.5
Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness7.5
Thor: Love and Thunder7.0
 
Last edited:
Finners said:
Non Agents of SHIELD TV show? I loved that!
Click to expand...

Unfortunately despite linking events to the MCU, Kevin Feige at the time said Agents wasnt part of the mcu and didnt acknowledge their existance despite having Cobie and Samuel making an appearance on it. Obviously as well Agent Colson.
 
Last edited:
For me, my scores is just based on my personal movie experience and my love for the content. So i may be more generous on some parts compared to your average movie goer.

Phase 1
8.5 Iron Man
7.5 The Incredible Hulk (Thought Edward Norton was a bit hard done imo)
7.0 Iron Man 2
7.5 Thor
7.0 Captain America: The First Avenger
9.0 The Avengers

Phase 2
6.0 Iron Man 3 (bit disappointing tbh)
6.5 Thor: The Dark World
9.0 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
8.5 Guardians of the Galaxy
7.0 Avengers: Age of Ultron (James Spader was excellent but overall a bit underwhelming)
8.0 Ant-Man

Phase 3
9.0 Captain America: Civil War
8.5 Doctor Strange
7.0 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
8.5 Spider-Man: Homecoming
9.0 Thor: Ragnorak
8.0 Black Panther
9.0 Avengers: Infinity War
8.0 Ant-Man and the Wasp
8.0 Captain Marvel
9.0 Avengers: Endgame
6.5 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
7.0 Black Widow
8.5 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings (Tony Leung is a legend, what an amazing Hollywood debut)
7.5 Eternals (i thought it wasnt as bad as most made out)
9.0 Spider-Man: No Way Home
6.5 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
5.5 Thor: Love and Thunder (Christine Bale was excellent but most of the movie got it totally wrong imo)

MCU TV Shows
7.0 Wandavision
6.5 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
7.0 Loki
6.5 What If...?
8.0 Hawkeye
8.5 Moon Knight
6.0 Ms. Marvel
7.0 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
 
Last edited:
Kyo said:
Unfortunately despite linking events to the MCU, Kevin Feige at the time said Agents wasnt part of the mcu and didnt acknowledge their existance despite having Cobie and Samuel making an appearance on it. Obviously as well Agent Colson.
Click to expand...
I just pretend it's multiverse shenanigans. SHIELD started off a bit hammy during season 1. Seasons 2-4 were amazing with a special mention to season 4. 5 was pretty good and would have been a good send off for the show. 6 was just okay. 7 was an abomination.
 
RobDogDog said:
I just pretend it's multiverse shenanigans. SHIELD started off a bit hammy during season 1. Seasons 2-4 were amazing with a special mention to season 4. 5 was pretty good and would have been a good send off for the show. 6 was just okay. 7 was an abomination.
Click to expand...

I know what you mean, they didnt think of the multiverse at the time and distance themselves when it wasnt fairing too well.
 
Phase 1
7.5 Iron Man
-.- The Incredible Hulk - Don't think I have seen it, no memory of it anyway
7.0 Iron Man 2
7.0 Thor
7.0 Captain America: The First Avenger
8.0 The Avengers

Phase 2
4.5 Iron Man 3
5.0 Thor: The Dark World
9.0 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
9.0 Guardians of the Galaxy
7.5 Avengers: Age of Ultron
8.0 Ant-Man

Phase 3
8.5 Captain America: Civil War
6.5 Doctor Strange
7.0 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
8.0 Spider-Man: Homecoming
8.0 Thor: Ragnorak
4.0 Black Panther
8.0 Avengers: Infinity War
7.5 Ant-Man and the Wasp
7.0 Captain Marvel
8.0 Avengers: Endgame
7.5 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
7.0 Black Widow
4.0 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
6.5 Eternals
7.5 Spider-Man: No Way Home
6.0 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
4.0 Thor: Love and Thunder

MCU TV Shows
7.5 Wandavision
6.5 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
8.0 Loki
-.- What If...? - Only watched the 1st one
8.0 Hawkeye
-.- Moon Knight - Watched 2 and a bit episodes
-.- Ms. Marvel - Never finished 1st episode
7.5 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
 
rp2000 said:
I thought I would create this thread. I know each movie or TV show gets it's own one, but this is more a general one. Might help to keep the movie specific ones cleaner, might not!

Anyway, for starters, for people who have watched all, or most of the movies, I created my own ranking. Might create a 2nd post to include the Disney+ TV shows that begin in Phase 4. I tried to make it so it's easy to copy/reply and just change your ratings. YMMV.

edit: I tried messing around with tables and other stuff, but failed. If anyone can make this into a tidy table with fixed widths or something that would be great.


rp2000
Click to expand...

You pretty much nailed the scores on the movies, we must have very similar taste, except for Black Panther which is a 6.5 for me, and Captain Marvel which is a 5 (SLJ saved it from being a 3 to be frank)
 
Phase 4 TV Shows

8.0 Wandavision
5.0 The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
7.5 Loki
7.0 What If...?
7.5 Hawkeye
9.0 Moon Knight (Loved this one!!)
6.0 Ms. Marvel
4.0 She-Hulk: Attorney at Law

Yeah the TV series has been a lot rougher for me with a few gems coming out
 
Last edited:
RobDogDog said:
I just pretend it's multiverse shenanigans. SHIELD started off a bit hammy during season 1. Seasons 2-4 were amazing with a special mention to season 4. 5 was pretty good and would have been a good send off for the show. 6 was just okay. 7 was an abomination.
Click to expand...
I have to be honest i only really stuck with it because i had an insane crush on the Chloe Bennet ;
maxresdefault.jpg
 
Last edited:
Phase 1
7.5 Iron Man
N/A The Incredible Hulk
5.0 Iron Man 2
6.0 Thor
7.0 Captain America: The First Avenger
6.5 The Avengers

Phase 2
N/A Iron Man 3
N/A Thor: The Dark World
6.5 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
8.0 Guardians of the Galaxy
4.5 Avengers: Age of Ultron
4.5 Ant-Man

Phase 3
6.5 Captain America: Civil War
7.0 Doctor Strange
7.5 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.2
7.0 Spider-Man: Homecoming
6.5 Thor: Ragnorak
6.5 Black Panther
8.5 Avengers: Infinity War
N/A Ant-Man and the Wasp
6.0 Captain Marvel
8.0 Avengers: Endgame
6.5 Spider-Man: Far From Home

Phase 4
N/A Black Widow
6.5 Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
N/A Eternals
7.0 Spider-Man: No Way Home
8.0 Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
6.5 Thor: Love and Thunder
N/A Black Panther: Wakanda Forever
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom